Some comments on the current (and future) status of Muslim personal law in South Africa

  • Christa Rautenbach North West University(Potchefstroom Campus)

Abstract

The state law of South Africa consists of the common law and the customary law. However, in reality there exist various cultural and religious communities who lead their private lives outside of state law. For example, the Muslim community in South Africa is a close-knit community which lives according to their own customs and usages. Muslims are subject to informal religious tribunals whose decisions and orders are neither recognised nor reviewable by the South African courts.

The non-recognition of certain aspects of Muslim personal law causes unnecessary hardships, especially for women. A Muslim woman is often in a "catch two" situation. For example, on the one hand her attempts to divorce her husband in terms of Muslim law may be foiled by the relevant religious tribunal and, on the other hand, the South African courts may not provide the necessary relief, because they might not recognise the validity of her Muslim marriage. 

Increasingly, South African courts are faced with complex issues regarding the Muslim community. The last few years there has been a definite change in the courts' attitude with regard to the recognition of certain aspects of Muslim personal law. Contrary to pre1994 court cases, the recent court cases attempt to develop the common law to give recognition to certain aspects of Muslim personal law. This article attempts to give an overview of the recent case law that dealt with issues regarding the recognition of aspects of Muslim personal law. 

Another issue, which eventuates from the current situation, is whether the South African legal order should continue to have a dualistic legal order or whether we should opt for a unified legal order or even a pluralistic legal order. In order to address this issue, some comments on the current status of Muslim personal law will be made and, finally, in order to contribute to the debate regarding the recognition of Muslim personal law, optional models for the recognition of Muslim personal law will briefly be evaluated.

    ScienceOpen_Log0495.png

References

Bibliography
Bonthuys 2000 SALJ
Bonthuys E "Obtaining a Get in Terms of Section 5A of the Divorce Act: Amar v Amar" 2000 SALJ 8-16
Barker 1998 DR
Barker H "New Hights in Religious Freedom" Jan 1998 DR 55-56
Cachalia Muslim Family Law
Cachalia F The Future of Muslim Family Law in South Africa (Centre for Applied Legal Studies University of the Witwatersrand Johannesburg 1991)
Faridi Islamic Personal Law
Faridi FR "Islamic Personal Law in India: Scope and Methodology of Reform" in
Mahmood T (ed) Islamic Law in Modern India (NM Tripathi Bombay 1972) 123127
Goolam 2001 Stell LR
Goolam N "Gender Equality in Islamic Family Law: Dispelling Common Misconceptions and Misunderstandings" 2001 Stell LR 199-214
Goolam and Rautenbach 2004 (2) Stell LR
Goolam N and Rautenbach C "The legal status of a Muslim wife under the Law of Succession: Is she still a hoar in terms of South African Law?" 2004 (2) Stell LR 369-380
Labuschagne 191 THRHR
Labuschagne JMT "Erkenning van die Inheemse Huwelik" 1991 THRHR 843846
Mahmood Statutes of Personal Law
Mahmood ST Statutes of Personal Law in Islamic Countries: History, Texts and
Analysis (India and Islam Research Council New Delhi 1995)
Mahomed 1997 DR
Mahomed A "Ryland v Edros [1996] 4 All SA 557 (C)" 1997 DR 189-190
Moosa Analysis
Moosa N An Analysis of the Human Rights and Gender Consequences of the New
South African Constitution and Bill of Rights (LLD thesis University of the Western Cape 1996)
Moosa Divorce
Moosa N "Divorce" in Rautenbach C and Goolam NMI (eds) Introduction to
Legal Pluralism in South Africa: Religious Legal Systems (Butterworths Durban 2002) 67-72
Moosa Shaping Muslim Law
Moosa E "Shaping Muslim Law in South Africa: Future and Prospects" in Schärf
W and Nina D (eds) The Other Law: Non-State Law in South Africa (Juta Landsdowne 2001) 121-147
Moosa 1995 Stell LR
Moosa N "Muslim personal Law: To Be or not to Be?" 1995 Stell LR 417-424
Poulter Separate Islamic System
Poulter S "The Claim to a Separate Islamic System of Personal Law for British Muslims" in Mallat C and Connors J (eds) Islamic Family Law (Graham & Trotman London 1990) 147-166
Rathnapaki Uniform Civil Code
Rathnapaki MS Uniform Civil Code: An Ignored Constitutional Imperative
(Atlantic Publishers and Distributors New Delhi 1997)
Rautenbach 2003 QUTLJJ
Rautenbach C "Gender Equality and Religious Family Laws in South Africa" 2003 (3:1) QUTLJJ 168-169
Rautenbach 2003 Koers
Rautenbach C "Islamic Marriages in South Africa: Quo Vadimus?" 2003 (69:1) Koers 136-140
Rautenbach and Du Plessis 2000 THRHR
Rautenbach C and Du Plessis W "The Extension of the Dependant's Action for
Loss of Support and the Recognition of Muslim Marriages: The Saga Continues" 2000 THRHR 302-314
Schärf and Nina (eds) The Other Law
Schärf W and Nina D (eds) The Other Law: Non-State Law in South Africa (Jutal Landsdowne 2001)
Sinclair Law of Marriage
Sinclair JD The Law of Marriage (Juta Kenwyn 1996)
SALC Review of the Marriage Act Discussion Paper 88
South African Law Reform Commission Project 109 Discussion Paper 88 on the Review of the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 (Pretoria 1999)
SALC Islamic Marriages and Related Matters Discussion Paper 101
South African Law Reform Commission Project 59 Discussion Paper 101 on Islamic Marriages and Related Matters (Pretoria 2001)
SALC Islamic Marriages and Related Matters Discussion Paper 93
South African Law Reform Commission Project 59 Discussion Paper 93 on Islamic Marriages and Related Matters (Pretoria 2000)
SALC Report on Islamic Marriages and Related Matters
South African Law Reform Commission Project 59 Report on Islamic Marriages and Related Matters (Pretoria 2003)
SALC Harmonisation of the Common Law and the Indigenous Law
South African Law Reform Commission Project 90 on the Harmonisation of the
Common Law and the Indigenous Law (Pretoria 1999)
Van Schalkwyk 2000 DJ
Van Schalkwyk LN "Amar v Amar 1999 3 SA 604 (W)" 2000 DJ 186-190

Register of court cases
Allen v Gibbs 1977 3 SA 212 (SE)
Amar v Amar 1999 3 SA 604 (W)
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accidents Fund (Commission for Gender Equality Intervening) 1999 4 SA 119 (SCA)
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accidents Fund 1998 4 SA 753 (CC)
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accident Fund 1997 12 BCLR 1716 (D)
Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha; Shibi v Sithole; South African Human Rights
Commission v President of the Republic of South Africa (to date unrep case no
CCT 49/03; CCT 69/03; CCT 50/03 delivered on 15 October 2004)
Bronn v Fritz Bronn's Executors (1860) 3 Searle 313
Daniels v Campbell 2003 9 BCLR 969 (C)
Daniels v Campbell 2004 7 BCLR 735 (CC)
Du Plessis v De Klerk 1996 5 BCLR 658 (CC)
Ismail v Ismail 1983 1 SA 1006 (A)
Langemaat v Minister of Safety and Security 1998 4 BCLR 444 (T)
Mohamed v Jassiem 1996 1 SA 673 (A)
Ryland v Edros 1997 2 SA 690 (C)
Ryland v Edros 1997 1 BCLR 77 (C)
Santam Bpk v Henery 1999 3 SA 421 (SCA)
Seedat's Executors v The Master (Natal) 1917 AD 302

Register of legislation
Black Laws Amendment Act 76 of 1963
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993
Divorce Act 70 of 1979
Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987
Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act 27 of 1990
Malaysian Islamic Family Law (Federal Territory) Act 1984
Marriage Act 25 of 1961
Marriage Act, Extension Act 50 of 1997
Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act 26 of 1937
Promotion and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998
South African Law Reform Commission Act 19 of 1973

Register of Internet resources
Gabru 2004 PER http://www.puk.ac.za/law/per/ 1 Des
Gabru N "Dilemma of Muslim Women Regarding Divorce in South Africa" 2004
(2) PER [Found on Internet] http://www.puk.ac.za/law/per [Date of use 1 December 2004]
Rautenbach, Jansen van Rensburg and Pienaar 2003 PER http://www.puk.ac.za/law/per 1 Nov
Rautenbach C, Jansen van Rensburg F and Pienaar GJ "Culture (and religion) in constitutional adjudication" 2003 PER [Found on Internet] http://www.puk.ac.za/law/per [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
SALC Collation of Submissions http://wwwserver.law.wits.ac.za/salc/discussn/collationdp101.doc 1 Nov
South African Law Reform Commission Collation of Submissions on Discussion Paper 101: Islamic and Related Matters [Found on Internet] http://wwwserver.law.wits.ac.za/salc/discussn/collationdp101.doc [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
SALC Islamic Marriages and Related Matters (Issue Paper 15) http://www.law.wits.ac.za/salc/issue/ip15.pdf 1 Nov
South African Law Reform Commission Islamic Marriages and Related Matters
(Issue paper 15: Project 59 May 2000) [Found on Internet] http://www.law.wits.ac.za/salc/issue/ip15.pdf [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
SALC Islamic Marriages and Related Matters (Discussion Paper 101) http://wwwserver.law.wits.ac.za/salc/discussn/discussn.html 1 Nov
South African Law Reform Commission Islamic Marriages and Related Matters
(Discussion Paper 101) [Found on Internet]
http://wwwserver.law.wits.ac.za/salc/discussn/discussn.html [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
SALC Responses http://www.law.wits.ac.za/salc/issue/issue.html 1 Nov South African Law Reform Commission Responses and the names of the
respondents to Issue Paper 15 [Found on Internet] http://www.law.wits.ac.za/salc/issue/issue.html [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
SouthAfrica.info http://www.wouthafrica.info/women/islamicmarriages.htm 1 Nov
SouthAfrica.info Recognition for Islamic Marriages 1 Aug 2003 [Found on Interenet] http://www.wouthafrica.info/women/islamicmarriages.htm [Date of use 1 Nov 2004]
Views
  • Abstract 334
  • PDF 244
  • XML 0
  • epub 30
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-07-10
Section
Contribution