The Power to Deduct Pension Benefits Under Lesotho’s Pension Funds Act: Lessons from South Africa and Eswatini
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2025/v28i0a16652Keywords:
Pension deduction, administrative action, withholding of benefits, Pension Funds ActAbstract
The changing demands of society and the emergence of new challenges necessitate the constant evolution and improvement of legal frameworks. In November 2019 Lesotho adopted the Pension Funds Act 5 of 2019 to modernise its regulation and supervision of private pension funds. Previously pension funds were regulated under the Income Tax (Superannuation and Assurance) Regulation, 1994 (Superannuation Regulation). Industry participants were of the opinion that the Superannuation Regulation was inadequate for the complexity of Lesotho's private pension funds system. The primary purpose of the Pension Funds Act of 2019 is to safeguard the financial interests of pension fund contributors and ensure their receipt of retirement benefits on retirement. With limited exceptions, section 40 of the Act prohibits the transfer or deduction of pension benefits. This article investigates the legal framework that regulates the power of a pension fund to deduct from pension benefits as well as the limitations on this power. The purpose of the article is to propose possible interpretations of the power to deduct, with the intention of assisting those who are involved in its implementation.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Berret J "The Application of the Constitutional Right to Just Administrative Action to Registered Pension Funds" 2002 Pensions World 1
Hanekom K The Manual on Retirement Funds South Africa (LexisNexis Durban 2019)
Hunter R et al The Pension Funds Act: A Commentary on the Act, Regulations, Selected Notices, Directives and Circular (Hunter Employee Benefits Law Johannesburg 2010)
Jeram N "Power of Withholding a Pension Benefit Confirmed by Supreme Court of Appeal" 2009 ILJ 804-813
Kaplan A and Frazer M Pension Law 3rd ed (Irwin Law Toronto 2021)
Manamela T "Deductions from Pension Benefits for Purposes of Section 37D of the Pension Funds Act 24 of 1956: Employers Forced to Toe the Line" 2007 SAMLJ 189-203
Manamela ME "'You Break, You Pay': Pension Benefits Deductions for Damage Caused to the Employer by the Employee" 2013 SAMLJ 578-588
Mhango M and Mosito K "The Constitutional Implications of Pension Deductions Under the Pension Funds Act of Lesotho: A Comparative Analysis" 2023 LDD 183-213 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/2077-4907/2023/ldd.v27.7
Shrosbree L "To What Extent Does Section 37D of the Pension Funds Act Protect Employers from Dishonest Conduct by Their Employees?" 2005 ILJ 17-26
Case law
Australia
Asea Brown Boveri Superannuation Fund No 1 Pty Ltd v Asea Brown Boveri Pty Ltd 1999 1 VR 144 DOI: https://doi.org/10.25291/VR/1999-1-VR-144
Karger v Paul 1984 VR 161 DOI: https://doi.org/10.25291/VR/1984-VR-161
Canada
Sloan v Union Oil Co of Canada Ltd 1955 4 DLR 664 (BCSC)
England
Balls v Strutt 1841 1 Hare 146
Cowan v Scargill 1984 2 All ER 750 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt0984-750
Edge v Pensions Ombudsman 1999 4 All ER 546 (CA)
India
DS Nakara vs Union of India 1983 AIR 130, 1983 SCR (2) DOI: https://doi.org/10.25291/VR/1983-2-VR-130
Devaki Nandan Prasad v State of Bihar 1983 AIR 1184, 1983 SCR (2)
Dr Hira Lal v State of Bihar Civil Appeal (Supreme Court of Appeal; Division Bench - Two Judge, Appeal (Civil)) case number 1677-1678 of 18 February 2020
Lesotho
Maloma v Lesotho Brake Clutch and Spares (LC 35 of 98) [2002] LSLC 13 (12 August 2002)
Moqhali v Lesotho Telecommunications Corporation (CIVAPN24793) (NULL) [1993] LSHC 56 (6 October 1993)
Putsoa v Standard Lesotho Bank (LAC/REV 3 of 7) [2007] LSLAC 12 (29 October 2007)
Thabo v Mohatlane Skills Training Centre (CIV/APN 84 of 2013) [2014] LSHC 56 (31 January 2014)
South Africa
Absa Bank Ltd v Burmeister 2005 3 All SA 409 (SCA)
Adam v Consolidated Retirement Fund for Local Government 2023 1 BPLR 1 (PFA)
Allison v IMATU Retirement Fund 2004 7 BPLR 5831 (FPA)
Anax Logistics Services (Pty) Ltd v Qubeka (PFA95/2020) [2021] ZAFST 121 (28 April 2021)
Anstey v Pegasus III Provident Fund 2000 2 BPLR 119 (PFA)
Appanna v Kelvinator Group Services of SA Provident Fund 2000 2 BPLR 126 (PFA)
Atkinson v Southern Field Staff Defined Contribution Pension Fund 2000 4 BPLR 367 (PFA)
Buitendag v Government Employees Pension Fund 2006 4 BPLR 297 (T)
Buthelezi v Municipal Gratuity Fund 2001 5 BPLR 1996 (PFA)
Cebisa Kalimashe v Eskom Pension and Provident Fund (Mthatha High Court) (unreported) case number 561/08 0f 18 November 2018
Chagonda v Transport Sector Retirement Fund 2023 1 BPLR 3 (PFA)
Charlton v Tongaat-Hulett Pension Fund 2006 2 BPLR 94 (D)
Dakin v Southern Sun Retirement Fund 1999 9 BPLR 22 (PFA)
Diale v Netcare 1999 Provident Fund 2022 1 BPLR 6 (PFA)
Erasmus v Mine Employees' Pension Fund 2011 2 BPLR 184 (PFA)
Fundsatwork Umbrella Provident Fund v Ngobeni (PFA64/2020) [2020] ZAFST 6 (3 December 2020)
Gerson v Mondi Pension Fund 2013 6 SA 162 (GSJ)
Hansen Genwest (Pty) Ltd v Corporate Selection Umbrella Retirement Fund 2023 ZAGPJHC 96 (6 February 2023)
Hemraj v Columbus Retirement Fund 2022 5 BPLR 93 (PFA)
Highveld Steel and Vanadium Corporation Ltd v Oosthuizen 2009 2 SA 225 (SCA)
Johannesburg Stock Exchange v Witwatersrand Nigel Ltd 1988 3 SA 132 (AD)
Joint Municipal Pension Fund v Grobler 2007 5 SA 629 (SCA)
Jonck v Retail and Allied Employees Provident Fund 2023 1 BPLR 6 (PFA)
Kim v Agri Staff Pension Fund (2017/47543) [2019] ZAGPJHC 156 (6 February 2019)
Kransdorff v Sentrachem Pension Fund 1999 9 BPLR 55 (PFA)
Lesufi v CSIR Pension Fund 2002 10 BPLR 3927 (PFA)
Letsoalo v Lukhaimane (48743/16) [2017] ZAGPPHC 1246 (13 December 2017)
Makhamo v Corporate Selection Umbrella Retirement Fund No. 2: Participating Employer – Gold Leaf Tobacco Corporation (Pty) Ltd 2020 2 BPLR 422 (PFA)
Malema v Printing Industry Pension Fund (1) 2001 4 BPLR 1867 (PFA)
Manzini v Metro Group Retirement Fund 2001 12 BPLR 2808 (PFA)
Mbatha v Transport Sector Retirement Fund (0016223/19) [2020] ZAGPJHC 18 (19 February 2020)
McNamee v Aeroquip SA (Pty) Ltd 2001 2 BPLR 1618 (PFA)
Mhlaba v Edcon Provident Fund 2020 2 BPLR 448 (PFA)
Moodley v Local Transitional Council of Scottburgh Umzinto North 2000 9 BPLR 945 (D)
Motlokoa v Standard Bank Group Retirement Fund 2020 JOL 52331 (PFA)
Mpuru v Corporate Selection Umbrella Retirement Fund 2022 1 BPLR 19 (PFA)
Msunduzi Municipality v Natal Joint Municipal Pension/Provident Fund 2006 3 BPLR 210 (N)
Ncobela v Edcon Provident Fund 2014 1 BPLR 99 (PFA)
Ndebele v South African National Blood Service Provident Fund 2019 2 BPLR 507 (PFA)
Pillay v RFA Umbrella Provident Fund (PFA) PFA/KN/000026080/2016/UM of 13 December 2016
Power v Old Mutual Superfund Pension Fund 2022 3 BPLR 66 (PFA)
Radebe v Mercedez-Benz South Africa Defined Contribution Provident Fund 2022 1 BPLR 26 (PFA)
Rampone v Blue Ribbon Bakery 2002 12 BPLR 4198 (PFA)
Razlog v PLJ Pension Fund 2003 1 BPLR 4294 (PFA)
Reckitt Benckiser Retirement Fund v BC Gamede Case No PFA 34/2020
Records v Barlows Pension Fund 2000 8 BPLR 920 (PFA)
Rowan v Standard Bank Staff Retirement Fund 2001 2 BPLR 1643 (PFA)
SA Metal Group (Pty) Ltd v Jeftha 2020 1 BPLR 20 (WCC)
Sayed-Essop v The Non-Ferrous Metal Works Pension Fund (2) 2003 7 BPLR 4956 (PFA)
Schoeman v Rentmeester Pensioenfonds 2003 9 BPLR 5145 (PFA)
Scientia Optimate Financial Services (Pty) Ltd v Lukhaimane 2021 JOL 53144 (GP)
Serongwa v Steve Ochse and Partners Provident Fund 2003 6 BPLR 4814 (PFA)
Sitela v MEC for the Provincial Department of Health Eastern Cape Province 2002 6 BPLR 3524 (B)
South African Association of Retired Persons v Transet Ltd 1999 4 All SA 25 (W)
South African Broadcasting Corporation SOC Limited v South African Broadcasting Corporation Pension Fund 2019 4 SA 608 (GJ)
Steenkamp v Consolidated Retirement Fund for Local Government and Another 2018 3 BPLR 770 (PFA)
Tape Aids for the Blind v Palhad (PFA3/2022) [2022] ZAFST 38 (16 May 2022)
Titi v Funds at Work Umbrella Provident Fund (1728/2010) [2011] ZAECMHC 22 (10 March 2011)
Twigg v Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund (1) 2001 12 BPLR 2870 (PFA)
Van Schalkwyk v DSV Flexi Retirement Fund Pension Section 2024 2 BPLR 39 (PFA)
Van Tonder v Motor Industry Provident Fund 2020 2 BPLR 600 (PFA)
Whitelock-Jones v Old Mutual Staff Retirement Fund 2000 6 BPLR 674 (PFA)
Swaziland
Maseko v Central Bank of Swaziland (42 of 2012) [2012] SZSC 64 (30 November 2012)
Standard Bank Limited v Motsa (2401 of 2011) [2012] SZHC 124 (8 June 2012)
Swazi MTN Limited v Nxumalo (898 of 2016) [2016] SZHC 114 (15 July 2016) DOI: https://doi.org/10.32964/TJ15.7
Legislation
Botswana
Retirement Funds Act 38 of 2022
Eswatini
Retirement Funds Act 5 of 2005
Lesotho
Income Tax (Superannuation and Assurance) Regulation, 1994
Pension Funds Act 5 of 2019
Pension Funds (Investments) Regulations, 2020
Public Officers' Defined Contribution Pension Fund Act 8 of 2008
South Africa
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Financial Sector Regulation Act 9 of 2017
Interpretation Act 19 of 1977
Pension Funds Act 24 of 1956
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
Specified Offices Defined Contribution Pension Fund Act 19 of 2011
Government publication
Lesotho
Government Notice 26 of 2019
South Africa
Draft Conduct of Financial Institutions Bill, 2020
Internet sources
Momentum 2021 Legal Update 3/2021: When is It Lawful for a Fund to Withhold a Benefit on Request of an Employer https://eb.momentum.co.za/webDocumentLibrary/LegalUpdates/2021/Legal_Update_3_of_2021_Withholding_of_a_benefit.pdf accessed 14 September 2024
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Mtende Mhango, Teron Rikhotso
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}