Grounds for dispensing with public tender procedures in Government Contracting
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2006/v9i2a2822Abstract
The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa1 provides that organs of state must comply with five principles when procuring goods or services: procurement procedures must be fair, equitable, transparent, competitive and cost-effective. In short, this means that organs of state should make use of competition when procuring goods or services. They should shop around and attract the maximum number of contractors who will participate in such competition. The aim should be the attainment of value for money, meaning, public money should be spent in an effective and efficient manner. Those who participate in competitions should also be treated fairly and without bias. In principle, no preferences should be afforded to different contractors; all contracting parties should have equal access to competition; some contractors should not be afforded more time for the preparation and submission of quotes or tenders than others; and the same information should be made available to all contracting parties. Government procurement procedures should further be transparent, meaning public or open. Thus, organs of state should not contract behind closed doors – government contracts should, as a rule, be advertised.
Depending on the nature and value of a particular contract, the use of a public call for tenders is generally the best way to ensure compliance with the
principles in the Constitution. By nature, a pubic call for tenders is open, it assists in the prevention of fraud and favouritism, and it ensures that the maximum number of contractors is approached to compete for a contract. Organs of state can also compare prices and quality and can contract with whoever offers the best deal. Most legislation therefore proceeds on the basis that procurement takes place by way of tendering. Generally, contracts above R200 000 are subject to public tender procedures.
In certain instances, however, a public call for tenders may be inappropriate regardless of the high value of the contract. For this reason, exceptions are provided for in legislation. Since tendering, however, is generally the best way to ensure compliance with all the principles in the Constitution, it is important for there to be sufficient guidance on the non-use of tender procedures. Proper guidance will, to a large extent, ensure uniformity and transparency in government procurement procedures which will, in turn, assist in the combating of corruption. In this article, attention is given to the legislation that provides for exceptions to the use of tendering at all three levels of government. Recommendations are then made as to how some of the legislative provisions should be interpreted in order to align them with the principles in the Constitution. In doing so, reference is made to a number of international instruments dealing with government procurement and specifically, the non-use of tender procedures.
Downloads
Metrics
References
Bibliography
Anon 2004 J of Public Procurement
Anonymous “Emergency procurement flexibilities: a framework for responsive contracting and guidelines for using simplified acquisition procedures” 2004 (4) Journal of Public Procurement 117-132
Arrowsmith 1998 ICLQ
Arrowsmith S “Towards a multilateral agreement on transparency in government procurement” 1998 (47) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 793-816
Arrowsmith Procurement and Judicial Review
Arrowsmith S Government Procurement and Judicial Review (Carswell Toronto 1988)
Arrowsmith Public and Utilities Procurement
Arrowsmith S The Law of Public and Utilities Procurement 2nd ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 2005)
Arrowsmith et al. Regulating Public Procurement
Arrowsmith SL, Linarelli J and Wallace D Jr Regulating Public
Procurement: National and International Perspectives (Kluwer Law
International London 2000)
Bolton 2006 Stell LR
Bolton P “Scope for negotiating and/or varying the terms of government contracts awarded by way of a tender process” 2006 (2) Stellenbosch Law Review (forthcoming)
Bolton Government Procurement
Bolton P The Legal Regulation of Government Procurement in South Africa (unpublished LLD thesis University of the Western Cape 2005)
Bright Public Procurement Handbook
Bright C Public Procurement Handbook (Wiley Chancery Law London 1994)
Brown 2005 PPLR
Brown A “Grounds for dispensing with competition under Works Directive
/97: a note on Case C-385/02 European Commission v Italy on Flood
Protection Works” 2005 (1) Public Procurement Law Review 5-7
Burton Legal Thesaurus
Burton WC Burton’s Legal Thesaurus 3rd ed (McGraw-Hill New York 1998)
Claassen Legal Words and Phrases
Claassen CJ Dictionary of Legal Words and Phrases Vol 2 E-M
(Butterworth Durban 1976)
Collins English Dictionary
Collins English Dictionary: Complete and Unabridged 6th ed
(HarperCollins Publishers Great Britain 2003)
Evenett and Hoekman Transparency
Evenett SJ and Hoekman BM “Transparency in Government Procurement:
What can we Expect from International Trade Agreements?” in Arrowsmith
S and Trybus M (eds) Public Procurement: The Continuing Revolution
(Kluwer Law International London 2003) 269-282
Goyder EC Competition Law
Goyder DG EC Competition Law 4th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)
Havenga et al Principles of Commercial Law
Havenga P et al. General Principles of Commercial Law 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2004)
Katayama 1968-1969 PCLJ
Katayama RN “Emergency procurement powers” (1968-1969) Public Contract Law Journal 236-264
Mkhize “No title”
Mkhize ZL (MEC for Finance and Economic Development) paper presented at the Supply Chain Management Conference: Transforming Government Procurement System (Durban South Africa 22-23 November 2004: on file with author)
Penfold and Reyburn Public Procurement
Penfold G and Reyburn P “Public Procurement” in Chaskalson et al (eds)
Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2003) 25-i to 25-36
Powell Cape Times 8 December 2005 1
Powell A “City project: Dexter to sue for „theft of idea‟” Cape Times 8 December 2005 1
Powell Cape Times 12 April 2006 1
Powell A “Another city tender scandal” Cape Times 12 April 2006 1
Powell Cape Times 13 April 2006 3
Powell A “Audit on cards as jewellery city figures „do not tally‟” Cape Times 13 April 2006 3
Powell Cape Times 11 April 2006 1, 3, 10
Powell A “Now tender boss defies city council” Cape Times 11 April 2006 1, 3, 10
Schwarts “Katrina‟s lessons"
Schwarts JI “Katrina‟s lessons for ongoing US procurement reform efforts” presented at the Public Procurement: Global Revolution III Conference, University of Nottingham United Kingdom 19-20 June 2006 (on file with author)
Trepte Public Procurement in the EC
Trepte P Public Procurement in the EC (CCH Europe 1993)
Turpin Government Procurement and Contracts
Turpin C Government Procurement and Contracts (Longman London 1989)
Register of statutes and legislative instruments
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Copyright Act 98 of 1978
Local Government Laws Amendment Act 51 of 2002
Local Government Transition Act 209 of 1993
Local Government: Municipal Finance Management Act 56 of 2003
Local Government: Municipal Finance Management Act 2003: Municipal Supply
Chain Management Regulations (Government Gazette No 27636 of 30 May 2005)
Local Government: Municipal Systems Act 32 of 2000
Local Government: Municipal Systems Amendment Act 44 of 2003
National Treasury: Regulations for Departments, Trading Entities,
Constitutional Institutions and Public Entities: Issued in terms of the Public
Finance Management Act 1999 (Government Gazette No 27388 of 15 March 2005)
Patents Act 57 of 1978
Polish Public Procurement Act 29 January 2004
Preferential Procurement Policy Framework Act 5 of 2000
Preferential Procurement Policy Framework Act 5 of 2000: Draft Preferential
Procurement Regulations (Government Gazette No 26863 of 4 October 2004)
Preferential Procurement Regulations (Government Gazette No 22549 of 10
August 2001)
Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999
Public Finance Management Amendment Act 29 of 1999
Trade Marks Act 194 of 1993
Register of government publications and official documents
Directive 2004/17/EC
Directive 2004/17/EC on coordinating the procurement procedures of entities operating in the water, energy, transport and postal services sectors – [2004] Official Journal of the European Union L 134/1
Directive 2004/18/EC
Directive 2004/18/EC on the coordination of procedures for the award of public works contracts, public supply contracts and public service contracts – [2004] Official Journal of the European Union L 134/114
Ministry of Finance and Public Works
Ministry of Finance and Public Works Green Paper on Public Sector
Procurement Reform in South Africa GG No 17928 of 14 April 1997
US FAR
United States Federal Acquisition Regulations
Register of cases
American Sterilizer Company 64 Comp Gen 868 (1985)
B-225400 December 12 1986
Case C-385/02 Commission of the European Communities v Italian Republic OJ C 323 of 21.12.2002
Case C-57/94 Commission of the European Communities v Italian Republic [1995] ECR I-01249
Comp Gen B-223914 (Oct 1986) (unpublished)
Council of Civil Service Unions and others v Minister for the Civil Service [1984] 3 All ER 935 (HL)
Design Pak Inc B-212, 579, 83-2 CPD 336
Design Pak Inc v Regan DC DC No 83-2628, 9/16/83
Essex Electro Engineers Inc B-250, 437, 93-1 CPD 74
Greenbier Industries Inc B-241304, 91-1 CPD 336
National Aerospace Group Inc B-282, 843, 99-2 CPD 43
Ngoasheng v Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2004 [JOL] 12953 (T)
Sabreliner Corp Comp Gen Dec B-288030 et al 2001 CPD 170
Scaccia v Borough of Old Forge 373 Pa 161, 163; 94 A.2d 563, 564 Pa (1953)
Register of Internet sources
Amos 2005 http://www.egovmonitor.com/ 12 May
Amos J 2005 Freedom of information and procurement [Found on internet] http://www.egovmonitor.com/node/180 [Date of use 12 May 2005)
Anon 2005 http://www.iafrica.com 14 Apr
Anonymous 2005 City defends Cape jewellery project 7 December 2005 [Found on internet] http://www.iafrica.com [Date of use 14 Apr 2006]
Anon 2005 http://www.DailyTenders.co.za 14 Apr
Anonymous 2005 Tender process in R6m Cape deal probed 6 December
[Found on internet] www.DailyTenders.co.za [Date of use 14 Apr 2006]
City of Cape Town http://www.capetown.gov.za 28 Oct
City of Cape Town Procurement Policy Initiative (September 2003) [Found on internet] http://www.capetown.gov.za/procurement/pdf/PolicyFinal%20ProcurementPolicy.pdf [Date of use 28 Oct 2005]
City of Cape Town http://www.capetown.gov.za/ 4 Apr
City of Cape Town Supply Chain Management Policy (September 2005)
[Found on internet] http://www.capetown.gov.za/policies/default.asp [Date of use 14 Apr 2006]
COED http://www.askoxford.com 25 Jan
Compact Oxford English Dictionary [Found on internet] www.askoxford.com [Date of use 25 Jan 2005]
Fontanot 2005 http://www.accountancysa.org.za/ 28 Oct Fontanot P 2005 Tender crimes [Found on internet] http://www.accountancysa.org.za/Archives/2005mar/features/01_crimes.ht m [Date of use 28 Oct 2005]
Madsen et al. 2002 http://mayerbrown.com/ 26 Jul
Madsen MG, Dowd DF and Farley MJ 2002 Combating terrorism: contracting approaches & lessons learned Briefing Papers [Found on internet] http://mayerbrown.com/publications/article.asp?id=173&nid=6 [Date of use 26 July 2006]
National Treasury http://www.treasury.go.za/ 14 Apr
National Treasury [no date] Overview of the Policy Strategy to Guide Uniformity in Procurement Reform Processes in Government: Promulgation of a Framework for Supply Chain Management (click “Supply Chain
Management”) [Found on internet] http://www.treasury.go.za/showpfma.htm [Date of use 14 Apr 2006]
National Treasury 2005 http://www.treasury.gov.za/ 14 Apr
National Treasury 2005 Supply Chain Management Office, Practice Note
Number SCM 2 of 2005 “Threshold Values for the Procurement of Goods and Services by means of Petty Cash, Verbal/Written Price Quotations and
Competitive Bids” (click: “Treasury Practice Notes”, “Supply Chain
Management Practice Notes”) [Found on internet] http://www.treasury.gov.za/showpfma.htm [Date of use 14 Apr 2006] OED http://www.oed.com/ 28 Oct
Oxford English Dictionary [Found on internet] http://www.oed.com/ [Date of use 28 Oct 2005]
Pool and Welch 2005 http://summitinsight.com/ 25 Jul
Pool C and Welch B 2005 Responding to Katrina: contracting in an emergency – version 2.0 [Found on internet] http://summitinsight.com/femakatrina.pdf [Date of use 25 Jul 2006]
UNCITRAL http://www.uncitral.org 28 Oct
United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Model Law on Procurement of Goods, Construction and Services 1994 [Found on internet] http://www.uncitral.org/english/texts/procurem/ml-procure.htm [Date of use Oct 2005]
WTO GPA http://www.wto.org 28 Oct
World Trade Organisation Government Procurement Agreement [Found on internet] http://www.wto.org [Date of use 28 Oct 2005]
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 P Bolton
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.