Recent Developments in the Provision of Pro Bono Legal Services by Attorneys in South Africa

  • Dave Holness University Of KwaZulu-Natal
Keywords: legal service delivery, indigent, attorneys, pro bono, civil matters, private practice, constitutional, South Africa, socio-economic, access to justice, foreign jurisdictions, voluntary, mandatory, legal aid, free legal services

Abstract

This paper focuses on legal service delivery for the indigent by attorneys in private practice acting pro bono in civil rather than criminal matters.  In this regard there have been and continue to be considerable gaps between the proper access to civil justice imperatives of constitutional South Africa and the status quo which has existed from the advent of a democratic South Africa until the present. Law as a vehicle for necessary positive change in the daily lives of South African residents is pertinently considered within the country’s woefully unequal socio-economic climate. This paper considers the role which pro bono work by private attorneys is playing and should play in promoting a more just and equitable society through proper access to justice. It explores the current position in South Africa as well as the position in selected foreign jurisdictions regarding pro bono services by attorneys in private practice in civil matters. Part of the discussion focuses on the question of whether pro bono work should be voluntary or mandatory. The merits of introducing a pro bono obligation are critically analysed by looking at the effect on both legal practitioners as well as those receiving the pro bono services. Having defined pro bono work, the practical need for pro bono work by lawyers in private practice is highlighted due to the dearth of legal aid in civil matters for indigent South Africans. Possible constitutional imperatives for the provision of free legal services in civil matters are highlighted. An important part of the paper is a reflection on some of the pro bono work being conducted by private firms of attorneys.  The paper concludes with suggestions on means for establishing a more effective pro bono system in South Africa.

   ScienceOpen_Log0343270.png

References

Bibliography

Abramowitz 1960 SALJ

Abramowitz N "Legal Aid in South Africa" 1960 SALJ 351-367

Benson "Justice for All" The Weekend Post (7 January 1995) 8

Brickhill 2005 SAJHR

Brickhill J "The Right to a Fair Civil Trial: The Duties of Lawyers and Law Students to Act Pro Bono" 2005 SAJHR 293-322

Budlender 2004 SALJ

Budlender G "Access to Courts" 2004 SALJ 339-358

Burke, Mechling and Pearce 1996 Stetson L Rev

Burke DD, Mechling GW and Pearce JW "Mandatory Pro Bono: Cui Bono?" 1996 Stetson L Rev 983-1020

Cramton 1991 Hofstra L Rev

Cramton RC "Mandatory Pro Bono" 1991 Hofstra L Rev 1113-1139

Dean 1996 Geo J Legal Ethics

Dean WJ "Six Persuasive Arguments for Pro Bono" 1996 Geo J Legal Ethics 927-930

De Klerk 2003 De Rebus

De Klerk W "Justice for All?" Jan 2003 De Rebus 26-30

Erasmus 2012 SAMJ

Erasmus N "Slaves of the State – Medical Internships and Community Service in South Africa" 2012 SAMJ 655-658

Geral 2006 De Rebus

Geral D "Pro Bono: An Opportunity to Express Lawyers’ Social Conscience" Sep 2006 De Rebus 16

Jacobs 1998 Fla L Rev

Jacobs MS "Mandatory Pro Bono: Real Change or Imagined" 1998 Fla L Rev 509-522

Jaichand 2002 De Rebus

Jaichand V "LHR calls on lawyers to embark on Pro Bono Work" Jan 2002 De Rebus 21

Kemp and Pleasence 2005 Obiter

Kemp V and Pleasence P "Targeting Civil Legal Needs: Matching Services to Needs" 2005 Obiter 285-303

McQuoid-Mason 1991 SACJ

McQuoid-Mason D "Public Defenders and Alternative Service" 1991 SACJ 267-275

McQuoid-Mason 2005 Obiter

McQuoid-Mason D "Lessons from South Africa for the Delivery of Legal Aid in Small and Developing Commonwealth Countries" 2005 Obiter 207-233

Quansah 2007 CILSA

Quansah EK "Legal Aid in Botswana: A Problem in Search of a Solution" 2007 CILSA 509-526

Russel 2003-2004 UMKC L Rev

Russel IS "The Lawyer as Public Citizen: Meeting the Pro Bono Challenge" 2003-2004 UMKC L Rev 439-446

Sarkin 1993 Stell L R

Sarkin J "Can South Africa Afford Justice? The Need and Future of a Public Defender System" 1993 Stell L R 261-273

Sarkin 1998 Hum Rts Q

Sarkin J "The Development of a Human Rights Culture in South Africa" 1998 Hum Rts Q 628-665

Sarkin 2002 SAJHR

Sarkin J "Promoting Access to Justice in South Africa: Should the Legal Profession have a Voluntary or Mandatory Role in Providing Legal Services to the Poor?" 2002 SAJHR 630-644

Scully 1990 Hofstra L Rev

Scully JC "Mandatory Pro Bono: An Attack on the Constitution" 1990 Hofstra L Rev 1229-1269

Strossen 1993 Mich L Rev

Strossen N "Pro Bono Legal Work: For the Good of Not Only the Public, But Also the Lawyer and the Legal Profession" 1993 Mich L Rev 2122-2149

Tabak 1995 Geo J Legal Ethics

Tabak RJ "Integration of Pro Bono into Law Firm Practice" 1995 Geo J Legal Ethics 931-932

Tudzin 1987 J Leg Profession

Tudzin LS "Pro Bono Work: Should it be Mandatory or Voluntary?" 1987 J Leg Profession 103-128

Van As 2005 J Afr L

Van As H "Legal Aid in South Africa: Making Justice Reality" 2005 J Afr L 54-72

Van der Merwe 1999 De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "Compulsory Community Service for Lawyers" August 1999 De Rebus 5

Van der Merwe 2001 De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "Pro Bono Waits in the Wings" Nov 2001 De Rebus 18

Van der Merwe 2002a De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "The Profession Prepares for Pro Bono" Apr 2002 De Rebus 18

Van der Merwe 2002b De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "SA Legal Profession should Promote and Recognise Pro Bono Work" Apr 2002 De Rebus 2

Van der Merwe 2006a De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "Pro Bono – Attorneys Rolling up Their Sleeves" 2006 De Rebus Jan 22-23

Van der Merwe 2006b De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "Formalising Pro Bono in South Africa" Mar 2006 De Rebus 20-21

Wachtler 1991 Hofstra L Rev

Wachtler S "Symposium on Mandatory Pro Bono: Introduction" 1991 Hofstra L Rev 739-744

Whittle 2001 De Rebus

Whittle B "Pro Bono Publico" 2001 De Rebus 2

Whittle 2002 De Rebus

Whittle B "Pro Bono – Appealing to the Profession’s Social Conscience" Jun 2002 De Rebus 13-15

Whittle 2003a De Rebus

Whittle B "Cape Attorneys Opt for Mandatory Pro Bono Work" Jan 2003 De Rebus 2

Whittle 2003b De Rebus

Whittle B "LSSA seeks vies on pro bono at CCMA " Jul 2003 De Rebus 14

Whittle 2006 De Rebus

Whittle B "Malawi Lawyers Prepare for Mandatory Pro Bono" May 2006 De Rebus 16

Register of cases

De Kock v Minister of Water Affairs and Forestry 2005 12 BCLR 1183 (CC)

Legal Aid Board v Msila 1997 2 BCLR 229 (SE)

S v Mhlungu 1995 3 SA 867 (CC)

Soobramoney v Minister of Health, KwaZulu Natal 1998 1 SA 765 (CC)

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Register of government publications

GN R516 in GG 32208 of 8 May 2009

Register of internet sources

ABA 2002 http://bit.ly/10VNzpy

American Bar Association 2002 Model Rules of Professional Conduct http://bit.ly/10VNzpy [date of use 21 Jan 2012]

Ackermann 2006 http://bit.ly/13uniCG

Ackermann L 2006 A South African Law Firm Setting the Pro Bono Pace http://bit.ly/ZwPV9V. [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

BKM Attorneys 2011 http://bit.ly/11IvL09

BKM Attorneys 2011 Pro Bono http://bit.ly/11IvL09 [date of use 24 Jan 2012]

Bowman Gilfillan 2011 http://bit.ly/YziiuA

Bowman Gilfillan 2011 Pro Bono http://bit.ly/YziiuA [date of use 21 Jan 2011]

Bowman Gilfillan 2013

Bowman Gilfillan 2013 The Bowman Gilfillan Model http://bit.ly/YrdRzU

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2006 http://bit.ly/10LCfw9

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development, Drafting Team of the Steering Committee (August 2006) first Draft of the Legal Services Sector Charter http://bit.ly/10LCfw9 [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2007 http://bit.ly/14miGO1

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development, Drafting Team of the Steering Committee (December 2007) final Legal Services Sector Charter http://bit.ly/14miGO1 [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

DLA Piper 2005 http://bit.ly/XEEFsx

DLA Piper 2005 DLA Piper Chicago Office Wins Prestigous ISBA McAndrews Pro Bono Service Award http://bit.ly/XEEFsx [date of use 27 Jan 2011]

ENS 2013 http://bit.ly/ZwP2hm

Edward Nathan Sonnenbergs 2013 ENS's Pro Bono Work http://bit.ly/ZwP2hm [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Geldenhuys 2010 http://bit.ly/11dyGzb

Geldenhuys O Pro Bono in South Africa (1 March 2010) http://bit.ly/11dyGzb [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Ginsburg 2006 http://bit.ly/16gcnZd

Ginsburg RB Renaissance of Idealism in the Legal Profession (22 Sep 2006) http://bit.ly/16gcnZd [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Kruuse 2009 http://bit.ly/15QYIYd

Kruuse H 2009 Mandating Pro Bono in South Africa http://bit.ly/15QYIYd [date of use 25 Jan 2011]

LASA 2012 http://bit.ly/XamQGY

Legal Aid South Africa 2012 Annual Reports http://bit.ly/XamQGY [date of use 30 Jan 2012]

SASLAW 2012 http://bit.ly/14mldYB

South African Society for Labour Law 2012 Pro Bono http://bit.ly/14mldYB [date of use 12 Sep 2012]

Singh 2005 http://bit.ly/11Ivb2t

Singh KJ 2005 Access to Justice: Developing a Pro Bono Practice for South Africa (Conference on Consolidating Transformation 7-8 February 2005) http://bit.ly/11Ivb2t [date of use 24 Jan 2012]

South Africa Government Online 2013 http://bit.ly/10iWhNz

South Africa Government Online 2013 second Draft Legal Services Charter (August 2006) http://bit.ly/10iWhNz [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

SouthAfrica.info 2010 http://bit.ly/WUbQuQ

SouthAfrica.info 2010 Free Legal Services for the Poor http://bit.ly/WUbQuQ [date of use 26 January 2011]

KwaZulu-Natal Law Society Rules http://bit.ly/179tRtj [date of use 1 April 2013]

Law Society of South Africa The Charter

Law Society of South Africa Legal Services Sector Charter and Scorecards (2007) http://www.lssa.org.za/upload/LSC.pdf [date of use 1 April 2013]

Norton Rose 2013 http://bit.ly/pwprmN

Norton Rose 2013 Public Interest Law http://bit.ly/pwprmN [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Webber Wentzel 2013 http://bit.ly/ZYNsIO

Webber Wentzel 2013 Pro Bono http://bit.ly/ZYNsIO [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Webber Wentzel Pro Bono Report 2011 http://bit.ly/16s9Pco

Webber Wentzel Pro Bono Report 2011 http://bit.ly/16s9Pco [date of use 1 Apr 2013]

Published
2017-04-26
How to Cite
HolnessD. (2017). Recent Developments in the Provision of Pro Bono Legal Services by Attorneys in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(1), 128-164. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i1a2306
Section
Articles