The Future of Collective Bargaining between Labour and the Employer after the Case of Public Servants Association v Minister of Public Service [2021] 3 BLLR 255 (LAC)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2024/v27i0a15350Keywords:
public service, collective bargaining, Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC), Department of Public Service and Administration (DPSA), trade unions, resolution/agreement, National Treasury, strike, labour relations, Labour Relations Act (LRA), federation, tripartite alliance, wageAbstract
This case note seeks to determine the future of collective bargaining after the Labour Appeal Court (LAC) judgment in Public Servants Association v Minister of Public Service [2021] 3 BLLR 255 (LAC). In arriving at a conclusion, context is provided. As part of the context it is shown that the right to engage in collective bargaining is not synonymous with the legal right to collective bargaining. This is based on the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, case law and international law. Despite this, it is demonstrated that it can be argued that collective bargaining can be accepted as a recognised practice (a right) when one uses the test of what is a custom. It is further revealed that the main parties in public sector collective bargaining are the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC), the Department of Public Service and Administration, and trade unions. The last two ordinarily have competing interests and the PSCBC is the platform where they resolve their differences and enter into collective agreements. In 2018 a three-year wage agreement was reached for public servants, which the employer failed to implement in its last year. This led to the PSCBC intervening in the matter, but before it could reach fruition the matter was scheduled to be heard by the court. The last leg of the agreement was declared to be invalid and unenforceable on the basis that it was unaffordable and did not comply with the legal prescripts. This led to a period of uncertainty (2022-2023). This period saw government employees receiving 0% salary increases, failed wage negotiations, the unilateral imposition of a wage increase by the employer, a disruptive strike, and shorter wage agreements to address the shortcoming identified by the LAC in PSA v DPSA. The context provided yields the answer (the conclusion) that there is still room for collective bargaining, but that it will be filled with turbulence.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Adams RJ "Collective Bargaining as a Minimum Employment Standard" 2011 The Economic and Labour Relations Review 153-164
Amoako S 2012 "Cogs in the Wheel: Teacher Unions and Public Sector Strikes in Post-Apartheid South Africa, 1999-2010" Labour, Capital and Society 85-110
Botha C Statutory Interpretation: An Introduction for Students 6th ed (Juta Cape Town 2022)
Botha MM "Responsible Unionism During Collective Bargaining and Industrial Action: Are We Ready Yet?" 2015 De Jure 328-350
Derber M "Collective Bargaining, Mutuality, and Workers Participation in Management: An International Analysis" 1980 Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 187-201
Finnemore M, Koekemoer GM and Joubert YT Introduction to Labour Relations in South Africa 12th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2018)
Garbers C, Le Roux PAK and Strydom EML The New Essential Labour Law Handbook 7th ed (Mace Labour Law Publication CC Centurion 2019)
Gyesie N Exploring the Impact of Collective Bargaining Agreements on Employee Performance Management (Doctoral dissertation Walden University 2017)
Heywood A Politics 5th ed (Red Globe Press London 2019)
Hutchison D and Pretorius CJ (eds) The Law of Contract in South Africa 3rd ed (Oxford Cape Town 2017)
Leppan F, Govindjee A and Cripps B "Bargaining in Bad Faith in South African Labour Law: An Antidote?" 2016 Obiter 474-486
Mahmood Z and Banerjee S "Towards what End? Collective Bargaining and the Making and Unmaking of the Working Class" 2023 Economic and Industrial Democracy 964-985
McGregor M et al Labour Rules 4th ed (Siber Ink Cape Town 2021)
Molusi AP "The Constitutional Duty to Engage in Collective Bargaining" 2010 Obiter 156-166
Pillay D "The South African Essential Services Committee Part I: The Definition of Essential Services in South Africa" 2001 Southern African Business Review 57-60
Van Niekerk A et al Law@Work 5th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2018)
Case law
Absa Bank Ltd v Naude 2016 6 SA 540 (SCA)
Judicial Service Commission v Cape Bar Council 2013 1 SA 170 (SCA)
Minister for the Public Service and Administration v National Education, Health and Allied Workers Union [2023] JOL 58172 (LC)
National Education Health and Allied Workers Union v Minister of Public Service and Administration 2022 6 BCLR 673 (CC)
NEHAWU v Minister for the Public Service and Administration 2023 6 BLLR 487 (LAC)
Public Servants Association v Minister of Public Service and Administration 2021 3 BLLR 255 (LAC)
Shilubana v Nwamitwa 2008 9 BCLR 914 (CC)
SANDU v Minister of Defence 2007 8 BCLR 863 (CC)
SANDU v Minister of Defence; Minister of Defence v SANDU 2007 4 BCLR 398 (SCA)
Van Breda v Jacobs 1921 AD 330
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995
Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999
Superior Courts Act 10 of 2013
International instruments
Collective Bargaining Recommendation No. 163 of 1981
Convention (No 154) Concerning the Promotion of Collective Bargaining (1981)
Government publications
GNR 1396 in GG 42121 of 19 December 2018
Internet sources
Congress of South African Trade Unions date unknown Contact Union http://mediadon.co.za/unions-contact/ accessed 16 April 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2019a Circular No 01 of 2019 https://www.dpsa.gov.za/dpsa2g/documents/rp/2019/18_1_p_30_
_2019.pdf accessed 16 April 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2019b Adjustment of the Housing Allowance for Public Service Employees https://www.dpsa.gov.za/
dpsa2g/documents/cos/2019/17_3_p_05_08_2019.pdf accessed 23 February 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2020 Adjustment of the Housing Allowance for Public Service Employees https://www.dpsa.gov.za/dpsa2g/documents/cos/2020/17_3_p_24_7_2020.pdf accessed 23 February 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2022a Circular No 47 of 2022 https://www.dpsa.gov.za/dpsa2g/documents/cos/2022/17_3_p_4_
_2022.pdf accessed 17 April 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2022b Circular No 50 of 2022 https://www.dpsa.gov.za/dpsa2g/documents/rp/2022/18_1_p_26_
_2022A.pdf accessed 24 February 2023
Department of Public Service and Administration 2023 Circular No 20 of 2023 https://www.dpsa.gov.za/dpsa2g/documents/rp/2023/18_1_p_06_
_2023.pdf accessed 20 April 2023
Duma N 2022 SADTU Takes Govt's 3% Salary Hike Offer, Says Wage Strike Won't Benefit Members https://ewn.co.za/2022/10/06/sadtu-takes-govt-s-3-salary-hike-offer-says-wage-strike-won-t-benefit-members accessed 16 April 2023
Federation of Unions of South Africa 2021 Affiliated Trade Unions http://www.fedusa.org.za/unions-2/ accessed 17 April 2023
Grawitzky R 2011 Collective Bargaining in Times of Crisis: A Case Study of South Africa https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_dialogue/---dialogue/documents/publication/wcms_175009.pdf accessed 23 January 2024
National Education, Health and Allied Workers' Union 2023 NEHAWU Clarifies Public Service Strike at Newsroom Afrika https://www.nehawu.org.za/NEHAWU%20Statement%20On%20The%20Public%20Service%20Strike%2015%20March%202023.html accessed 17 April 2023
National Treasury 2023 Media Statement: 2023 Public Sector Coordinated Bargaining Council Outcome https://www.treasury.gov.za/comm_media/
press/2023/2023033101%20Media%20statement%20-%202023%20Public%20sector%20coordinated%20bargaining%20council%20outcome.pdf accessed 19 April 2023
Public Servants Association 2022 Media Release: PSA/Fedusa Public-Service Strike to Continue on 10 November 2022 https://www.psa.co.za/docs/default-source/psa-documents/media-statements/psa-fedusa-public-service-strike-to-continue-on-10-november-2022.pdf?sfvrsn=59996bfc_4 accessed 17 April 2023
Public Servants Association 2023 Public Service Wage Negotiations Update https://www.psa.co.za/docs/default-source/psa-documents/news
letters/2023-to-be-used-from-3-january-2023/pscbc-17022023.pdf?sfvrsn=5dab0434_4 accessed 27 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2017 Public Service Co-Ordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC): Information Brochure https://pscbc.org.za/index.php/sample-page/pscbc-information-brochure accessed 23 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2018 PSCBC Resolutions 2018 https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/collective-bargaining/psbc-resolutions-docman/2018-1 accessed 23 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2021a PSCBC Resolutions 2021 https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/collective-bargaining/psbc-resolutions-docman/2021 accessed 24 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2021b Vote Weights https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/collective-bargaining/vote-weights accessed 27 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2022 Press Release: Public Service Wage Negotiations https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/docman/media-statements/2231-pscbc-media-release-update-on-wage-negotiations-081122/file accessed 24 February 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2023a Press Release: PSCBC: Breakthrough of Impasse https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/
docman/media-statements/2250-pscbc-media-release-140323-oo-bn-002/file accessed 17 April 2023
Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council 2023b PSCBC Resolutions 2023 https://pscbc.co.za/index.php/collective-bargaining/psbc-resolutions-docman/2023 accessed 16 April 2023
Sithole S 2022 Police Union Withdraws its SAFTU Affiliation https://www.iol.co.za/the-star/news/police-union-withdraws-its-saftu-affiliation-24705195-4afd-4615-9930-7ffc9def82e4 accessed 17 April 2023
South African Federation of Trade Unions 2023 Affiliates https://saftu.org.za/affiliates/ accessed 17 April 2023
South African Government 2022 Public Service and Administration on 2022/23 Public Service Wage Negotiations https://www.gov.za/speeches/update-202223-public-service-wage-negotiations-9-nov-2022-0000 accessed 24 February 2023
Staff Reporter 1999 Nehawu Rejects Implementation https://mg.co.za/article/1999-08-17-nehawu-rejects-implementation/ accessed 2 May 2023
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Matthews Eddie Nkuna-mavutane, Brigitte Barends , Vukile Ezrom Sibiya, Clarence Itumeleng Tshoose, Reuben Letseku
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}