The Constitutional Case Against the Mandatory Vaccine Policy — An Interdisciplinary South African Perspective
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a14109Keywords:
mandatory vaccine policy, constitutionality, curative medicine, critical public health, social sciences complementarity, preventive strategies, erroneous approachAbstract
In this article, I rethink the perceived/received wisdom of the mandatory vaccine policy which has been punted so ardently, largely uncritically, in South Africa. I investigate whether this line of argument could be justified from a comparative South African constitutional perspective. It became evident in the early stages of my research that the legal perspective is too narrow and constricting to allow for a proper understanding of the puzzle. Following Friedman's suggestion of the schism between Western-based curative medicine and preventive strategies, I employ a critical public health theoretical framework complemented by insights from the social sciences. Given that the vaccine is a product of an outdated paradigm, South Africa's erroneous approach to the pandemic led to disastrous consequences and fared less favourably than the rest of Africa. It is concluded that a mandatory vaccine policy is both unconstitutional and unjustifiable, in the wider view.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Braithwaite J "Inequality and Republican Criminology" in Hagan J and Peterson R (eds) Crime and Inequality (Stanford University Press Stanford 1995) 277-305 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9781503615557-014
Christie N Crime Control as Industry: Towards Gulags Western Style 3rd edn (Routledge London 2017) DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315512051
Classen JB "US COVID-19 Vaccines Proven to Cause More Harm than Good Based on Pivotal Clinical Trial Data Analyzed Using the Proper Scientific Endpoint, 'All Cause Severe Morbidity'" 2021 Trends Int Med 1-6 DOI: https://doi.org/10.33425/2771-5906.1004
Crouch C Post-Democracy (Polity Press Cambridge 2004)
Davis AY Is the Prison Obsolete? (Seven Stories Press New York 2003)
Doshi P "Pandemrix Vaccine: Why was the Public not Told of Early Warning Signs?" 2018 BMJ k3948 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.k3948 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.k3948
Duckworth A Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance (Scribner New York 2017)
Friedman S One Virus, Two Countries: What Covid-19 Tells Us About South Africa (Wits University Press Johannesburg 2021) DOI: https://doi.org/10.18772/12021117434
Habermas J "On Systematically Distorted Communication" 1970 Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 205-218 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00201747008601590
Habermas J Between Facts and Norms: A Contribution to the Discourse on Law and Morality (Polity/Blackwell Cambridge/Oxford 1996) DOI: https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/1564.001.0001
Habermas J Knowledge and Human Interests (Heinemann London 1971)
Habermas J Legitimation Crisis (Beacon Press Boston 1975) DOI: https://doi.org/10.3817/0975025210
Hurst AM Thinking about Research: Methodology and Hermeneutics in the Social Sciences (PE Technikon Gqeberha/Port Elizabeth 2004)
Jureidini J and McHenry LB The Illusion of Evidence-Based Medicine: Exposing the Crisis of Credibility in Clinical Research (Wakefield Press Adelaide 2020)
Klein N This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs the Climate (Penguin London 2015)
Leys C "The Cynical State" (essay) in Leys C Total Capitalism: Market Politics, Market State (Merlin Press Monmouth 2008) 111-144
Lötter C "Does Economic Restructuring During Covid-19 in South Africa Amount to Disaster Capitalism?" 2022 Phronimon 1-25 DOI: https://doi.org/10.25159/2413-3086/10503
Lötter C The Reintegration of Ex-offenders in South Africa Based on the Contemporary Chinese Model: An Interdisciplinary Study (PhD-thesis University of the Free State 2018)
Lyotard J-F The Differend: Phrases in Dispute (Manchester University Press Manchester 1988)
McCarthy T The Critical Theory of Jürgen Habermas (Hutchinson London 1978)
McLaughlin E "Critical Criminology" in McLaughlin E and Newburn T (eds) The Sage Handbook of Criminological Theory (Sage London 2010) 153-174 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4135/9781446200926.n9
Merchant HA "CoViD Vaccines and Thrombotic Events: EMA Issued Warning to Patients and Healthcare Professionals" 2021 J Pharm Policy Pract 1-2 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40545-021-00315-w
Olivier B "The Tacit Influences on One's Ways of Teaching and Doing Research" 2015 Alternation Special Edition 346-371
Olivier B "The "Pandemic and the Differend" 2021 Phronimon 1-35 DOI: https://doi.org/10.25159/2413-3086/9764
Patterson AS and Balogun E "African Responses to COVID-19: The Reckoning of Agency?" 2021 African Studies Review 144-167 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/asr.2020.122
Payne M "Introduction" in Bowie M (ed) Psychoanalysis and the Future of Theory (Blackwell Oxford 1993) 1-10
Popper K The Logic of Scientific Discovery (Routledge London 1992)
Schafer A "Biomedical Conflicts of Interest: A Defense of the Sequestration Thesis: Learning from the Cases of Nancy Olivieri and David Healy" 2004 Journal of Medical Ethics 8-24 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.2003.005702
Willen SS et al "Rethinking Flourishing: Critical Insights and Qualitative Perspectives from the US Midwest" 2022 SSM - Mental Health 1-13 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssmmh.2021.100057
Žižek S Pandemic! COVID-19 Shakes the World (Wiley Hoboken 2020) DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv16t6n4q
Case law
Bessick v Baroque Medical (Pty) Ltd (WECT 13083 of 21) [2022] ZACCMA 1 (9 May 2022)
Biden v Missouri (Supreme Court of the United States) Case No 21A240 (13 January 2022)
Four Midwives NZDSOS and NZTSOS v Minister for COVID-19 Response [2021] NZHC 3064 (12 November 2021)
GF v Minister of COVID-19 Response [2021] NZHC 2526 (24 September 2021)
KBLN v Minister of COVID-19 Response [2021] NZHC 3012 (8 November 2021)
National Federation of Independent Business v Department of Labor (Supreme Court of the United States) Case No 21A244 (13 January 2022)
Nga Kaitiaki Tuku Iho Medical Action Society v Minister of Health [2021] NZHC 1107 (18 May 2021)
NZDSOS Inc & NZTSOS v Minister for COVID-19 Response & Attorney General [2022] NZHC 716 (8 April 2022)
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, 1990
Internet sources
Anonymous 2021 South Africa's Ramaphosa Dlams COVID-19 'Health Apartheid'
https://english.alarabiya.net/coronavirus/2021/12/02/South-Africa-s-Ramaphosa-slams-COVID-19-health-apartheid- accessed 18 April 2022
Anonymous 2022 The Covid-19 Pandemic: Latest Updates https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/coronavirus accessed 29 April 2022
Bank L 2021 The Sociology of Ground Zero: The South African Variant and Colonial Prejudice https://africanarguments.org/2021/02/the-sociology-of-ground-zero-south-african-variant-and-colonial-prejudice/ accessed 24 April 2022
Bank L 2021 Ground Zero: Deep-Seated Colonial-Era Prejudice Fueled the Pandemic in Rural Eastern Cape https://dev.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-02-24-ground-zero-deep-seated-colonial-era-prejudice-fuelled-the-pandemic-in-rural-eastern-cape/ accessed 24 April 2022
Bernault F 2020 Some Lessons from the History of Pandemics in Africa https://africanarguments.org/2020/06/some-lessons-from-the-history-of-epidemics-in-africa/ accessed 24 April 2022
Bhargava A 2021 Is the Shot Safe and Effective as Advertised? [Interview] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5coAP9BLZOk accessed 18 April 2022
Breaking News-CA 2021 1,000 Lawyers and 10,000 Doctors have Filed a Lawsuit for Violations of the Nuremberg Code https://breakingnews.ca/the-new-nuremberg-trials-2021-please-share-this-info/ accessed 25 April 2022
Canadian Physicians 2021 Declaration of Canadian Physicians for Science and Truth https://canadianphysicians.org/ accessed 25 April 2022
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2021 What You Should Know About the Possibility of Covid-19 Illness After Vaccination https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/effectiveness/why-measureeffectiveness/breakthrough-cases.html accessed 4 November 2021
Center for Critical Public Health date unknown What is Critical Public Health? https://criticalpublichealth.org/about/ accessed 23 April 2022
Chen S 2021 Big Pharma's COVID-19 Reputation Boost May Not Last - Here's Why https://theconversation.com/big-pharmas-covid-19-reputation-boost-may-not-last-heres-why-162975 accessed 28 April 2022
Erdbrink T et al 2021 A Christmas Party in Norway Becomes a Possible Omnicron-Spreading Event, and Other International News https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/03/world/Omnicron-norway-christmas-party.html?campaign_id=57&emc=edit_ne_20211203 &instance_id=46990&nl=evening-brie accessed 21 April 2022
Ghebreyesus 2020 https://www.who.int/director-general/speeches/detail/
who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-media-briefing-on-covid-19---12-october-2020
Ghebreyesus TA 2020 WHO Director-General's Opening Remarks at the Media Briefing on COVID-19 - 11 March 2020 https://www.who.int/director-general/speeches/detail/who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-media-briefing-on-covid-19---12-october-2020 accessed 25 April 2022
Hdogar 2021 https://medium.com/lessons-from-history/black-death-pandemic-that-killed-200-million-people-7d94f2753465
Hdogar O 2021 Black Death — Pandemic That Killed 200 Million People https://medium.com/lessons-from-history/black-death-pandemic-that-killed-200-million-people-7d94f2753465 accessed 28 April 2022
Hodge 2022 https://www.the-sun.com/news/184/spanish-flu-pandemic-1918-death-toll/
Hodge M 2022 Deadly Virus: How Many People Died from the Spanish Flu Pandemic? https://www.the-sun.com/news/184/spanish-flu-pandemic-1918-death-toll/ accessed 29 April 2022
HPCSA 2016 https://www.hpcsa.co.za/Uploads/Professional_Practice/
Conduct%20%26%20Ethics/Booklet%204%20Informed%20Consent%20September%20%202016.pdf?msclkid=ba7b9b31ba4111ecb1e22c378c715614
Health Professions Council of South Africa 2016 Guidelines for Good Practice in the Health Care Professions - Seeking Patients' Informed Consent: The Ethical Considerations https://www.hpcsa.co.za/
Uploads/Professional_Practice/Conduct%20%26%20Ethics/Booklet%204%20Informed%20Consent%20September%20%202016.pdf?msclkid=ba7b9b31ba4111ecb1e22c378c715614 accessed 12 April 2022
Johns Hopkins University Coronavirus Resource Center 2021 https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html
Johns Hopkins University Coronavirus Resource Center 2021 Covid-19 Map https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html accessed 25 April 2022
Kent 2021 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jan/
/funding-self-isolate-covid-rampant
Kent J 2021 Thousands Have Been Refused Funding to Self-Isolate - No Wonder Covid is Rampant https://www.theguardian.com/
commentisfree/2021/jan/22/funding-self-isolate-covid-rampant accessed 30 April 2022
Khoza A Covid-19 Vaccine Compensation Scheme Investigating 55 Claims https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2022-04-13-covid-19-vaccine-compensation-scheme-investigating-55-claims/ accessed 15 April 2022
Kormann 2021 https://www.newyorker.com/science/elements/the-mysterious-case-of-the-covid-19-lab-leak-theory
Kormann C 2021 The Mysterious Case of the COVID-19 Lab-Leak Theory: Did the Virus Spring from Nature or from Human Error? https://www.newyorker.com/science/elements/the-mysterious-case-of-the-covid-19-lab-leak-theory accessed 12 October 2021
Li 2022 https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/13/business/china-covid-zero-shanghai.html
Li Y 2022 China's "Zero Covid" Mess Proves Autocracy Hurts Everyone https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/13/business/china-covid-zero-shanghai.html accessed 28 April 2022
Liptak 2022 https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/13/us/politics/supreme-court-biden-vaccine-mandate.html
Liptak A 2022 Supreme Court Blocks Biden's Virus Mandate for Large Employers https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/13/us/politics/supreme-court-biden-vaccine-mandate.html accessed 28 April 2022
Lister and Shukla 2020 https://edition.cnn.com/2020/04/10/europe/sweden-lockdown-turmp-intl/index.html
Lister T and Shukla S 2020. Sweden Challenges Trump and Scientific Mainstream by Refusing to Lock Down https://edition.cnn.com/
/04/10/europe/sweden-lockdown-turmp-intl/index.html accessed 25 April 2022
Lovelace B Jr 2021 CDC Study Shows 74% of People Infected in Massachusetts Covid Outbreak Were Fully Vaccinated https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/30/cdc-study-shows-74percent-of-people-infected-in-massachusetts-covid-outbreak-were-fully-vaccinated.html accessed 21 April 2022
Mark 2020 https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1540/medieval-cures-for-the-black-death/
Mark JJ 2020 Medieval Cures for the Black Death https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1540/medieval-cures-for-the-black-death/ accessed 29 April 2022
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary date unknown https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-atplay/epidemic-vs-pandemic-difference
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary date unknown Pandemic vs Epidemic — How They Overlap and Where They Differ https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-atplay/epidemic-vs-pandemic-difference accessed 29 June 2021
Moynihan R 2021 COVID Vaccines Offer the Pharma Industry a Once-in-a-Generation Opportunity to Reset its Reputation. But it's After Decades of Big Profits and Scandals https://theconversation.com/covid-vaccines-offer-the-pharma-industry-a-once-in-a-generation-opportunity-to-reset-its-reputation-but-its-after-decades-of-big-profits-and-scandals-165082?utm_med accessed 28 April 2021
Ross and Klompas 2010 https://digital.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/docs/
publication/r18hs017045-lazarus-final-report-2011.pdf
Ross L and Klompas M 2010 Electronic Support for Public Health – Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (ESP:VAERS) https://digital.ahrq.gov/
sites/default/files/docs/publication/r18hs017045-lazarus-final-report-2011.pdf accessed 18 April 2022
Sayer F 2021 Nigerian Museums Must Tell Stories of Slavery with More Complexity and Nuance https://theconversation.com/nigerian-museums-must-tell-stories-of-slavery-with-more-complexity-and-nuance-169785 accessed 30 October 2021
Shipman 2014 https://www.americanscientist.org/article/the-bright-side-of-the-black-death
Shipman PL 2014 The Bright Side of the Black Death https://www.americanscientist.org/article/the-bright-side-of-the-black-death accessed 29 April 2022 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1511/2014.111.410
Staff Writer 2022 Vaccine Mandates in South African Workplaces – Where We are Heading https://businesstech.co.za/news/business/562366/vaccine-mandates-in-south-african-workplaces-where-we-are-heading/ accessed 28 April 2022
Weijer C 2020 How Pharma Can Build Trust in COVID-19 Vaccines: Transparency on Trials and Side-Effects https://theconversation.com/how-pharma-can-build-trust-in-covid-19-vaccines-transparency-on-trials-and-side-effects-150270 accessed 29 September 2022
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Casper Lӧtter
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}