Reflecting on Evictions and Unlawful Occupation of Land in South Africa: Where Do Some Gaps Still Remain?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a14687Keywords:
PIE, Unlawful occupation, EvictionsAbstract
The issue of unlawful occupation and homelessness has been a very prominent topic for many decades. While our approach to evictions and unlawful occupation has clearly shifted from a draconian approach under the Prevention of Illegal Squatting Act 51 of 1951 (hereafter PISA) to an approach that focusses on human rights under the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998 (hereafter PIE), there are still various aspects that potentially fall short in protecting the rights of the various stakeholders involved in these disputes. In particular, this paper focusses on three areas where PIE potentially falls short. In this regard we examine cases of the impossibility of eviction orders, our current understanding of the notion of "home", and whether or not PIE applies to both occupied and unoccupied structures. We also briefly explore issues relating to the non-implementation of PIE, especially in relation to the government's goal of preventing unlawful occupation. Central to these discussions is whether our current approach is sufficient and in line with constitutional obligations or whether we need to rethink our approaches to ensure that we do not undo the progress made since apartheid.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Albertyn C "Contested Substantive Equality in the South African Constitution: Beyond Social Inclusion Towards Systemic Justice" 2018 SAJHR 441-468 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2018.1550938
Arbour L "Economic and Social Justice for Societies in Transition" 2007 New York University Journal of Law and Politics 1-28
Bishop M "Remedies" in Woolman S and Bishop M (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa (Cape Town Juta OS 06-08) ch 9
Boggenpoel ZT "Does Method Really Matter? Reconsidering the Role of Common Law Remedies in the Eviction Paradigm" 2014 Stell LR 72-98
Boggenpoel ZT "(Re)defining the Contours of Ownership: Moving Beyond White Picket Fences" 2019 Stell LR 234-249
Boggenpoel ZT and Mahomedy S "Evictions During the COVID-19 Pandemic and Beyond [Discussion of South African Human Rights Commission v City of Cape Town 2021 2 SA 565 (WCC)]" 2021 Stell LR 482-495
Boggenpoel ZT and Pienaar JM "The Continued Relevance of the Mandament van Spolie: Recent Developments Relating to Dispossession and Eviction" 2013 De Jure 998-1021
Boggenpoel ZT and Slade BV "Where is Property? Some Thoughts on the Theoretical Implications of Daniels v Scribante" 2020 CCR 379-399 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR.2020.0014
Botha H "Democracy and Rights: Constitutional Interpretation in a Postrealist World" 2000 THRHR 561-581
Boudreaux K "Land Reform as Social Justice: The Case of South Africa" 2010 Economic Affairs 13-20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0270.2009.01967.x
Brand D "The 'Politics of Need Interpretation' and the Adjudication of Socio-Economic Rights Claims in South Africa" in Van der Walt AJ (ed) Theories of Social and Economic Justice (SUN Media Stellenbosch 2005) 17-36
Brandon FM and Kobayashi LC "Structural Inequality in the Time of COVID-19: Urbanization, Segregation, and Pandemic Control in Sub-Saharan Africa" 2020 Dialogues in Human Geography 217-220 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2043820620934310
Chenwi L "A New Approach to Remedies in Socio-Economic Rights Adjudication: Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road and Others v City of Johannesburg and Others" 2009 CCR 371-393 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR/2009.0010
Chenwi L "'Meaning Engagement' in the Realisation of Socio-Economic Rights: The South African Experience" 2011 SAPL 128-156
Cloete CT and Boggenpoel ZT "Re-evaluating the Prescribed Role of Courts Pertaining to the Court System Applicable in PIE Eviction Cases" 2018 SALJ 432-446
Cramer R and Mostert H "'Home' and Unlawful Occupation: The Horns of Local Government's Dilemma – Fischer and Another v Persons Unknown 2014 3 SA 291 (WCC)" 2015 Stell LR 583-611
Davis DM "The Relationship between the Courts and the Other Arms of Government in Promoting and Protecting Socio-Economic Rights in South Africa: What about Separation of Powers?" 2012 PELJ 1-14 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i5a2516
Davis DM "Is the South African Constitution an Obstacle to a Democratic Post-Colonial State?" 2018 SAJHR 359-374 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2018.1543839
De Groot J and Lemanski C "COVID-19 Responses: Infrastructure Inequality and Privileged Capacity to Transform Everyday Life in South Africa" 2021 Environment and Urbanization 255-272 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0956247820970094
Dixon R "Creating Dialogue About Socioeconomic Rights: Strong-Form Versus Weak-Form Judicial Review Revisited" 2007 ICON 391-418 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mom021
Du Plessis E "Ways of Living in a Transformative Democracy" in De Ville J (ed) Memory and Meaning: Essays in Honour of Lourens du Plessis (LexisNexis Durban 2015) 1-17
Dugard J "Modderklip Revisited: Can Courts Compel the State to Expropriate Property Where the Eviction is not Just and Equitable?" 2018 PELJ 1-20 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2018/v21i0a3477
Dugard J "Unpacking Section 25: What, if Any, are the Legal Barriers to Transformative Land Reform?" 2019 CCR 135-160 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR.2019.0006
Dugard J and Seme N "Property Rights in Court: An Examination of Judicial Attempts to Settle Section 25's Balancing Act re Restitution and Expropriation" 2018 SAJHR 33-56 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2018.1432103
Etienne CF "COVID-19 has Revealed a Pandemic of Inequality" 2022 Nature Medicine 17 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-021-01596-z
Fennel LA "Order with Outlaws?" 2007 U Pa L Rev 269-278
Fox O'Mahony L Conceptualising Home: Theories, Laws and Policies (Hart Oxford 2006)
Froneman JC "Legal Reasoning and Legal Culture: Our 'Vision' of Law" 2005 Stell LR 3-20
Kennedy D "Form and Substance in Private Law Adjudication" 1976 Harv L Rev 1713-1724 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1340104
Killander M "Criminalising Homelessness and Survival Strategies through Municipal By-laws: Colonial Legacy and Constitutionality" 2019 SAJHR 70-93 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2019.1586129
Klare KE "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.1998.11834974
Liebenberg S "Engaging the Paradoxes of the Universal and Particular in Human Rights Adjudication: The Possibilities and Pitfalls of 'Meaningful Engagement'" 2012 AHRLJ 1-29
Liebenberg S "Participatory Approaches to Socio-Economic Rights Adjudication: Tentative Lessons from South African Evictions Law" 2014 Nordic Journal of Human Rights 312-330 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/18918131.2015.957462
Liebenberg S Socio-Economic Rights: Adjudication under a Transformative Constitution (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2010)
Mahomedy S Investigating the Role of Participation in the Upgrading of Informal Settlements: Identifying Challenges and Opportunities (LLD-dissertation Stellenbosch University 2022)
Mahomedy S The Potential of Meaningful Engagement in Realising Socioeconomic Rights: Addressing Quality Concerns (LLM-thesis Stellenbosch University 2019)
Minow M "Forgiveness, Law and Justice" 2015 CLR 1615-1646
Mostert H "Land Restitution, Social Justice and Development in South Africa" 2002 SALJ 400-428
Mostert H and Cramer R "'Home' and Unlawful Occupation: The Horns of Local Government's Dilemma: Fischer and Another v Persons Unknown 2014 3 SA 291 (WCC)" 2015 Stell LR 583-611
Muller G "Conceptualising 'Meaningful Engagement' as a Deliberative Democratic Partnership" 2011 Stell LR 742-758
Muller G "The Legal-Historical Context of Urban Forced Evictions in South Africa" 2013 Fundamina 367-396
Muller G and Marais EJ "Reconsidering Counter-Spoliation as a Common-Law Remedy in the Eviction Context in View of the Single-System-of-Law Principle" 2020 TSAR 103-124
Muller G et al Silberberg and Schoeman's The Law of Property 6th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2019)
Ngam RN "Government-Driven Land and Agrarian Reform Programmes in Post-Apartheid South Africa: A Brief History (1994-2021)" 2021 African Sociological Review 131-152
O'Regan K "Text Matters: Some Reflections on the Forging of a New Constitutional Jurisprudence in South Africa" 2012 MLR 1-32 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2230.2012.00886.x
Peñalver EM and Katyal SK "Property Outlaws" 2007 U Pa L Rev 1095-1186 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.745324
Pienaar JM "Approaching Systemic Failure? A Brief Overview of Recent Land Reform Case Law" 2020 TSAR 536-546
Pienaar JM "'Unlawful Occupier' in Perspective: History, Legislation and Case Law" in Mostert H and De Waal MJ (eds) Essays in Honour of CG van der Merwe (Juta Cape Town 2011) 317-338
Pienaar JM and Muller A "The Impact of the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998 on Homelessness and Unlawful Occupation within the Present Statutory Framework" 1999 Stell LR 370-396
Pienaar JM Land Reform (Juta Cape Town 2014)
Ray BB "Proceduralisation's Triumph and Engagement's Promise in Socio-Economic Rights Litigation" 2011 SAJHR 107-126 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19962126.2011.11865007
Rochelle PB and Gordon E "The Shadow Pandemic: Inequitable Gendered Impacts of COVID‐19 in South Africa" 2021 Gender, Work and Organization 795-806 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/gwao.12565
Robbertze G and Muller G "Conceptualising the Home in Law and Gender" 2005 De Jure 332-352
Rosenberg GM The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring about Social Change? 2nd ed (University of Chicago Press Chicago 2008) DOI: https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226726687.001.0001
Roux T The Politics of Principle: The First South African Constitutional Court, 1995-2005 (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2013) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139005081
Sabanda S "When Do You Call a Time on a Compromise? South Africa's Discourse on Transformation and the Future of Transformative Constitutionalism" 2020 LDD 384-412 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/2077-4907/2020/ldd.v24.16
Scott TS "The Precarious Position of a Landowner vis-à-vis Unlawful Occupiers: Common Law Remedies to the Rescue?" 2018 TSAR 158-176
Strydom J and Viljoen S "Unlawful Occupation of Inner-City Buildings: A Constitutional Analysis of the Rights and Obligations Involved" 2014 PELJ 1207-1261 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v17i4.01
Van der Berg S "Meaningful Engagement: Proceduralising Socio-Economic Rights Further or Infusing Administrative Law with Substance" 2013 SAJHR 376-398 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19962126.2013.11865079
Van der Merwe CG Sakereg 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1989)
Van der Walt AJ "Exclusivity of Ownership, Security of Tenure, and Eviction Orders: A Model to Evaluate South African Land-Reform Legislation" 2002 TSAR 254-289
Van der Walt AJ "The State's Duty to Protect Property Owners v the State's Duty to Provide Housing: Thoughts on the Modderklip Case" 2005 SAJHR 144-161
Van der Walt AJ "Legal History, Legal Culture and Transformation in a Constitutional Democracy" 2006 Fundamina 1-47
Van der Walt AJ "Property, Social Justice and Citizenship: Property Law in the Post-Apartheid South Africa" 2008 Stell LR 325-346
Van der Walt AJ "Sharing Servitudes" 2015 European Property Law Journal 162-222 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/eplj-2015-0009
Van der Walt AJ Property in the Margins (Hart Oxford 2009) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195391572.003.004
Van Wyk J "The Role of Local Government in Evictions" 2011 PELJ 50-83 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v14i3.4
Viljoen S "A Systemically Correct Approach to State Evictions" 2020 Stell LR 201-225
Wenzel J "The Pastoral Promise and the Political Imperative: The Plaasroman Tradition in an Era of Land Reform" 2000 Modern Fiction Studies 90-113 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/mfs.2000.0014
Wilson S "Breaking the Tie: Evictions from Private Land, Homelessness and a New Normality" 2009 SALJ 270-290
Wilson S Human Rights and the Transformation of Property (Juta Cape Town 2021)
Xaba MB "South African Land Question and the Dilemma of Land Expropriation without Compensation: A Critical Examination" in Akinola AO, Kaseeram I and Jili NN (eds) The New Political Economy of Land Reform in South Africa (Springer New York 2021) 79-99 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-51129-6_5
Zitzke E "A Decolonial Critique of Private Law Human Rights" 2018 SAJHR 492-516 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2018.1543836
Case law
Absa Bank Ltd v Murray (CA338/2017) [2018] ZAECGHC 75 (28 August 2018)
Barnett v Minister of Land Affairs 2007 6 SA 313 (SCA)
Breede Vallei Munisipaliteit v Die Inwoners van Erf 18184 (A369/12) [2012] ZAWCHC 390 (13 December 2012)
Chetty v Naidoo 1974 3 SA 13 (A)
City of Cape Town v Rudolph (89700/01) [2003] ZAWCHC 29 (7 July 2003)
City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2011 4 SA 337 (SCA)
Dladla v City of Johannesburg 2018 2 SA 327 (CC)
First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Commissioner, South African Revenue Service; First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Minister of Finance 2002 4 SA 768 (CC)
Fischer v Persons Whose Identities are to the Applicants Unknown and Who Have Attempted or are Threatening to Unlawfully Occupy Erf 150 (Remaining Extent) Philippi in re: Ramahlele v Fisher 2014 3 SA 291 (WCC)
Fose v Minister of Safety and Security 1997 3 SA 786 (CC)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
MEC, Department of Welfare, Eastern Cape v Kate 2006 4 SA 478 (SCA)
Modder East Squatters v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd, President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery 2004 3 All SA 169 (SCA)
Modderklip Boerdery (Edms) Bpk v President van die Republiek van Suid-Afrik 2003 6 BCLR 638 (T)
Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd v Modder East Squatters 2001 4 SA 385 (W)
Ndlovu v Ngcobo; Bekker v Jika 2002 4 All SA 384 (SCA)
Ngomane v City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality 2020 1 SA 52 (SCA)
Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township, and 197 Main Street, Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg 2008 3 SA 208 (CC)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd 2005 5 SA 3 (CC)
Rakgase v Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform (33497/2018) [2019] ZAGPPHC 375 (4 September 2019)
Residents of Joe Slovo Community, Western Cape v Thubelisha Homes 2010 3 SA 454 (CC)
South African Human Rights Commission v City of Cape Town (WC) (unreported) case number 8631/2021 of 15 July 2022
South African Human Rights Commission v City of Cape Town 2021 2 SA 565 (WCC) DOI: https://doi.org/10.47348/SLR/2021/i3a6
Legislation
City of Cape Town: Integrated Waste Management By-law, 2009
City of Cape Town: Streets, Public Places and the Prevention of Noise Nuisances By-law, 2007
City of Cape Town: Streets, Public Places and the Prevention of Noise Nuisances Amendment By-law, 2021
City of Cape Town: Unlawful Occupation By-law, 2021
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Disaster Management Act 57 of 2002
Expropriation Act 63 of 1975
Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997
Housing Act 107 of 1997
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Prevention of Illegal Squatting Act 51 of 1951
Social Assistance Act 59 of 1992
Internet source
Bennie A 2017 GroundUp: Red Ants Accused of Firing Rubber Bullets https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2017-07-14-groundup-red-ants-accused-of-firing-rubber-bullets/ accessed 10 September 2022
Bhengu L 2021 "We are Powerless": Red Ants Evict People Living Illegally in Posh Joburg Suburb https://www.news24.com/news24/
southafrica/news/we-are-powerless-red-ants-evict-people-living-illegally-in-posh-joburg-suburb-20210406 accessed 10 September 2022
Bornman J and Nyoka N 2020 City of Joburg's Heartless Red Ants Demolitions https://www.newframe.com/city-of-joburgs-heartless-red-ants-demolitions/ accessed 10 September 2022
Evans J 2022 "You Will Die Here": Red Ant Recounts Eviction Battle in Knysna https://www.news24.com/news24/southafrica/news/you-will-die-here-red-ant-recounts-eviction-battle-in-knysna-20220409 accessed 10 September 2022
Gillespie K et al 2021 Part One | The Red Ants and the City of Cape Town https://www.newframe.com/part-one-the-red-ants-and-the-city-of-cape-town/ accessed 10 September 2022
Government of the Republic of South Africa 2019 Regulations and Guidelines: Coronavirus COVID-19 https://www.gov.za/covid-19/resources/regulations-and-guidelines-coronavirus-covid-19 accessed 10 September 2022
Ndifuna Ukwazi 2021 Press Statement: Eleven People Who are Homeless Go to Court to Challenge Cape Town's Discriminatory By-laws https://nu.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/NU_press_release_2021_
_07.pdf accessed 10 September 2022
Neille D 2020 Gauteng Demolitions: Red Ants in All-Out War on the Poor https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2020-04-22-gauteng-demolitions-red-ants-in-all-out-war-on-the-poor/ accessed 10 September 2022
Payi B 2021 City of Cape Town's By-laws Challenged by Homeless in Court Action https://www.iol.co.za/weekend-argus/news/city-of-cape-towns-by-laws-challenged-by-homeless-in-court-action-52590643-69fd-40c6-b3e5-81f40b63705b accessed 10 September 2022
Staff Reporter 2014 Jo'burg Residents Battle Red Ant Evictions https://mg.co.za/article/2014-09-18-joburg-residents-battle-red-ant-evictions/ accessed 10 September 2022
Staff Reporter 2021 City Forks Out R170.8m More for Security in the Fight against Cape Land Invasions https://www.iol.co.za/capeargus/news/city-forks-out-r1708m-more-for-security-in-the-fight-against-cape-land-invasions-411939da-4da6-4967-a113-ba5f40ca5006 accessed 10 September 2022
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Zsa-Zsa Boggenpoel, Sameera Mahomedy
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}