Constitutional Damages – a Stagnant or a Changing Landscape?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2023/v26i0a15901Keywords:
constitutional damages, appropriate relief, delictual damages, principle of subsidiarityAbstract
Section 38 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 provides for appropriate relief where a right in the Bill of Rights has been infringed. In Fose v Minister of Safety and Security 1997 3 SA 786 (CC) the Constitutional Court raised the question of "appropriate relief" with reference to section 7(4)(a) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993. In the Fose case the plaintiff claimed "punitive constitutional damages" together with delictual damages. While the court did not rule out an award for damages for the infringement, it did not award constitutional damages in that instance, specifically because the plaintiff claimed "punitive constitutional damages". The Fose case has been followed by most of the cases heard in the years after Fose was decided. In most instances where constitutional damages were claimed the courts, following Fose, have not awarded constitutional damages where delictual damages were available. The rules relating to constitutional damages are casuistic and it is submitted that the principle of subsidiarity could form a foundational principle to solve the problem of casuistry in this regard.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
De Vos P and Freedman W South African Constitutional Law in Context 2nd ed (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2021)
Dendy M "Damages" in Faris JA (ed) Law of South Africa (LexisNexis Durban 2018) vol 14(1)
Department of Human Settlements National Housing Code (Department of Human Settlements Pretoria 2009)
Kika M Fashioning Judicial Remedies that Work in a Constitutional Society Establishing a Framework for a Functional Approach to the Awarding of Constitutional Damages in South Africa Law and Comparative Jurisdictions (PhD-thesis University of Cape Town 2019)
Klopper H Damages (LexisNexis Durban 2017)
Liebenberg S "The Art of the (Im)possible? Justice Froneman's Contribution to Designing Remedies for Structural Human Rights Violations" 2022 CCR 139-169 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR.2022.0006
Loubser MM and Midgley R (eds) The Law of Delict in South Africa 3rd ed (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2017)
Neethling J and Potgieter JM Law of Delict 8th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2020)
Price A "State Liability and Accountability" 2015 Acta Juridica 313-335
Van der Walt JC Delict: Principles and Cases (Butterworths Durban 1979)
Zitzke E "Constitutional Heedlessness and Over-Excitement in the Common Law of Delict's Development" 2015 CCR 259-290 DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR/2015.0011
Zitzke E "Grondwetlike Skadevergoeding as 'Nominale' en 'Verswaarde' Skadevergoeding in Dringende Aansoeke Ngomane v Johannesburg (City) 2020 1 SA 52 (HHA)" 2020 Litnet 790-802
Zitzke E "The Life Esidimeni Arbitration: Towards Transformative Constitutional Damages?" 2020 TSAR 419-440
Case law
Canada
Vancouver (City) v Ward [2010] 2 SCR 28
Ireland
Kennedy v Ireland [1987] IR 587
Conway v Irish National Teachers Organisations [1991] 2 IR 305
New Zealand
Dunlea v Attorney-General [2000] 3 NZLR
Liston-Lloyd v The Commissioner of Police [2015] NZHC 2614
South Africa
Arbitration Award between Families of Mental Health Care Users Affected by the Gauteng Mental Marathon Project (Claimants) and National Minister of Health of the Republic of South Africa, Government of the Province of Gauteng, Premier of the Province of Gauteng, Member of the Executive Council of Health: Province of Gauteng (Respondents) http://www.saflii.org/images/LifeEsidimeniArbitrationAward.pdf accessed 13 March 2023
Dikoko v Mokhatla 2006 6 SA 235 (CC)
Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v Thubakgale (125/2018) [2018] ZASCA 76 (31 May 2018)
Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v Thubakgale (High Court, Gauteng Division, Pretoria) (unreported) case number 39602/2015 of 13 July 2020
Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd v Vaal River Development Association (Pty) Ltd 2023 5 BCLR 527 (CC)
Esorfranki Pipelines (Pty) Ltd v Mopani District Municipality 2023 2 SA 31 (CC)
Esselen v Argus Printing and Publishing Co Ltd 1992 3 SA 764 (T)
Fose v Minister of Safety and Security 1996 2 BCLR 232 (W)
Fose v Minister of Safety and Security 1997 3 SA 786 (CC)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Kate v MEC for the Department of Welfare, Eastern Cape 2005 1 SA 141 (SECLD)
Law Society of South Africa v Minister for Transport 2011 1 SA 400 (CC)
M v Minister of Police 2013 5 SA 622 (GNP)
Mahambehlala v MEC for Welfare, Eastern Cape 2001 1 SA 342 (SE)
Mazibuko v City of Johannesburg 2010 4 SA 1 (CC)
Mbanga v MEC for Welfare, Eastern Cape 2002 1 SA 359 (SE)
Member of the Executive Council: Welfare v Kate 2006 4 SA 478 (SCA)
Minister of Police v Mboweni 2014 6 SA 256 (SCA)
Modderfontein Squatters, Greater Benoni City Council v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd (Agri SA and Legal Resources Centre, Amici Curiae); President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd (Agri SA and Legal Resources Centre, Amici Curiae) 2004 6 SA 40 (SCA)
My Vote Counts NPC v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services 2018 5 SA 380 (CC)
Ngomane v Johannesburg (City) 2020 1 SA 52 (SCA)
Olitzki Property Holdings v State Tender Board 2001 3 SA 1247 (SCA)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd 2005 5 SA 3 (CC)
Residents of Industry House, 5 Davies Street, New Doornfontein, Johannesburg v Minister of Police 2023 3 SA 329 (CC)
RK v Minister of Basic Education 2020 2 SA 347 (SCA)
S v Vermaas; S v Du Plessis 1995 3 SA 292 (CC)
South African Human Rights Commission obo South African Jewish Board of Deputies v Masuku 2022 4 SA 1 (CC) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02587203.2023.2275311
Thubakgale v Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2018 6 SA 584 (GP)
Thubakgale v Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2022 8 BCLR 985 (CC)
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Expropriation Act 63 of 1975
Housing Act 107 of 1997
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995
Internet sources
Office of the Health Ombud 2017 Report into the Circumstances Surrounding the Deaths of Mentally Ill Patients: Gauteng Province http://healthombud.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/FINALREPORT.pdf accessed 8 August 2023
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Andre Mukheibir
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}