A Legal Perspective on Sexual Grooming Behaviours as Professional Boundary Violations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a16890Keywords:
educator-on-learner sexual grooming, law and policy, professional boundary violations, South African Council for Educators, South AfricaAbstract
A literature review revealed that sexual grooming can be counteracted in public schools by focussing on educators’ professional boundary violations. However, there is a scarcity of literature where sexual grooming behaviours are linked to professional boundary violations and on the handling of these behaviours from an Education Law perspective. Such information would be most valuable to school principals, departments of education, bodies overseeing the teaching profession and forums and courts that consider cases dealing with educator-on-leaner sexual grooming. In this article, the author not only links typical grooming behaviours with professional boundary violations but also considers the law and policy that governs it, and which would apply when dealing with such as a breach of the South African Council for Educators Code of Professional Ethics, and or misconduct. Sexual grooming behaviours are associated with the violation of professional relationship boundaries which protect learners from abuse of power and trust, inappropriate communication, educators exceeding their tasks and roles, educators physically abusing learners and educators invading learners' personal space and privacy. To allege that an educator has committed a professional boundary violation it is essential to distinguish between boundary violations which are acceptable and boundary violations that are inappropriate and part of sexual grooming. The author suggests a test that can be used to make this distinction and that would make it possible to deal with boundary violations before a sexual grooming pattern forms. The article is concluded with recommendations inter alia to rephrase section 17(1)(f) of the Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998 so that it would be unambiguous and be able to cover sexual grooming as a form of serious misconduct.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Australasian Teacher Regulatory Authorities Managing Professional Boundaries: Guidelines for Teachers (ATRA Melbourne 2015)
Badenhorst MC The Grooming Process in Child Pornography: A Social Work Case Study (Magister Artium Social Work in Forensic Practice North-West University 2008)
Bennett N and O'Donohue W "The Construct of Grooming in Child Sexual Abuse: Conceptual and Measurement Issues" 2014 JCSA 957-976
Black PJ et al "A Linguistic Analysis of Grooming Strategies of Online Child Sex Offenders: Implications for our Understanding of Predatory Sexual Behavior in an Increasingly Computer-mediated World" 2015 Child Abuse Neglect 140-149
Canadian Centre for Child Protection Child Sexual Abuse by K-12 School Personnel in Canada: Executive Summary (Canadian Centre for Child Protection Manitoba 2018)
Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre Out of Mind, Out of Sight: Breaking Down the Barriers to Understanding Child Sexual Exploitation (Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre London 2011)
Christopher DE "Specific Concerns for Teachers, School Counselors, and Administrators" in Schwilk C, Stevenson R and Bateman D (eds) Sexual Misconduct in the Education and Human Services Sector (IGI Global Hershey 2017) 24-42
Coetzee SA "Forms of Educator-on-Learner Sexual Misconduct Redefined" 2011 CARSA 51-64
Coetzee SA "Educator Sexual Misconduct: Exposing or Causing Learners to be Exposed to Child Pornography or Pornography" 2015 PELJ 2107-2139
Coetzee SA "Holding the State Directly Liable for Educator-on-Learner Sexual Abuse" 2018 CARSA 30-44
Coetzee SA "Sexual Grooming of Children in Teaching as a Trust Profession in South Africa" 2023 PELJ http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a14192
Conte JR, Wolf S and Smith T "What Sexual Offenders Tell Us about Prevention Strategies" 1989 Child Abuse and Neglect 293-301
Cotliar S "Prep School Abuse: Out of the Shadows" People Magazine (6 October 2014) 65-69
Courtois and Alpert "MIND F*CK The Grooming Process in 'Professional Incest'" in Schwilk C, Stevenson R and Bateman D (eds) Sexual Misconduct in the Education and Human Services Sector (IGI Global Hershey 2017) 239-261
Elliott IA "A Self-Regulation Model of Sexual Grooming" 2017 TVA 83-97
Egan V, Hoskinson J and Shewan D "Perverted Justice: A Content Analyses of the Language Used by Offenders Detected Attempting to Solicit Children for Sex" in Clarke RM (ed) Antisocial Behavior: Causes, Correlations and Treatments (Nova Science Publishers New York 2011) 1-15
Erooga M, Allnock D and Telford P Towards Safer Organisations II: Using the Perspectives of Convicted Sex Offenders to Inform Organisational Safeguarding of Children (NSPCC London 2012)
Gámez-Guadix M et al "Persuasion Strategies and Sexual Solicitations and Interactions in Online Sexual Grooming of Adolescents: Modeling Direct and Indirect Pathways" 2018 Journal of Adolescence 11-18
Graham A et al Teachers' Professional Boundary Transgressions: A Literature Summary (Centre for Children and Young People, Southern Cross University Lismore 2018)
Gushwa M, Bernier J and Robinson D "Advancing Child Sexual Abuse Prevention in Schools: An Exploration of the Effectiveness of the Enough! Online Training Program for K-12 Teachers" 2019 JCSA 144-159
Hook and Devereux "Sexual Boundary Violations: Victims, Perpetrators and Risk Reduction" 2018 BJPsych Advances 374-383
Kinzel A Groomers: A Corpus Assisted Discourse Study of Intentions, Requests and Grooming Duration (PhD-thesis in Applied Linguistics Swansea University 2021)
Lanning KV and Dietz P "Acquaintance Molestation and Youth-Serving Organizations" 2014 JIV 2815-2838
Lorenzo-Dus N and Kinzel A "ʹSo is your Mom as Cute as You?ʹ: Examining Patterns of Language Use by Online Sexual Groomers" 2019 Journal of Corpora and Discourse Studies 1-30
McElvaney R "Grooming: A Case Study" 2019 JCSA 608-627
Minnie D The Grooming Process and the Defence of Consent in Child Sexual Abuse Case (LLM-dissertation Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University 2008)
Munroe and Fish Hear no Evil, See no Evil: Understanding Failure to Identify and Report Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts (Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse Commonwealth of Australia Sydney 2015)
O'Leary P, Koh E and Dare A Grooming and Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts (Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse Commonwealth of Australia Sydney 2017)
Ost S "Getting to Grips with Sexual Grooming? The New Offence under the Sexual Offences Act 2003" 2004 JSWFL 147-159
Palmer D The Role of Organisational Culture in Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts (Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse Commonwealth of Australia Sydney 2016)
Patterson MA and Austin DF "Stop the Grooming: How can you Help Protect Children from Sexual Misconduct by School Employees?" 2008 December ASBJ 18-20
Pollack D and MacIver A "Understanding Sexual Grooming in Child Abuse Cases" 2015 ABA Child Law Practice 166-168
Queensland College for Educators Professional Boundaries: A Guideline for Queensland Teachers (Queensland College of Teachers Brisbane 2019)
Shakeshaft C "Know the Warning Signs of Educator Sexual Misconduct" 2013 February Kappan 8-13
Shakeshaft C and Cohan A In Loco Parentis: Sexual Abuse of Students in Schools. What Administrators should Know (Hofstra University Long Island 1994)
Snyman C Criminal Law 6th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2014)
United States of America Department of Education Educator Sexual Misconduct: A Synthesis of Existing Literature (USA Department of Education, Office of the Under Secretary Washington DC 2004)
Winters GM and Jeglic EL "Stages of Sexual Grooming: Recognizing Potentially Predatory Behaviors of Child Molesters" 2017 Deviant Behavior 724-733
Winters GM, Jeglic EL and Kaylor LE "Validation of the Sexual Grooming Model of Child Sexual Abusers" 2020 JCSA 855-875
Wojciechowska "Managing Personal and Professional Boundaries"Wojciechowska E "Managing Personal and Professional Boundaries" in Hartley P and Kennard D (ed) Staff Support Groups in the Helping Professions: Principles, Practice and Pitfalls (Routledge London 2009) 147-160
Wolf MR, Linn BK and Pruitt DK "Grooming Child Victims into Sexual Abuse: A Psychometric Analysis of Survivors' Experiences" 2018 Journal of Sexual Aggression 215-224
Wurtele SK "Preventing the Sexual Exploitation of Minors in Youth-Serving Organizations" 2012 Children and Youth Services Review 2442-2453
Case law
Chetty v S (AR 377/2014) [2015] ZAKZPHC 41 (21 August 2015)
Davids and Western Cape Department of Education ELRC767-21/22WC (6 May 2022)
Davidson v Victorian Institute of Teaching (Occupational and Business Regulation) [2007] VCAT 920 (30 May 2007)
Diholo and Gauteng Department of Education PSES933-18/19GP (9 May 2019)
Free State Department of Education and Mofokeng ELRC276-20/21FS (27 October 2021)
Gauteng Department of Education and Rasekhula ELRC990-21/22GP (25 April 2022)
Gauteng Department of Education and Modiba PSES720-19/20GP (24 February 2020)
Gauteng Department of Higher Education and Mlangeni ELRC52-23/24GP (9 July 2023)
K v S [2003] JOL 10720 (SCA)
Le Roux v State (A & R 25/2018) [2021] ZAECGHC 57 (13 May 2021)
Limpopo Department of Education and Mathekga ELRC200-21/22LP (12 November 2021)
Mokotjo and Free State Department of Education ELRC18-21/22FS (22 September 2021)
Mugridge v S (657/12) [2013] ZASCA 43 (28 March 2013)
Ncakeni and Gauteng Department of Education PSES58-13/14GP (23 April 2014)
Queensland College of Teachers v JNS [2018] QCAT 228
Satani and Western Cape Department of Education PSES232-13/14WC (7 June 2017)
SADTU obo Jacobs and Western Cape Department of Education PSES651-15/16WC (29 July 2016)
SADTU obo July and Northern Cape Department of Education PSES610-18/19NC (14 May 2019)
SADTU obo Ramphal and the Gauteng Department of Education PSES442–17/18GP (2 July 2019)
Sheldon-Lakey v S (CA 42/2014) [2016] ZANWHC 33 (14 July 2016)
Sogoni and Western Cape Education Department PSES407-19/20WC (17 February 2020)
S v RC 2016 1 SACR 34 (KZP)
Strydom v S (A463/2014) [2015] ZAGPPHC 272 (5 February 2015)
Van den Heever and Northern Cape Department of Education ELRC716-19/20NC (31 July 2022)
Victorian Institute of Teaching and Davidson Case 005 (27 October 2004)
Victorian Institute of Teaching and Dore Case 060 (15 April 2008)
Waterson and Gauteng Department of Education PSES345-12/13 (19 November 2013)
Legislation
Electronic Communications Act 36 of 2005
Employment of Educators Act 76 of 1998
Liquor Act 59 of 2003
South African Council for Educators Act 31 of 2000
South African Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act 32 of 2007
Tobacco Products Control Act 83 of 1993
Government publications
Education Laws Amendment Bill [B48-2000]
Internet sources
Australasian Teacher Regulatory Authorities date unknown Who We Are https://www.atra.edu.au/ accessed 21 April 2024
Australia ACT Ombudsman 2018 https://www.ombudsman.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/81000/No.-2-Identifying-Reportable-Conduct.pdf
Australia ACT Ombudsman 2018 ACT Ombudsman Practice Guide No 2 https://www.ombudsman.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/81000/No.-2-Identifying-Reportable-Conduct.pdf accessed 26 August 2023
Morgan S 2016 Safeguarding: Maintaining Professional Boundaries Headteacher Update 11 November 2016 https://www.headteacher-update.com/best-practice-article/safeguarding-maintaining-professional-boundaries/147893/ accessed 26 August 2023
New South Wales Ombudsman for the Protection of Children 2013 Defining Reportable Conduct https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/sites/
default/files/OMB.0015.001.0140.pdf accessed 26 August 2023
Robins SL 2000 Protecting our Students: A Review to Identify and Prevent Sexual Misconduct in Ontario Schools (Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General) https://wayback.archive-it.org/16312/20210402200200/http://www.attorneygeneral.jus.gov.on.ca/english/about/pubs/robins/ch3.php accessed 22 April 2024
South African Council for Educators date unknown Code of Professional Ethics (as updated) https://www.sace.org.za/assets/documents/
uploads/sace_31646-2023-01-17-0000_SACE_Booklet_Yellow_
BOOK_OF_ETHICS__proof_5.1.pdf accessed 28 August 2023SACE date unknown https://www.sace.org.za/assets/documents/
uploads/sace_31646-2023-01-17-0000_SACE_Booklet_Yellow_BOOK_OF_ETHICS__proof_5.1.pdf
South African Council for Educators date unknown Disciplinary Procedures https://www.sace.org.za/assets/documents/uploads/sace_31646-2023-01-17-0000_SACE_Booklet_Yellow_BOOK_OF_ETHICS__proof_5.1.pdf accessed 26 August 2023
Tanner J and Brake S 2013 Exploring Sex Offender Grooming http://www.kbsolutions.com/Grooming.pdf accessed 26 August 2023
Victoria Family and Community Development Committee 2013 Betrayal of Trust: Inquiry into the Handling of Child Abuse by Religious and Other Non-Government Organisations https://apo.org.au/node/36348 accessed 25 August 2023
Weber GM date unknown Boundary Violations, "Grooming" and Child Sexual Abuse (Springfield Diocese Office of Counseling, Prevention and Victim Services) https://diospringfield.org/wp-content/uploads/YPParent-Resoucre-1.pdf accessed 26 August 2023
Webster S et al (eds) 2012 European Online Grooming Project Final Report https://www.academia.edu/23987615/European_Online_Grooming_Project_Final_Report accessed 21 April 2024
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Susanna Abigael Coetzee
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}