Johannes Althusius' Grand Federalism, the Role of the Ephors and Post-Statist Constitutionalism
Keywords:Statist paradigm, State-departmentalisation, Republican federalism, Ephors, Family, Collegia, Cities, Provinces, Commonwealth or realm, Diffuse sovereignty, Communitarian constitutionalism
This article discusses the primary structures Johannes Althusius’ constitutionalism, as explained in his Politica: Politics Methodically Set Forth and Illustrated with Sacred and Profane Examples published in 1603. The first of these structures and the theme that Althusius is most famous for, is his scheme of grand republican federalism. The second is the public office of the ephors. The discussion is not primarily historical, however. The main aim, instead, is to assess the potential relevance of Althusius’ thinking for present-day constitutionalism. After centuries of at best scant relevance owing to the dominance of the statist paradigm in constitutional doctrine and practice, the decline of this paradigm is now creating considerable new interest in Althusius’ thinking.
The discussion starts off with a concise account of the statist paradigm, which was at its advent in Althusius’ days. Thereafter follows an exposition of his federalism which consists of a set of associations, beginning with the closest-knit association, namely the family, spiralling out into the most encompassing association, which is the commonwealth or realm, with collegia, cities and provinces in between. The office of the supreme magistrate is dealt with under this heading. This discussion also focusses pertinently on the question of sovereignty, which in Althusian conceptualisation was a diffuse popular sovereignty in contrast to that of his statist opponents, more specifically Jean Bodin, and in posterity, Thomas Hobbes.
Then follows an assessment of the public office of the (council of the) ephors, which assists the supreme magistrate in executing his responsibilities in accordance with the law and the covenant between the commonwealth and the magistrate and serves a as counterbalance of authority and power against the sovereign.
Against this backdrop Althusius’ constitutional thinking is evaluated. First, his constitutionalism is placed in historical context in contrast to (1) classical polis-based thought; (2) medieval imperial thinking and (3) modern statist constitutionalism. Secondly, Althusius’ communitarian anthropology, which is in part the basis for his federalism, and which constitutes an anticipatory response to liberal individualism is assessed. Lastly it is argued that Althusius’ federalism provides a valuable source for improving on the state-departmentalisation of power separation and checks and balances, currently still sway in terms of the statist paradigm.
Althusius J Politica: Politics Methodically Set Forth and Illustrated with Sacred and Profane Examples (an abridged and translated version edited and translated from Latin by FS Carney) (Liberty Fund Indianapolis 1994)
Aristotle The Politics
Aristotle The Politics (translated from Greek by TA Sinclair) (Penguin Middlesex 1962)
Barnard Herder's Social and Political Thought
Barnard FM Herder's Social and Political Thought from Enlightenment to Nationalism (Clarendon Press London 1965)
Berman Law and Revolution
Berman HJ Law and Revolution: The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition (Harvard University Press Massachusetts 1983)
Burke E Reflections on the Revolution in France (Penguin Middlesex 1968)
Cable 1995 Daedalus
Cable V "The Diminished Nation State: A Study in the Loss of Economic Power" 1995 Daedalus 23-54
Carlyle History of Medieval Political Theory
Carlyle AJ A History of Medieval Political Theory in the West Vol III; Vol VI (Blankwood London 1928)
Carney "Translators Introduction"
Carney FS "Translators Introduction" in Althusius J Politica: Politics Methodically Set Forth and Illustrated with Sacred and Profane Examples (an abridged and translated version edited and translated from Latin by FS Carney) (Liberty Fund Indianapolis 1994) ix-xxxiii
Casey Freedom's Progress?
Casey R Freedom's Progress? A History of Political Thought from the Perspective of Liberty (Imprint Academic Exeter 2017)
Choudhry 2009 CCR
Choudhry S "'He had a Mandate': The South African Constitutional Court and the African National Congress in a Dominant Party Democracy" 2009 CCR 1-86
De Benoist 2000 Telos
De Benoist A "The First Federalist: Johannes Althusius" 2000 Telos 25-58
De Tocqueville Ancient Regime
De Tocqueville A The Ancient Regime and the Revolution (Penguin London 2008)
Diamond "Rule of Law"
Diamond S "The Rule of Law versus the Order of Custom" in Wolff RP (ed) The Rule of Law (Simon and Schuster New York1971) 115-144
Elazar "Althusius's Grand Design"
Elazar DL "Althusius's Grand Design for a Federal Commonwealth" in Althusius J Politica: Politics Methodically Set Forth and Illustrated with Sacred and Profane Examples (an abridged and translated version edited and translated from Latin by FS Carney) (Liberty Fund Indianapolis 1994) xxxv-xlvi
Friedrich Man and his Government
Friedrich CJ Man and his Government: An Empirical Theory of Politics (McGraw-Hill New York 1963)
Giliomee, Myburgh and Schlemmer 2001 Democratization
Giliomee H, Myburgh J and Schlemmer L "Dominant Party Rule, Opposition Parties and Minorities in South Africa" 2001 Democratization 161-182
Hueglin Early Modern Concepts
Hueglin TO Early Modern Concepts for a Late Modern World – Althusius on Community and Federalism (Wilfred Laurier University Press Waterloo, Ontario 1999)
Locke Of Civil Government
Locke J Of Civil Government: The Second Treatise (Wildside Rockville 2008)
Malan K Politocracy: An Assessment of the Coercive Logic of the Territorial State and Ideas around an Answer to It (Pretoria University Law Press Pretoria 2012)
Malan 2014 De Jure
Malan K "The Suitability and Unsuitability of Ubuntu in Constitutional Law – Inter-communal Relations versus Public Office-bearing" 2014 De Jure 231-257
Malan 2014 PELJ
Malan K "Reassessing of Judicial Independence and Impartiality against the Backdrop of Judicial Appointments in South Africa" 2014(17)5 PELJ 1965-2040, available at http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v17i5.05
Malan 2014 Tydskr Geesteswet
Malan K "Taalverval met Besondere Verwysing na die Ideologieë en Praktyke van Verstaatliking″ 2014 Tydskr Geesteswet 462-480
Malan 2015 THRHR
Malan K "Die Dinamika van die Hedendaagse Oppermagtige Grondwet Beskou in die Lig van Voor- en Vroeg-Moderne Opvattings oor Regsoppergesag en Populêre Soewereiniteit" 2015 THRHR 248-266
Malan 2017 PELJ
Malan K "The Foundational Tenets of Johannes Althusius' Constitutionalism" 2017(20) PELJ http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2017/v20i0a1344
McRae 1979 CJPS
McRae K "The Plural Society and the Western Political Tradition" 1979 CJPS 575-688
Nisbet Quest for Community
Nisbet R The Quest for Community: A Study in the Ethics of Order and Freedom (ICS Press San Francisco 1990)
Pennington Seventeenth Century Europe
Pennington DH Seventeenth Century Europe (Longman London 1970)
Pestieau 1991 Can J Law Jurisprud
Pestieau J "Minority Rights: Caught between Individual Rights and Peoples' Rights" 1991 Can J Law Jurisprud 361-373
Sabine History of Political Theory
Sabine GH A History of Political Theory (Harrap London 1971)
Sartori Democratic Theory
Sartori G Democratic Theory (Wayne State University Press Detroit 1962)
Skinner "The State"
Skinner Q "The State" in Ball T et al (eds) Political Innovation and Conceptual Change (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1989) 90-131
Southall 2005 Africa Spectrum
Southall R "The 'Dominant Party Debate' in South Africa" 2005 Africa Spectrum 61-82
Strange 1995 Daedalus
Strange S "The Defective State" 1995 Daedalus 55-74
Van Dyke 1974 Am J Pol Sci
Van Dyke V "Human Rights and the Rights of Groups" 1974 Am J Pol Sci 725-741
Van Dyke 1976-77 World Politics
Van Dyke V "The Individual the State and Ethnic Communities in Political Theory" 1976-77 World Politics 343-369
How to Cite