Muslim personal law and the meaning of "law" in the South African and Indian constitutions

  • Christa Rautenbach North West University(Potchefstroom Campus)

Abstract

The Muslim population of South Africa follows a practice which may be referred to as

Muslim personal law. Although section 15 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 108 of 1996 recognises religious freedom and makes provision for the future recognition of other personal law systems, Muslim personal law is, at this stage, not formally recognised in terms of South African law. Since Muslim personal law receives no constitutional recognition the question may be asked whether the 1996 Constitution, and in particular the Bill of Rights as contained in chapter 2 of the 1996 Constitution, is applicable to "non-recognised" Muslim personal law. The answer to this question depends to a large extent on the meaning of "law" as contained in the 1996 Constitution.

When the viewpoint of academic writers and the courts are evaluated it seems as if the meaning of law in South Africa is restricted to the common law, customary law and legislation. If such a viewpoint is to be followed, Muslim personal law is excluded from the scrutiny of the Bill of Rights. It is, however, inconceivable that there might be certain areas of "law" that are not subject to the scrutiny of the Bill of Rights. In this note it will be argued that Muslim personal law should be regarded as law in terms of the 1996 Constitution, or in the alternative, that Muslim personal law (or at least Muslim marriages) should be recognised in terms of section 15 of the 1996 Constitution.

Due to the historical resemblance between South Africa and India the meaning of

"law" as contained in the 1996 Constitution will be compared with the meaning of "law" as contained in the Constitution of India. Although the Constitution of India indirectly gives recognition to various personal laws in India, these personal laws are not subject to the provisions of the Constitution of India. Therefore, it would be argued that one should approach the Constitution of India with caution when its provisions are compared to those of the 1996 Constitution of South Africa.

    ScienceOpen_Log0531.png

References

Bibliography
Bakshi Constitution of India 304-305
Bakshi PM The Constitution of India (Universal Delhi1999)
Basu Constitutional Law of India 440
Basu DD Constitutional Law of India 6th ed (Prentice-Hall of India New Delhi1991)
Bhattacharjee Muslim Law and the Constitution 53-57
Bhattacharjee AM Muslim Law and the Constitution (Eastern Law House Calcutta 1994)
Boulle Harris and Hoexter Constitutional and Administrative Law 117
Boulle L, Harris B and Hoexter C Constitutional and Administrative Law: Basic Principles (Juta Cape Town 1989)
Burns Administrative Law 15 Burns Y Administrative Law under the 1996 Constitution (Butterworths Durban 1998)
Central Statistical Services Report 03/01/22 (91) Population Census 1991
De Reede 1996 Tilburg Foreign Law Review 145
De Reede J "The Muslims in India" 1996 Tilburg Foreign Law Review 145¬170
De Waal Currie and Erasmus Bill of Rights Handbook 50
De Waal J Currie I and Erasmus G The Bill of Rights Handbook 2nd ed (Juta Kenwyn 1999)
Diwan Family Law 2-3
Diwan P Family Law (Allahabad Law Agency Allahabad 1991)
Ghouse Personal laws 57
Ghouse M "Personal laws and the Constitution in India" in Mahmood T (ed) Islamic Law in Modern India (NM Tripathi Bombay 1972) 50-58
Jain Judicial system 134-135
Jain SN "Judicial system and legal remedies" in Minattur J (ed) The Indian Legal System (Oceana Publications New York 1978) 133-147
Mahmood Muslim Personal Law 87
Mahmood T Muslim Personal Law 2nd ed (AIR Nagpur 1988)
Mahmood Personal Laws in a Crisis 14-15
Mahmood T Personal Laws in a Crisis (Metropolitan New Delhi 1986)
Mahmood Statute-Law 10-12
Mahmood T Statute-Law relating to Muslims in India (Institute of Objective Studies New Delhi 1995)
Moosa Muslim Personal Law 35
Moosa N An Analysis of the Human Rights and Gender Consequences of the New South African Constitution and Bill of Rights with regard to the Recognition and Implementation of Muslim Personal Law (LLM-thesis University of the Western Cape 1996)
Moosa 1995 StellLR 417-424
Moosa N "Muslim personal law: to be or not to be?" 1995 StellLR 417-424
Neethling Potgieter and Visser Law of Delict 283
Neethling J, Potgieter JM and Visser PJ Law of Delict 3rd ed (Butterworths Durban 1999)

Pearl Interpersonal Conflict of Laws in India 27-34
Pearl D Interpersonal Conflict of Laws in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh (Stevens & Sons London 1981)
Rautenbach "Recognition of Muslim marriages" 21 et seq
Rautenbach C "The recognition of Muslim marriages in South Africa: past, present and future" Paper delivered at the 17th RIMO-symposium 18 June 1999 Leyden 21 et seq -to be published
Rautenbach and Malherbe Staatsreg 306
Rautenbach IM and Malherbe EFJ Staatsreg 2nd rev ed (Butterworths Durban 1996)
Seervai Constitutional Law of India 401-403
Seervai HM Constitutional Law of India: A Critical Commentary (NM Tripathi Bombay 1983)
Van Zyl and Van der Vyver Inleiding tot die Regswetenskap
Van Zyl FJ and Van der Vyver JD Inleiding tot die Regswetenskap 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1982)
Cases
Ali v Sufaira 1988 2 KLT 94
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accident Fund 1997 12 BCLR 1716 (D)
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accident Fund case no 444/98 of 29.11.99
Charanjit Lal v Union of India AIR 1951 SC 41
Du Plessis v De Klerk 1996 5 BCLR 658 (CC) 682
Keshavan Madhava Menon v State of Bombay AIR 1951 SC 128
Krishna Singh v Mathura Ahir AIR 1980 SC 707
Park-Ross v Director, Office for Serious Economic Offences 1995 1 SACR 530 (C)
Ryland v Edros 1997 1 BCLR 77 (C)
Srinivasa Aiyar v Saraswathi Ammal AIR 1952 Mad 193
The State of Bombay v Narasu Appa Mali AIR 1952 Bom 84
Acts
Births and Deaths Registration Act 51 of 1992
Bombay Prevention of Hindu Bigamous Marriages Act 25 of 1946
Constitution of India
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 108 of 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993
Demobilisation Act 99 of 1996 Insolvency Act 24 of 1936
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998
Special Pensions Act 69 of 1996
Internet
The Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa 1999 Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accident Fund case no 444/98 of 29/11/99 [Gevind op Internet] http://www.law.wits.ac.za/sca/scadate.html [Datum van gebruik Christa 1999]
Views
  • Abstract 586
  • PDF 200
  • XML 0
  • epub 10
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-07-10
Section
Contribution