A Customary Right to Fish when Fish are Sparse: Managing Conflicting Claims between Customary Rights and Environmental Rights
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i5a2448Keywords:
Custom, Customary law, Customary rights, Marine resources, Conservation, Environment.Abstract
This contribution considers the potential conflicts that may arise between customary rights and environmental rights in the face of dwindling marine resources. It sets the scene by reflecting on some of the common themes present in indigenous claims to marine resource by communities who were subjected to colonisation. In doing so it analyses the South African judgment, S v Gongqose Case No. E382/10 (unreported), which alluded to the existence of a customary right to fishing, a concept that has until now remained unexplored in South African law. This discussion is followed by a brief overview of the rapidly declining state of marine resources, worldwide and in South Africa. The note then considers the relationship between customary law and marine resources and some of the challenges in meeting rights-based customary claims to marine resources against the need to conserve a dwindling resource. It concludes by offering possibilities for reconciliation.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
ACHPR Report
African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights Report of the African Commission's Working Group of Experts on Indigenous Populations/Communities (ACHPR Banjul 2005)
Bennett Customary Law
Bennett TW Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2007)
Blumm 1989-1990 Wis Int'l L J
Blumm M "Native Fishing Rights and Environmental Protection in North America and New Zealand: A Comparative Analysis of Profits A Prendre and Habitat Servitudes" 1989-1990 Wis Int'l L J 1-4
Charlton Constitutional Conflicts
Charlton G Constitutional Conflicts and Aboriginal Rights: Hunting, Fishing and Gathering Rights in Canada, New Zealand and the United States (PhD-thesis University of Auckland 2009)
Cheadle "Limitation of Rights"
Cheadle H "Limitation of Rights" in Cheadle H, Davis D and Haysom N (eds) South African Constitutional Law: The Bill of Rights (LexisNexis Durban 2013) ch 3
Cornell "Indigenous Peoples"
Cornell S "Indigenous Peoples, Poverty, and Self-Determination in Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and the United States" in Eversole R, McNeish J and Cimadamore AD Indigenous Peoples and Poverty: An International Perspective (Zed Books London 2005) ch 11
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2006)
Fabricius and Koch "Fundamentals of Community-Based Natural Resource Management"
Fabricius C and Koch E "The Fundamentals of Community-Based Natural Resource Management" in Fabricius C and Koch E (eds) Rights, Resources and Rural Development: Community-Based Natural Resource Management in Southern Africa (Earthscan London 2004) 3-43
FAO State of World Fisheries
United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation The State of World Fisheries And Aquaculture (FAO Rome 2012)
Fay 2009 World Development
Fay D "Land Tenure, Land Use, and Land Reform at Dwesa-Cwebe, South Africa: Local Transformations and the Limits of the State" 2009 World Development 1424-1433
Notzke Aboriginal Peoples
Notzke C Aboriginal Peoples and Natural Resources in Canada (Captus Press North York 1994)
Ntshona 2010 Development Southern Africa
Ntshona Z et al "From land rights to environmental entitlements: Community discontent in the 'successful' Dwesa-Cwebe land claim in South Africa" 2010 Development Southern Africa 353-361
Palmer, Timmermans and Fay From Conflict to Negotiation
Palmer R, Timmermans H and Fay D (eds) From Conflict to Negotiation: Nature-Based Development on the South African Wild Coast (HSRC Pretoria 2000)
Pinkerton and Weinstein Fisheries That Work
Pinkerton E and Weinstein M Fisheries That Work: Sustainability Through Community-Based Management (David Suzuki Foundation Vancouver 1995)
Sowman 2006 Marine Policy
Sowman M "Subsistence and small-scale fisheries in South Africa: A ten-year review" 2006 Marine Policy 60-73
Wachira Mukundi Constitutional and Legislative Protection
Wachira Mukundi G The Constitutional and Legislative Protection of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Country Report of the Research Project by the International Labour Organization and the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights (Centre for Human Rights Pretoria 2009)
Walter, M'Gonigle and McKay 2000 McGill L J
Walter E, M'Gonigle M and McKay C "Fishing Around the Law: The Pacific Salmon Management System as a 'Structural Infringement' of Aboriginal Rights" 2000 McGill L J 263-314
Wicomb and Smith 2011 AHRLJ
Wicomb W and Smith H "Customary communities as 'peoples' and their customary tenure as 'culture': What we can do with the Endorois decision" 2011 AHRLJ 422-446
Wilkinson Messages from Frank's Landing
Wilkinson C Messages from Frank's Landing: A Story of Salmon, Treaties, and the Indian Way (University of Washington Press Seattle 2000)
Worm and Branch 2012 Trends in Ecology and Evolution
Worm B and Branch TA "The Future of Fish" 2012 Trends in Ecology and Evolution 594-599
WWF Sanlam Living Waters Partnership Report
World Wide Fund for Nature Sanlam Living Waters Partnership Report on Proposed Opening of Tsitsikamma MPA to Fishing (WWF Cape Town 2004)
Register of case law
Alexkor Ltd v Richtersveld Community 2004 5 SA 460 (CC)
Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education 1998 12 BCLR 1449 (CC)
Kruger v The Queen 1978 1 SCR 104
Mabo v Queensland (No 2) 1992 175 CLR 1
R v Van der Peet 1993 80 BCLR (2d) 75
R v Van der Peet 1996 2 SCR 507
S v Gongqose Case No. E382/10 (unreported)
Settlement Agreement in terms of Section 42D of the Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994: The Dwesa-Cwebe Community Land Restitution Claim
Te Weehi v Regional Fisheries Officer 1986 1 NZLR 680
United States v Washington 384 F Supp 312 (WD Wash 1974)
United States v Washington (Phase I) 506 F Supp 187 (WD Wash 1980)
Register of legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Canadian Constitution Act, 1982
Marine Living Resources Act 18 of 1998
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998
Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994
Torres Strait Fisheries Act, 1984
Register of international instruments
Torres Strait Treaty (1978)
Register of government publications
GN R1429 in GG 21948 of 29 December 2000
GN 474 in GG 35455 of 20 June 2012 (Policy for the Small Scale Fisheries Sector in South Africa (2012))
Register of internet sources
Traffic 2010 www.traffic.org
Traffic 2010 Removal of Trade Controls Signals Bleak Future for Abalone www.traffic.org/home/2010/6/4/removal-of-trade-controls-signals-bleakfuture-for-abalone.html [date of use May 2013]
WWF Date Unknown www.wwf.org.za
World Wide Fund for Nature Date Unknown Marine Protected Areas www.wwf.org.za/what_we_do/marine/mpas/ [date of use May 2013]
WWF 2011 www.wwf.org.za
World Wide Fund for Nature 2011 Fisheries: Facts and Trends in South Africa www.wwf.org.za/media_room/publications/?7004/fisheries-facts-and-trends [date of use May 2013]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Loretta Feris
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}