The Need for Monitoring and Assessment of Legal Aid Quality in South Africa

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2022/v25i0a13182

Keywords:

Legal aid, South Africa, monitoring, assessment, quality, quality measures, pro bono

Abstract

Legal aid is needed in South Africa as one mechanism for poor South Africans to realise their legal rights and to use the law as a vehicle for positive social change in a grossly unequal society in which deep poverty is rife. However, simply having a legal aid service provider is insufficient if the quality of such services is not satisfactory. But how can high quality legal services be ensured? This paper considers how different forms of legal aid service provision can be effectively monitored and assessed to ensure that satisfactory standards of legal aid work are delivered. Categories of "legal aid" (broadly construed) which are considered are legal NGOs, including university law clinics, the state's Legal Aid South Africa telephonic advice, and pro bono work by private lawyers. Separate research has focussed on the need for much improved coordination between legal service providers to promote co-operation among legal aid services. The next step is to ensure that such coordination leads to quality services and promoting quality control mechanisms which are appropriate and which can be considered best practice. This paper analyses and discusses this next step. If legal aid is not of an adequate standard or quality assurance is not in place, the legal aid is not serving a positive function. The paper considers viable means for vetting the quality of these free legal services in a South African context, including telephonic legal advice in the Covid era. It suggests mechanisms to promote high-level free legal service provision by assessing the quality of such services. Legal aid quality control methods abroad were analysed to serve as an indicator of the options used in this regard in those jurisdictions. The question to be answered is what quality control measures are most apposite in the South African legal aid arena.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

  • Dave Holness, University of KwaZulu-Natal

    Director of UKZN Law Clinic. University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

References

Bibliography

Literature

Bhabha F "Institutionalizing Access-to-Justice: Judicial, Legislative and Grassroots Dimensions" 2007-2008 Queen's LJ 139-149

Holness D "Recent Developments in the Provision of Pro Bono Legal Services by Attorneys in South Africa" 2013 PELJ 129-164 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v16i1.5

Holness D "The Need for Recognition and Regulation of Paralegals: an Analysis of the Roles, Training, Remuneration and Impact of Community Based Paralegals in South Africa" 2013 Journal of Juridical Science 78-105

Holness D Coordinating Free Legal Services in Civil Matters for Indigent People in eThekwini: A Model for Improved Access to Justice (LLD-thesis Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University 2015)

Holness D "Improving Access to Justice through Law Graduate Post-Study Community Service in South Africa" 2020 PELJ 1-24 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2020/v23i0a5968

Holness "Promoting the Quality of Legal Aid in South Africa through Better Co-ordination of Service Provision" 2021 LDD 1-23 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/2077-4907/2021/ldd.v25.1

Maphumulo M "Lockdown Increases Possibility of Professional Negligence Claims Against Lawyers" 2020 Without Prejudice 35

Ogilvy JP "Guidelines for the Self Evaluation of Legal Education Clinics and Clinical Programs" 2014 TM Cooley Journal of Practical & Clinical Law 1-173

South African University Law Clinic Association 2021 Workshop: 2021 Questionnaire to University Law Clinics On file with author

International Instruments

Principles and Guidelines on the Right to Fair Trial and Legal Assistance in Africa ACHPR Doc DOC/OS(XXX)247 (2003)

Human Rights Committee Concluding Observations on the Initial Report of South Africa UN Doc CCPR/C/ZAF/CO/1 (2016)

United Nations Principles and Guidelines on Access to Legal Aid in Criminal Justice Systems UN Doc A/RES/67/187 (2012)

Legislation

Legal Practice Act 28 of 2014

Internet sources

Aung KK and Kamiko A 2019 A Study on Quality Assurance for Criminal Legal Aid Systems in Common Law Jurisdictions https://ritsumei.repo.nii.ac.jp/?action=repository_action_common_download&item_id=5285&item_no=1&attribute_id=22&file_no=1 accessed 19 October 2021

Barendrecht M and van den Biggelaar P 2009 Sustainable Legal Aid and Access to Justice: A Supply Chain Approach https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1387716 accessed 4 November 2014 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1387716

Black Sash date unknown About http://www.blacksash.org.za/ accessed 18 October 2021

Brickhill J 2020 Constitutional Implications of COVID-19: Access to Justice and the Functioning of the Courts During Lockdown https://juta.co.za/press-room/2020/05/10/constitutional-implications-covid-19-access-justice-and-functioning-courts-during-lockdown-issue-8/ accessed 15 December 2021

Council of Europe 2016 Assessment of the Free Secondary Legal Aid System in Ukraine in the Light of Council of Europe Standards and Best Practices https://rm.coe.int/16806ff4a8 accessed 17 October 2021

Currie A 2001 The Emergence of Unmet Needs as an Issue in Canadian Legal Aid Policy Research http://216.92.68.58/conference/ilag2001.htm accessed 19 December 2014

Donovan B 2012 "Paralegals Support the Justice System as a Whole": An Interview with Nomboniso Nangu Maqubela https://namati.org/news-stories/paralegals-support-the-justice-system-as-a-whole/ accessed 15 October 2021

HiiL 2017 Justice Needs and Satisfaction in Kenya: Legal Problems in Daily Life https://www.hiil.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/hiil-report_Kenya-JNS-web.pdf accessed 16 October 2021

Holness D 2017 Access to Justice in South Africa https://globalaccesstojustice.com/files/national_reports/national-report-south-africa.pdf accessed 14 October 2021

International Commission of Jurists, Kenyan Section et al 2020 Statement to the 67th Ordinary Session of the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights https://namati.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/ACHPR-statement.docx.pdf accessed 1 December 2021

International Legal Aid Group date unknown Home http://ilagnet.org/index.php/en/201309-24-22-3634.html?highlight=Wy

JwYXRlcnNvbiJd accessed 5 October 2014

Kádár A 2007 The Legal Aid Reform in Hungary http://www.ua.ac.be/main.aspx?c=.ILAG2007&n=39311 accessed 24 October 2014

Legal Aid South Africa date unknown Home https://legal-aid.co.za/legalaidsa/ accessed 23 August 2021

Legal Aid South Africa 2017 Country Report for ILAG http://www.internationallegalaidgroup.org/images/miscdocs/SA_Country_report_-April_2017.pdf accessed 15 September 2021

Legal Aid South Africa 2020 Guidelines on Measures to Deal with the Covid-19 Pandemic https://www.lssa.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Legal-Aid-SA-guidelines-on-measures-to-deal-with-the-Covid-19-pandemic.pdf accessed 4 October 2021

Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund date unknown Home http://www.fidfund.co.za/ accessed 1 July 2021

McKeown M 2011 Pro Bono Lawyers Provide Access to Justice Across Europe http://rightsni.org/2011/11/pro-bono-lawyers-provide-access-to-justice-across-europe/ accessed 1 June 2021

North-West University Faculty of Law date unknown Community Law Centre https://law.nwu.ac.za/Community-Law-Centre accessed 16 October 2021

Paterson A 2001 Community Legal Services: An Inter-Jurisdictional Comparison http://216.92.68.58/conference/ilag2001.htm accessed 5 October 2014

Paterson A 2005 Peer Review in Scotland http://internationallegalaid

group.org/images/publications/killarney2005/conferencepapers/Alan_Paterson_-_Peer_Review_in_Scotland.pdf accessed 31 October 2014

Paterson A and Sherr A 2007 Peer Review and Quality Assurance. The Emergence of Peer Review in the Legal Profession http://www.ua.ac.be/main.aspx?c=.ILAG2007&n=39311 accessed 30 November 2014

Paterson A and Sherr A 2019 Peer Review and Cultural Change: Quality Assurance, Legal Aid and the Legal Profession http://internationallegalaidgroup.org/images/miscdocs/Conference_Papers/Peer_Review_and_Cultural_Change.3docx_28APAS29.pdf accessed 15 October 2021

ProBono.Org 2021 Priority Work Areas https://probono.org.za/ accessed 18 October 2021

Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar, Ministry of Constitution and Legal Affairs 2020 Legal Aid Baseline Assessment Report 2020 https://utumishismz.go.tz/docs/qKRpj727B7_LEGAL_AID_BASELINE_ASSESSMENT_REPORT_2020.pdf accessed 12 October 2021

Rhodes University Law Clinic 2017 Legal Services https://www.ru.ac.za/lawclinic/legalservices/ accessed 22 November 2021

Schakenraad 2007 http://www.ua.ac.be/main.aspx?c=.ILAG2007&n=39311

Schakenraad 2009 http://216.92.68.58/conf_2009/papers/Guido%20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.33899/rjs.2009.39949

Schakenraad G 2009 Improving Quality Costs a Lot of Money; not Improving Quality Costs a Fortune http://216.92.68.58/conf_2009/papers/Guido%20Schakenraad%20Conference%20Paper.pdf accessed 30 November 2014

SECTION27 date unknown Home https://section27.org.za/ accessed 23 August 2021

South African Human Rights Commission 2015 List of Issues Report to the Human Rights Committee on South Africa's Implementation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CCPR/Shared%20Documents/ZAF/INT_CCPR_ICO_ZAF_20239_E.pdf accessed 18 January 2022

South African University Law Clinic Association date unknown Home https://www.saulca.co.za/ accessed 23 August 2021

United Nations Development Programme 2014 Legal Aid Service Provision: A Guide on Programming in Africa https://childrenandaids.

org/sites/default/files/2020-03/Legal%20Aid%20Service%20Provision%20-%20A%20Guide%20on%20Programming%20in%20

Africa.pdf accessed 16 October 2021

United Nations Development Programme 2013 Widening Access to Justice: Quality of Legal Aid and New UN Principles and Guidelines on Access to Legal Aid https://www.academia.edu/24661038/Quality_of_Legal_Aid_and_New_UN_Principles_and_Guidelines_on_

Access_to_Legal_Aid accessed 19 October 2021

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime 2019 Handbook on Ensuring Quality of Legal Aid Services in Criminal Justice Processes: Practical Guidance and Promising Practices https://www.unodc.org/documents/justice-and-prison-reform/HB_Ensuring_Quality_Legal_Aid_Services.pdf accessed 15 October 2021

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime 2020 Guidance Note: Ensuring Access to Justice in the Context of COVID-19 https://www.unodc.org/documents/Advocacy-Section/Ensuring_Access_to_Justice_in_the_Context_of_COVID-191.pdf accessed 20 October 2021

Published

01-11-2022

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Holness, D. (2022). The Need for Monitoring and Assessment of Legal Aid Quality in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 25, (Published 1 November 2022) pp 1 - 32. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2022/v25i0a13182

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1161

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.