Recalibrating Everyday Space: Using Section 24 of the South African Constitution to Resolve Contestation in the Urban and Spatial Environment

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2021/v24i0a9432

Keywords:

Law and urban space, The right to an environment, Right to Freedom of Movement, Right to Safety and Security of the Person, Law and urban planning

Abstract

Positioned as existing predominantly within a green agenda, the right to an environment (section 24 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996) presents numerous opportunities for rights-based interpretation in the "brown" urban and spatial environment. In this article I conduct such an exercise, focussing on both the right to freedom of movement (section 21 of the Constitution) and the right to the safety and security of the person (section 12 of the Constitution). I begin by drawing out the historical and contemporary spatial implications of both rights, drawing on empirical research that demonstrates how the enclosure of everyday space through gating practices and private securitisation in the South African city serves to extend spatial apartheid into the current day. A siloed interpretation of both rights, however, leads to an impasse between the two. Both rights are prima facie of an equal value in a constitutional setting.

To resolve this standoff, I argue for the use of the environmental right as a constitutional value. This is an underutilised right in the South African Constitution, and yet it holds much promise given how it seeks to protect the health and wellbeing of both present and future generations.

There are two benefits to employing the environmental right as a constitutional value. First, the environmental right situates both section 12 and section 21 in a symbiosis of individual claims to shared resources, in the process recalibrating the human ecology of the urban and spatial environment away from the centrality of dominant actors and towards a polycentricity of interests. In so doing, section 24 provides a fuller and more connected picture of both rights.

Second, the duty implicit in the environmental right reveals how to begin realising these rights on a wider scale that goes beyond individual injustices and towards community justice. I argue strongly that this duty exists on the state: left unattended to, everyday space becomes the preserve of those with the means – financial or otherwise – to shape space according to their own anti-public interests. In this regard, I present two instances of policy and legal choices available to the state that serve to undo contemporary experiences of spatial apartheid

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Bibliography

Literature

Applebaum A Contestation, Transformation and Competing Visions: A Study of Orange Grove and Norwood (University of the Witwatersrand Johannesburg 2017)

Baudelaire C The Painter of Modern Life (Mayne J ed & trans) (Phaidon New York City 1863)

Bénit-Gbaffou G "Police-Community Partnerships and Responses to Crime: Lessons from Yeoville and Observatory, Johannesburg" 2006 Urban Forum 301-325

Budlender J and Royston L Edged Out: Spatial Mismatch and Spatial Justice in South Africa's Main Urban Areas (SERI Johannesburg 2016)

Clarno A and Murray M "Policing in Johannesburg After Apartheid" 2013 Social Dynamics: A Journal of African Studies 210-227

Cooper-Knock S-J "Behind Closed Gates: Everyday Policing in Durban, South Africa" 2016 Africa 98-121

Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 6th ed (Juta Cape Town 2017)

Dirsuweit T "Johannesburg: A Fearful City?" 2002 Urban Forum 3-19

Dirsuweit T "Public Space and the Politics of Propinquity in Johannesburg" in Farber L (ed) Representation and Spatial Practices in Urban South Africa (The Visual Identities in Art and Design Research Centre Johannesburg 2008) 51-58

Dirsuweit T and Wafer A "Scale, Governance and the Maintenance of Privileged Control: The Case of Road Closures in Johannesburg's Northern Suburbs" 2006 Urban Forum 327-352

Du Plessis AA "South Africa's Constitutional Environmental Right (Generously) Interpreted: What Is in It for Poverty?" 2011 SAJHR 279-307

Du Plessis AA "The 'Brown' Environmental Agenda and the Constitutional Duties of Local Government in South Africa: A Conceptual Introduction" 2015 PELJ 1846-1880

Durrington M "Race, Space and Place in Suburban Durban: An Ethnographic Assessment of Gated Community Environments and Residents" 2006 GeoJournal 147-160

Harrison P et al "Corridors of Freedom: Analyzing Johannesburg's Ambitious Inclusionary Transit-Oriented Development" 2019 JPER 456-468

Harvey D Rebel Cities (Verso London 2012)

Hohfeld WN "Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning, Part I" in Cook WW (ed) Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning and Other Legal Essays by Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld (Yale University Press New Haven CT 1964) 23-64

Hook D and Vrdoljak M "Gated Communities, Heterotopia and a 'Rights' of Privilege: A Heterotopology of the South African Security-Park" 2002 Geoforum 195-219

Haysom N "Dignity" in Cheadle H, Davis D and Haysom N (eds) South African Constitutional Law: The Bill of Rights (LexisNexis Johannesburg 2002) ch 5

Kepe T, McGregor G and Irvine P "Rights of 'Passage' and Contested Land Use: Gendered Conflict Over Urban Space During Ritual Performance in South Africa" 2015 Applied Geography 91-99

Kynoch G "Fear and Alienation: Narratives of Crime and Race in Post-Apartheid South Africa" 2014 Canadian Journal of African Studies / Revenue Canadienne des Études Africaines 427-441

Landman K Gated Communities in South Africa: Comparison of Four Case Studies in Gauteng (CSIR Pretoria 2004)

Lemanski C "Residential Responses to Fear (of Crime Plus) in Two Cape Town Suburbs: Implications for the Post-Apartheid City" 2006 Journal of International Development 787-802

Lemanski C and Oldfield S "The Parallel Claims of Gated Communities and Land Invasions in a Southern City: Polarised State Responses" 2009 Environment and Planning 634-648

Lemanski C, Landman K and Durington M "Divergent and Similar Experiences of 'Gating' in South Africa: Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town" 2008 Urban Forum 133-158

Madlalate R "Dismantling Apartheid Geography: Transformation and the Limits of Law" 2019 CCR 195-217

Moore M A Political Theory of Territory (Oxford University Press Oxford 2015)

Pieterse M "The Right to the City and the Urban Environment: Re-Imagining Section 24 of the 1996 Constitution" 2014 SAPL 175-193

Ramoroka T and Tsheola J "Gated-Communities and the Privatization of Public Spaces in Urban South Africa: Democratic Social Integration or Exclusion?" 2016 JGRP 58-68

Stavrides S Common Space: The City as Commons (Zed Books London 2016)

Tandogan O and Ilhan BS "Fear of Crime in Public Spaces: From the View of Women Living in Cities" 2016 Procedia Engineering 2011-2018

Van der Berg A Municipal Planning Law and Policy for Sustainable Cities in South Africa (PhD-dissertation Tilburg University 2019)

Young IM Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press Princeton NJ 1990)

Case law

F v Minister of Safety and Security 2012 1 SA 536 (CC)

Loureiro v iMvula Quality Protection (Pty) Ltd 2014 3 SA 394 (CC)

Mazibuko v City of Johannesburg 2010 4 SA 1 (CC)

Legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Natives (Abolition of Passes and Co-Ordination of Documents) Act 67 of 1952

Natives (Urban Areas) Consolidation Act 25 of 1942

Private Security Industry Regulation Act 56 of 2001

Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Act 16 of 2013

Government publications

GN 305 in GG 24971 of 28 February 2003

Internet sources

Anonymous 2019 Amy-Leigh's Missing Kids Facebook Page https://bit.ly/2lZHJbc accessed 26 November 2019

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform 2017 Land Audit Report: Phase II: Private Land Ownership by Race, Gender and Nationality https://bit.ly/3sCmERF accessed 14 January 2021

Gasa N 2016 Nomboniso Gase Facebook Post https://bit.ly/3slJJrw accessed 19 November 2019

Human L 2020 Rondebosch Golf Club Lease Renewal Under Fire from Housing Activists https://bit.ly/3sEhd4E accessed 14 January 2021

Igual R 2021 Queer Individual Andile Ntuthela Butchered and Burned in Uitenhage https://bit.ly/3tBvG16 accessed 16 April 2021

South African Human Rights Commission 2004 Road Closures / Boom Gates Report https://bit.ly/3dza2VM accessed 21 April 2021

Statistics South Africa 2020 Statistical Release: Governance, Public Safety, and Justice Survey 2019/20 https://bit.ly/2XZF0hn accessed 20 January 2021

Statistics South Africa 2020 Mid-Year Population Estimates 2020 https://bit.ly/3bRJFKk accessed 14 January 2021

Published

2021-07-22

How to Cite

Coggin, T. (2021). Recalibrating Everyday Space: Using Section 24 of the South African Constitution to Resolve Contestation in the Urban and Spatial Environment: . Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 24, 1–31. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2021/v24i0a9432

Issue

Section

SARChi CLES Series on Cities, Law and Environmental Sustainability