The Use of a Therapeutic Jurisprudence Approach to the Teaching and Learning of Law to a New Generation of Law Students in South Africa

Authors

  • Elmarie Fourie University of Johannesburg
  • Enid Coetzee Universityn of Johannesburg

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i1a2468

Keywords:

Teaching and learning, new generation law students, challenges, social, cultural, economic, linguistic barriers, learning about and learning to be, competitive legal profession, integrated teaching approach towards legal skills, therapeutic jurisprudence

Abstract

In rapidly changing social, economic and intellectual environments it is imperative that teaching and learning should be transformed from being primarily concerned with the transmission of knowledge (learning about) to being primarily concerned with the practices of a knowledge domain (learning to be). Law lecturers are faced with a new generation of law students, many of whom may be the first in their families to enter university, and one of the important challenges that we face, when educating law students, is how to enable these students to take their place in a very important profession. To meet this challenge it is necessary to instill skills that will be beneficial to the profession, future clients and the community as a whole. We at the University of Johannesburg are endeavouring to do so through embracing a therapeutic jurisprudence approach that focuses on the well-being of the student, the client and the community.

 

The integration of therapeutic jurisprudence throughout the law student's studies, starting with orientation and continuing through to the final-year clinical experience, will enhance the therapeutic outcomes for all of the parties involved. A therapeutic jurisprudence approach, combined with appropriate teaching and learning methods, will enhance the student's interpersonal skills and writing and reading skills.

 

The teaching methods invoked include role-play to transform formal knowledge into living knowledge, thereby stimulating students' natural practical curiosity and creating a learning environment that supports collaboration and encourages students to act purposefully in such an environment.

 

This article discusses the teaching of first-generation students and how to overcome the existing social, cultural, economic and linguistic barriers by using a therapeutic jurisprudence approach, while upholding the values that should guide legal practice, such as integrity and respect for diversity and human dignity. The constitutional imperative of access to justice for all underlines the importance for law teachers of incorporating therapeutic jurisprudence in their teaching methods.

 

In South Africa, law lecturers face many challenges in teaching law students and first-generation students. Passionate teachers will produce passionate students and realise that they have the power to transform thoughts, policies and lives. Students should be reminded that law is not just about financial rewards, but the ultimate reward of contributing to the betterment of society.

 

The legal profession expects us to produce a well-rounded graduate for entry into the profession. This necessitates that our teaching methods be appropriate to prepare the student for an entry level of competence for the legal profession. Therapeutic jurisprudence creates the opportunity for the lecturer not only to equip the student with the skills required by the profession but to implement teaching methods that will prove to be beneficial for all of the role-players involved. The honing of skills such as legal writing and oral advocacy from the first year of study creates the opportunity for the students to develop to their full potential. In order to support a meaningful, integrated teaching approach, the development of skills is expanded on during each year of study and can prove beneficial to all role-players during clinical education, where the student has the opportunity to apply the acquired skills in real-life situations. The impact of a therapeutic jurisprudence on the development of legal skills can now be measured through the student's ability to focus on the well-being of the client and the community.

    1_ScienceOpen_Log03432115.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bibliography

Baker 2006 Whittier L Rev

Baker G "Do you hear the knocking at the door? A 'therapeutic' approach to enriching clinical legal education comes calling" 2006 Whittier L Rev 1-16

Baker and Zawid 2005 St Thomas L Rev

Baker G and Zawid J "The birth of a therapeutic courts externship program: hard labor but worth the effort" 2005 St Thomas L Rev 711-742

Boyle and Dunn 1998 Alb L Rev

Boyle RA and Dunn R "Teaching law students through individual learning styles" 1998 Alb L Rev 213-247

Chanen 2007 ABAJ

Chanen JS "Re-engineering the JD: Schools across the country are teaching less about the law and more about lawyering" 2007 ABAJ 42

Cooney 2005 St Thomas L Rev

Cooney LL "Heart and soul: A new rhythm for clinical externships" 2005 St Thomas L Rev 407-428

Cooney 2007-8 Ky L J

Cooney LL "Giving millennials a leg-up: How to avoid the 'If I knew then what I know now' syndrome" 2007-8 Ky L J 505-525

Corrigal Sunday Independent

Corrigal M 'Generation Disappointment' The Sunday Independent 24 October 2010 7-8

Gould and Perlin 2000 Seattle U L Rev

Gould KK and Perlin ML "'Johnny's in the Basement/Mixing up His Medicine': Therapeutic Jurisprudence and Clinical Teaching" 2000 Seattle U L Rev 339-371

Greenbaum 2004 Stell L Rev

Greenbaum LA "Teaching legal writing at South African law faculties: A review of the current position and suggestions for the incorporation of a model based on new theoretical perspectives" 2004 Stell L Rev 1-21

Haggis 2006 Studies in Higher Education

Haggis T "Pedagogies for diversity: retaining critical challenge amidst fears of dumbing down" 2006 Studies in Higher Education 521-535

Hattie Visible Learning

Hattie J Visible Learning: A Synthesis of Meta-analyses Relating to Achievement (Routledge London 2009)

Herrington, Oliver and Reeves 2003 Australian Journal of Educational Technology

Herrington J, Oliver R and Reeves TC "Patterns of engagement in authentic online learning activities" 2003 Australian Journal of Educational Technology 59-71

Kasting 2006 NJLJ

Kasting T "The 'Millennial' Law Student Generation" 2006 NJLJ 185-265

Killen Teaching Strategies

Killen R Teaching Strategies for Quality Teaching and Learning (Juta Cape Town 2010)

Kochan 2011 Sw L Rev

Kochan DJ "'Learning' research and legal education: a brief overview and selected bibliographical survey" 2011 Sw L Rev 449-471

Kreiling 1981 Md L Rev

Kreiling K "Clinical education and lawyer competency: The process of learning to learn from experience through properly structured clinical supervision" 1981 Md L Rev 284-288

Lombardi 2007 Educause Learning Initiative

Lombardi MM “Authentic learning for the 21st century: An overview” Educause Learning Initiative Paper 1:2007 1-12

Phelps 1986 Sw L J

Phelps TG "The new legal rhetoric"1986 Sw L J 1089-1102

Taylor Smith, Miller and Bermeo Bridging the Gaps to Success

Taylor Smith C, Miller A and Bermeo CA Bridging the Gaps to Success (Pell Institute Washington, DC 2009)

Van Zyl Safenet Report

Van Zyl A Safenet Report (University of Johannesburg Johannesburg 2011)

Wexler 1992 Law and Human Behaviour

Wexler DB "Putting Mental Health into Mental Health Law: Therapeutic Jurisprudence" 1992 Law and Human Behaviour 27-38

Wexler 1996 Applied & Preventive Psychol

Wexler DB "Applying the Law Therapeutically" 1996 Applied & Preventive Psychol 179-186

Register of legislation

Children's Act 38 of 2005

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Register of case law

Minister of Welfare and Population Development v Fitzpatrick 2000 3 SA 422 (CC)

Register of Internet sources

Amory, Gravett and Van der Westhuizen 2008 ujdigispace.uj.ac.za

Amory A, Gravett S and Van der Westhuizen D 2008 Teaching and learning at the University of Johannesburg: a position paper https://ujdigispace.uj.ac.za

/handle/10210/4270 [date of use 10 March 2012]

Australasian Therapeutic Jurisprudence Clearinghouse 2007 aija.org.au

Australasian Therapeutic Jurisprudence Clearinghouse 2007 Legal and Judicial Education aija.org.au/research/australasian-therapeutic-jurisprudence-clearing

house/legal-and-judicial-education.html [date of use 22 June 2011]

McQuoid-Mason [date unknown] law.gsu.edu

McQuoid-Mason D [date unknown] Legal aid services and human rights in South Africa law.gsu.edu/ccunningham/LegalEd/SouthAfrica-McQuoid-Mason-PILI.pdf [date of use 7 May 2011]

Wexler 1999 www.law.arizona.edu

Wexler DB 1999 Therapeutic Jurisprudence: An Overview law.arizona.edu/depts

/upr-intj/intj-welcome.html [date of use 15 May 2008]

Published

22-05-2017

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Fourie, E., & Coetzee, E. (2017). The Use of a Therapeutic Jurisprudence Approach to the Teaching and Learning of Law to a New Generation of Law Students in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 15(1), 367-390. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i1a2468

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1195

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.