The Impact of the Labour Relations Act on Minority Trade Unions: A South African Perspective

  • Johan Kruger University of south Africa
  • Clarence Itumeleng Tshoose Uuniversity of South Africa
Keywords: Minority unions, collective bargaining, freedom of association, organisational rights, international labour standards.

Abstract

The advent of the new political dispensation in 1994 heralded the coming of a new labour dispensation. Labour relations and labour policies changed significantly from that which prevailed under the previous government. The review of the labour legislation framework was at that stage a priority for the new government, with specific focus on the review of the collective bargaining dispensation.

 

The abuse of trade unions under the previous government gave rise to a unique entrenchment of labour rights in the Constitution. The drafters thereof were determined to avoid a repetition of this abuse after 1994. Section 23 of the Constitution goes to great lengths to protect, amongst others, the right to form and join a trade union, the right of every trade union to organise and the right of every trade union to engage in collective bargaining. In furtherance of section 23(5) of the Constitution, the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 was promulgated. One of the most significant changes of the LRA was that it now provided for legislated organisational rights.

 

Commentators have often viewed the LRA as favouring larger unions and as conferring clear advantages on unions with majority support at the establishment or industry level.  It is within this context that this article examines the impact of section 18 of the LRA on the constitutionally entrenched right of every person to freedom of association, the right of every trade union to engage in collective bargaining, and the right of every trade union to organise. Furthermore, this article explores the justifiability of the impact of section 18 on minority trade unions in terms of international labour standards and the Constitution. In part one the article examines the concept of majoritarianism, pluralism and industrial unionism in the context of South African Labour market. Part two deals with the impact of section 18 of the LRA on minority Trade Unions. Whilst part three explores the concept of workplace democracy. Part five investigates the applicability of international labour standards in the context of the right to freedom of association. Part four ends up with conclusion and recommendations on the impact of section 18 of the LRA.

   ScienceOpen_Log0343291.png

References

Bibliography

Adams 2009 CLELJ

Adams RJ "Fraser v Ontario and International Human Rights: A Comment" 2009 CLELJ 377-392

Baskin and Satgar New Labour Relations

Baskin J and Satgar V South Africa’s New Labour Relations Act: A Critical Assessment and Challenges for Labour (National Labour Economic and Development Institute Johannesburg 1995)

Bellamy 2012 CRISPP

Bellamy R "Rights as Democracy" 2012 CRISPP 1-23

Bendix Industrial Relations

Bendix S Industrial Relations in South Africa 4th ed (Juta Cape Town 2001)

Brassey Employment and Labour Law

Brassey M Employment and Labour Law (Juta Cape Town 1998)

Budeli 2009 Fundamina

Budeli M "Workers' Rights to Freedom of Association and Trade Unionism in South Africa: An Historical Perspective" 2009 Fundamina 57-74

Buhlungu 1999 African Sociology Review

Buhlungu S "A Question of Power: Co-Determination and Trade Union Capacity" 1999 African Sociology Review 111-129

Cheadle 1994 Current Labour Law

Cheadle H "Workplace Forums" 1994 Current Labour Law 69-75

Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook

Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)

Dugard Essays

Dugard J Essays in Honour of Ellison Kahn - The Place of Public International Law in South African Law (Juta Cape Town 1989)

Du Toit et al Labour Relations Law

Du Toit D et al Labour Relations Law: A Comprehensive Guide 4th ed (Lexis Nexis Butterworths Durban 2003)

Dworkin 1987 USFL Rev

Dworkin R "What is Equality? Part 4: Political Equality" 1987 USFL Rev 1-30

Emerson 1964 Yale L Rev

Emerson T "Freedom of Association and Freedom of Expression" 1964 Yale L Rev 1-35

Grogan Collective Labour Law

Grogan J Collective Labour Law (Juta Cape Town 2007)

ILO Law on Freedom of Association

ILO Law on Freedom of Association: Standards and Procedures (ILO Geneva 1995)

Lister 2012 Stan J Int’l L

Lister M "There is No Human Right to Democracy: But May We Promote it Anyway" 2012 Stan J Int’l L 257-276

Macun 1997 LDD

Macun I "Does size matter? The Labour Relations Act, majoritarianism and union structure" 1997 LDD 69-82

Malan 2010 TSAR

Malan K "Observations on representivity, democracy and homogenisation" 2010 TSAR 427-448

Muhammad 2010 Far East Journal of Psychology and Business

Muhammad T "The role of labour unions beyond collective bargaining" 2010 Far East Journal of Psychology and Business 79-82

Olivier Dissipline, Ontslag en Menseregte Handleiding

Olivier HJ Dissipline, Ontslag en Menseregte Handleiding 3rd ed (Laboras Pretoria 2006)

Olivier 1996 ILJ

Olivier M "Workplace Forums: Critical Questions from a Labour Law Perspective" 1996 Industrial Law Journal 803-814

Olivier Managing Employment Relations

Olivier HJ Managing Employment Relations in South Africa: Collective Bargaining and Collective Agreements (Lecture notes handed out to LLM / M Phil in Labour Law SA students at the University of Johannesburg, 22 February 2006)

Satgar 1998 LDD

Satgar V "The LRA and Work-place Forums: Legislative Provisions, Origins, and Transformative Possibilities" 1998 LDD 43-60

Steadman 2004 ILJ

Steadman F "Workplace Forums in South Africa: A Critical Analysis" 2004 ILJ 1170-1202

Van der Walt Democratisation of the Workplace

Van der Walt R The Democratisation of the Workplace in Selected South African Organisations (D Comm-thesis UP 2002)

Van Niekerk et al Law @ Work

Van Niekerk A et al Law @ Work 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2011)

Vettori Alternative Means

Vettori S Alternative Means to Regulate the Employment Relationship in the Changing World of Work (LLD-thesis UP 2005)

Wall 2006 Journal of Political Philosophy

Wall S "Democracy, Authority and Publicity" 2006 Journal of Political Philosophy 85-100

Wood and Mahabir 2001 Industrial Relations Journal

Wood G and Mahabir P "South Africa's Workplace Forum System: A Stillborn Experiment in the Democratisation of Work" 2001 Industrial Relations Journal 230-241

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995

Register of international documents

African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (1981) (Banjul Charter)

European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (1950)

Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention (1948) (Convention No. 87)

ILO Declaration of Philadelphia (1944)

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)

Register of case law

Avril Elizabeth Home for the Mentally Handicapped v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration 2006 ZALC 122

Demir and Baykara v Turkey 2008 ECHR 1345

Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie 2006 3 BCLR 355 (CC)

National Union of Metalworkers v Bader Bop (Pty) Ltd 2003 24 ILJ (CC)

OCGAWU v Volkswagen of South Africa (Pty) Ltd 2002 23 ILJ 220 (CCMA)

South African National Defence Union v Minister of Defence 1999 20 ILJ 2265 (CC)

South African Post Office Ltd v Commissioner Nowosenetz 2013 2 BLLR 216 (LC)

The Glass, Cement and Soil Industries Workers' Union Case No 2303 (Turkey) (2003)

Wilson v UK 2002 35 EHRR 523

Register of interviews

Interview 1: Gideon du Plessis: Deputy-General Secretary (Solidarity Trade Union) 2012

Interview 2: André van der Merwe: Head Mining Industry (Solidarity Trade Union) 2012

Interview 3: Louis Pretorius: Senior National Organiser: Mining (Solidarity Trade Union) 2012

Register of internet sources

Blackett and Sheppard 2002 www.ilo.org

Blackett A and Sheppard C 2002 The Links Between Collective Bargaining and Equality www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_norm/---declaration/

documents/publication/wcms_decl_wp_12_en.pdf [date of use 22 Nov 2012]

DPRU 2008 blogs.uct.ac.za

DPRU 2008 Policy Brief Series, School of Economics, University of Cape Town, April 2008, 10 blogs.uct.ac.za/blog/development-policy-research-unit [date of use 22 Nov 2012]

Godfrey, Theron and Visser 2007 www.dpru.uct.ac.za

Godfrey S, Theron J and Visser M 2007 The State of Collective Bargaining in South Africa: An Empirical and Conceptual Study of Collective Bargaining www.dpru.uct.ac.za/?q=node/216 [date of use 25 Feb 2013]

ILO 2005 www.ilo.org

ILO 2005 The Role of Trade Unions in the Global Economy and the Fight against Poverty (International Labour Organisation, Bureau for Workers' Activities Background Paper International Workers' Symposium Geneva 17-21 October 2005) www.ilo.org/actrav/what/events/WCMS_111309/lang--en/index.htm [date of use 25 Feb 2013]

ILO 2006 www.ilo.org

ILO 2006 Freedom of Association Digest of Decisions and Principles of the Freedom of Association Committee of the Governing Body of the ILO, International Labour Office, Geneva (5th edition 2006) www.ilo.org/wcmsps/... [date of use 25 Feb 2013]

Published
2017-05-17
How to Cite
KrugerJ., & TshooseC. I. (2017). The Impact of the Labour Relations Act on Minority Trade Unions: A South African Perspective. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(4), 284-326. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i4a2416
Section
Articles