A Case for the Need to Improve the Unilateral Double Taxation Relief for Estate Duty in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159//1727-3781/2024/v27i0a17136Keywords:
estate duty, wealth transfer tax, double taxation relief, deceased estateAbstract
This article aims to address a specific problem statement, namely how the unilateral relief under the Estate Duty Act can be enhanced to alleviate the potential hardship of double estate taxation on cross-border estates. Double taxation is a common occurrence when a person owns properties in more than one country, which become part of their estate at the time of death and liable for estate tax. The limited estate tax treaty network causes countries to reconsider their unilateral relief provisions under their domestic legislation. South Africa faces the same challenge under the Estate Duty Act. This article highlights the areas where clarity is needed in relation to the type of foreign death duty that may qualify for tax relief, such as the scope of qualifying foreign property, the exchange rate applicable and the date on which the conversion should be done, as well as the limitations and conditions of the unilateral relief available under the Estate Duty Act. Insights are provided that could be considered for possible amendments to the Estate Duty Act to provide greater clarity and certainty in calculating the estate duty liability payable in South Africa.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Beckmann NF Some Aspects of Estate Duty on Deceased Estates in the Republic of South Africa – with Special Reference to the Problems and Effects of Double Taxation Occurring in Relation to the German Erbschaftsteuergesetz (Inheritance Tax Act) (LLM-dissertation University of Cape Town 1993)
Bornman C Estate Planning: The Impact of Estate Duty and Capital Gains Tax on Offshore Assets (LLM-mini-dissertation North-West University 2010)
Butler Condensed Wealth of Nations
Butler E The Condensed Wealth of Nations and The Incredibly Condensed Theory of Moral Sentiments (Adam Smith Research Trust London 2011)
Croome B Taxpayers' Rights in South Africa: An Analysis and Evaluation of the Extent to which the Powers of the South African Revenue Service Comply with the Constitutional Rights to Property, Privacy, Administrative Justice, Access to Information and Access to Courts (PhD-thesis University of Cape Town 2008)
Davis DM, Jooste RD and Beneke C Estate Planning (electronic version) (LexisNexis Cape Town 2022)
European Commission "Commission Recommendation of 15 December 2011 Regarding Relief for Double Taxation of Inheritances" 2011 OJ 81-84
Ger B "Time for Estate Duty to go?" 2012 De Rebus 59-62
Haupt P Notes on South African Income Tax 39th ed (H & H Publications Roggebaai 2020)
Margo Commission Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Tax Structure of the Republic of South Africa by the Margo Commissioner (Government Printer Pretoria 1987)
Meade JE The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation (George Allen & Unwin London 1978)
Meyerowitz D Meyerowitz on Administration of Estates and their Taxation (Juta Cape Town 2016)
Meyerowitz D "Estate Duty – Successive Deaths – Rebate of Duty under Proviso to First Schedule – Ascertainment of 'Duty Attributable' to the Inclusion in Estate of Second-Dying of Property Inherited from the First-Dying" 1987 The Taxpayer 117-121
Michaelides G The International Tax Consequences Arising on the Death of South African Individuals Owning Greek or Portuguese Property and Greeks or Portuguese Owning South African Property (MCom-dissertation University of Cape Town 2011)
Muller E A Framework for Wealth Transfer Taxation in South Africa (LLD-dissertation University of Pretoria 2010)
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Inheritance Taxation in OECD Countries (OECD Publishing Paris 2021)
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Model Double Taxation Convention on Estates and Inheritances and on Gifts (OECD Publishing Paris 1983)Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital 2017 (Full Version) (OECD Publishing Paris 2019)
Ostaszweska O and Obuoforibo B Roy Rohatgi on International Taxation [Volume 1: Principles] (Juta Cape Town 2020)
Ostler LM The Impact of Estate Planning on the Effectiveness of Estate Duty as a Wealth Tax in South Africa (MCom-dissertation Rhodes University 2012)
Roeleveld J "An Argument for Either Excluding Death as a Capital Gains Tax Event or Abolishing Estate Duty" 2015 SAJAR 143-164
Rudnick RS and Gordon RK "Taxation of Wealth" in Thuronyi V (ed) Tax Law Design and Drafting (International Monetary Fund Washington DC 1996) 292-339
Seade J "Tax Revenue Implications of Exchange Rate Adjustment" in Tanzi V (ed) Fiscal Policy in Open Developing Economies (International Monetary Fund Washington DC 1990) 54-65
Stiglingh M et al Silke: South African Income Tax 2021 (LexisNexis Cape Town 2020)
Thorpe L Is It Time to Abolish Estate Duty in South Africa? A Comparative Look at Global Trends in Levying Death Taxes and the Feasibility of Suggested Changes to South Africa's Current Regime (LLM-dissertation University of Cape Town 2015)
Weber-Frisch N and Duquennois-Djoua R "Domestic Inheritance Tax Rules in EU Member States Regarding Cross-Border Successions" 2014 ERA Forum: Journal of the Academy of European Law 409-424
Whitfield RB Taxation Implications Arising from South African Residents Owning or Having a Tax Interest in Fixed Property in Greece (MCom-dissertation University of South Africa 2008)
Williams RC Income Tax in South Africa: Cases and Materials 4th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2015)
Wilson K Potential Cross-Border Double Taxation on Death Limits Global Investment Opportunities for Long Term South African Resident Investors (MCom-dissertation University of Cape Town 2019)
Case law
De Ferm v Von Lieres und Wilkau (WCHC) (unreported) case number 10805 / 2023 of 11 October 2023
Legislation
South Africa
Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965
Death Duties Act 29 of 1922
Estate Duty Act 45 of 1955
Estate Duty Amendment Act 65 of 1960
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011
United Kingdom
Inheritance Tax Act, 1984
United States
Internal Revenue Code, 1986
Government publications
eSwatini
Legal Notice 80 of 2018 (The Declaration of Change of Swaziland Name Notice, 2018)
Internet resources
Adams & Adams 2018 Eswatini | Swaziland Name Change Made Official by Notice in Gazette https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?
g=278eafa1-d6c5-4be5-9524-10f1900fbe0c accessed 20 September 2023
Dictionary.com 2023 Death Duty https://www.dictionary.com/browse/death-duty accessed 25 March 2023
Davis Tax Committee 2015 First and Interim Report on Estate Duty https://www.taxcom.org.za/docs/20150723%20DTC%20First%20Interim%20Report%20on%20Estate%20Duty%20-%20website.pdf accessed 21 February 2022
European Commission Expert Group 2015 Ways to Tackle Inheritance Cross-Border Tax Obstacles Facing Individuals within the EU https://www.kessler.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Ways-to-tackle-inheritance-cross-border-tax-obstacles.pdf accessed 23 March 2023
Goodwin 2019 The Impact of Exchange Rates when Administering Estates https://www.lawskills.co.uk/articles/2019/10/the-impact-of-exchange-rates-when-administering-estates/ accessed 31 March 2023
HM Revenue & Customs 2023 Foreign Property: Double Taxation Conventions: Procedure with Non-Convention Countries: Introduction https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/inheritance-tax-manual/ihtm27185 accessed 26 September 2023
Internal Revenue Service 2020 International Estate and Gift Tax Examinations https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-025-004 accessed 4 October 2022
Jestle S 2018 Inheritance Tax Regimes: A Comparison https://wiiw.ac.at/inheritance-tax-regimes-a-comparison-dlp-4690.pdf accessed 2 June 2023
Katz Commission 1997 Fourth Report on Capital Transfer http://www.treasury.gov.za/publications/other/katz/4.pdf accessed 10 January 2022
Lambert ITG 1992 Some Modern Principles of Taxation Adam Smith Revisited https://cooperative-individualism.org/lambert-ian_some-modern-principles-of-taxation-adam-smith-revisited-1992-jan.htm accessed 10 January 2022
Merriam-Webster Dictionary 2023 Death Duty https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/death%20duty accessed 25 March 2023
Nevil S 2023 What are Death Taxes? How to Reduce or Avoid Them? https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/death-taxes.asp accessed 25 March 2023
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development date unknown Glossary of Tax Terms https://www.oecd.org/ctp/glossaryoftaxterms.htm accessed 28 March 2023
Oxford Reference 2023 Death Duties https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095704769 accessed 25 March 2023
South African Revenue Service date unknown Estate Duty Agreements https://www.sars.gov.za/legal-counsel/international-treaties-agreements/estate-duty-agreements/ accessed 5 August 2023
South African Revenue Service 2015 Interpretation Note No 63 (Issue 2): Rules for the Translation of Amounts Measured in Foreign Currencies Other than Exchange Differences Governed by Section 24I and the Eighth Schedule https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/LAPD-IntR-IN-2012-63-Rules-Translation-Amounts-Foreign-Currencies.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
South African Revenue Service 2022 Interpretation Note No 18 (Issue 5): Rebate and Deduction for Foreign Taxes on Income https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IN-18-Rebate-and-deduction-for-foreign-taxes-on-income.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
South African Revenue Service 2023 Interpretation Note No 101 (Issue 2): Gains or Losses on Foreign Exchange Transactions https://www.sars.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/Legal/Notes/Legal-IntR-IN-101-Gains-or-losses-on-foreign-exchange-transactions.pdf accessed 26 September 2023
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Maretha Retief
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}