The relevance of a contextualisation of the state-individual relationship for child victims of armed Conflict
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i2a2483Keywords:
State-individual relationship, armed conflict, child victims, public subjective rights, Reformed traditionAbstract
The relationship between the individual and the State is discussed in this contribution. The argument is put forward that both the State and the individual are legal subjects endowed with legal subjectivity. In their relationship it must be accepted that the State is not only endowed with State sovereignty, but also that it prescriptively makes use of its authority. However, theirs is a legal relationship characterised by reciprocal rights and duties so that the balance point in their relationship must as a matter of course be determined legally. As an explanatory model the theory of public subjective rights, which is of German origin, is applied. This theory can serve only as a starting point, though, as it fails to address certain fundamental questions. The viewpoints of authors of the so-called Reformed Tradition will therefore be applied to elaborate on the theory. By adopting this approach it is endeavoured to explain that the relationship between the State and the individual may not be viewed as one characterised by the abuse of State authority or excessive individual claims against the State.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Alexy Theorie der Grundrechte
Alexy R Theorie der Grundrechte 2nd ed (Nomos Baden-Baden 1985)
Barth Rechtfertigung und Recht
Barth K Rechtfertigung und Recht (Evangelisher Zurich 1942)
Baur 1988 Archiv des Öffentliches Rechts
Baur F "Altes und neues zur Schutznormtheorie" 1988 Archiv des Öffentliches Rechts 133, 582
Bühler Subjektiv-öffentlichen Rechte
Bühler O Die Subjektiv-öffentlichen Rechte und ihr Schutz in der Deutschen Verwaltungrechtsprechung (Kohlhammer Berlin 1914)
Cronjé and Heaton South African Law of Persons
Cronjé DSP and Heaton J The South African Law of Persons 3rd ed (LexisNexis Durban 2008)
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2006)
De Jouvenel Über die Staatsgewalt
De Jouvenel B Über die Staatsgewalt (Rombach Freiburg im Breisgau 1972)
Detterbeck Öffentliches Recht
Detterbeck S Öffentliches Recht (Verlag Franz Vahlen Munich 2009)
Dooyeweerd De Wijsbegeerte der Wetsidee Boek II
Dooyeweerd H De Wijsbegeerte der Wetsidee Boek II (HJ Paris Amsterdam 1935-1936)
Dooyeweerd De Wijsbegeerte der Wetsidee Boek III
Dooyeweerd H De Wijsbegeerte der Wetsidee Boek III (HJ Paris Amsterdam 1935-1936)
Dooyeweerd New Critique of Theoretical Thought
Dooyeweerd H A New Critique of Theoretical Thought Vol III (HJ Paris Amsterdam & The Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Company Philidelphia 1957)
Dreier 1994 Jura
Dreier GH "Subjektiv-rechtliche und objektiv-rechtliche Grundrechts¬gehalte" 1994 Jura 505-509
Du Plessis 1980 Obiter
Du Plessis LM "Reg, geregtigheid en menseregte – 'n Ondersoek na die eie-aard van elkeen met toespitsing op die vraag wat regverdige regsinstellings is" 1980 Obiter 51-85
Du Plessis 1981 Koers
Du Plessis LM "Staatsveiligheid in teoreties-prinsipiële perspektief" 1981 Koers 248-268
Du Plessis Reg, Geregtigheid en Menseregte
Du Plessis LM Reg, Geregtigheid en Menseregte (Regswetenskaplike variasies op filosofiese temas) (Pro Rege 198) 176-216
Epping Grundrechte
Epping V Grundrechte 3rd ed (Springer London 2007)
Falk "Sovereignty and Human Dignity"
Falk R "Sovereignty and Human Dignity: The Search for Reconciliation" in Steiner HJ, Alston P and Goodman R International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics, Morals 3rd ed (Oxford University Press New York 2008) 696-698
Ferreira-Snyman Erosion of State Sovereignty
Ferreira-Snyman MP The Erosion of State Sovereignty in Public International Law: Towards a World Law? (LLD thesis University of South Africa 2009)
Ipsen Staatsrecht II
Ipsen J Staatsrecht II: Grundrechte 8th ed (Wolters Kluver 2007)
Jellinek System der Subjektiven Őffentlichen Rechte
Jellinek G System der Subjektiven Őffentlichen Rechte 2nd ed (Mohr Tübingen 1919)
Jordaan and Davel Law of Persons
Jordaan RA and Davel CJ Law of Persons 4th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
Katz Staatsrecht
Katz A Staatsrecht: Grundkurs im Őffentlichen Recht 3rd ed (Athenäum Königstein 1978)
Klement Verantwortung
Klement JH Verantwortung: Funktion und Legitimation eines Begriffs im Őffentlichen Recht (Mohr Siebeck Tübingen 2006)
Krabbe Lehre der Rechtssouveranität
Krabbe H Die Lehre der Rechtssouveranität: Beitrag zur Staatslehre (Wolters Kluver 1906)
Kuyper Antirevolutionaire Staatkunde
Kuyper A Antirevolutionaire Staatkunde (JH Kok Kampen 1917)
Kuyper Calvinism
Kuyper A Calvinism - Six Stone Lezingen (T and T Clark Edinburgh 1898)
Kuyper Calvinisme, Oorsprong en Waarborg Onzer Constitutioneele Vrijheden
Kuyper A Het Calvinisme, Oorsprong en Waarborg Onzer Constitutioneele Vrijheden (Van der Land Amsterdam 1874)
Kuyper Gemeene Gratie
Kuyper A De Gemeene Gratie Volume III (Donner Leiden 1902)
Loewenstein Verfassungslehre
Loewenstein K Verfassungslehre (Mohr Tübingen 2000)
MacCormick Questioning Sovereignty
MacCormick N Questioning Sovereignty: Law, State, and Nation in the European Commonwealth (Oxford University Press Oxford 2001)
Makinda "Recasting Global Governance"
Makinda SM "Recasting Global Governance" in Thakur R and Newman E (eds) New Millennium, New Perspectives: The United Nations, Security and Governance (United Nations University Press Tokyo 2000) 168-172
Malan 2008 De Jure
Malan K "The nature of human rights treaties: Minimum protection agreements to the benefit of third parties" 2008 De Jure 81-92
Michael and Morlok Grundrechte
Michael L and Morlok M Grundrechte 2nd ed (Nomos Verlag Berlin 2010)
Nagler Über die Funktion des Staates
Nagler M Über die Funktion des Staates und des Widerstandsrechts (Academia Sankt Augustin 1990)
Robinson 2012 PER
Robinson JA "The right of child victims of armed conflict to reintegration and recovery" 2012 PER 46 - 101
Robinson et al Introduction to the South African Law of Persons
Robinson JA et al Introduction to the South African Law of Persons (Printing Things Potchefstroom 2008)
Sachs Verfassungsrecht II
Sachs M Verfassungsrecht II 2nd ed (Springer Berlin 2002)
Scherzberg 2006 Jura
Scherzberg A "Das subjektiv-öffentliche Recht – Grundfragen und Fälle" 2006 Jura 839-949
Schmidt Grundrechte
Schmidt R Grundrechte 11th ed (Druckhaus Pinkvoss 2009)
Stern Das Staatsrecht der Bundesrepublik Deutchland
Stern K Das Staatsrecht der Bundesrepublik Deutchland Band III/2 (CH Beck München 2005)
Van der Vyver Seven Lectures
Van der Vyver JD Seven Lectures on Human Rights (Juta Cape Town 1976)
Van der Vyver and Joubert Persone- en Familiereg
Van der Vyver JD and Joubert D Persone- en Familiereg 3rd ed (Juta Kenwyn 1991)
Van Wyk Persoonlike Status
Van Wyk DJ Persoonlike Status in die Suid-Afrikaanse Publiekreg (LLD thesis University of South Africa 1979)
Van Zyl and Van der Vyver Inleiding tot die Regswetenskap
Van Zyl FJ and Van der Vyver JD Inleiding tot die Regswetenskap 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1982)
Venter 1977 THRHR
Venter F "Salus reipublicae suprema lex" 1977 THRHR 233-252
Venter Publiekregtelike Verhouding
Venter F Die Publiekregtelike Verhouding (Butterworths Durban 1985)
Venter Publieke Subjektiewe Regte
Venter F Publieke Subjektiewe Regte: 'n Beskouing oor die Regsverhouding tussen Staat en Burger (Wetenskaplike bydraes van die PU vir CHO) 1980 Reeks H74
Vorster Ethical Perspectives
Vorster JM Ethical Perspectives on Human Rights (V & R Printing Works Pretoria 2004)
Wiechers Administratiefreg
Wiechers M Administratiefreg 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1984)
Witte Christian Theory of Social Institutions
Witte J A Christian Theory of Social Institutions – Herman Dooyeweerd (The Herman Dooyeweerd Foundation La Jolla California 1986)
Register of case law
BVerfGE 1, 97
BVerfGE 46, 160
Government of the RSA v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Krohn v Minister of Defence 1915 AD 191
R v Bekker 1900 SC 340
S v Baker, S v Doyle 1965 1 SA 821 (W)
S v Essop 1973 2 SA 815 (T)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
Trümpelman v Minister of Justice 1940 TPD 242
Register of legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Register of international instruments
Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
Protocol Additional to the Geneva Convention of August 12, 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts (1977) (AP (II))
Rome Statute of the International Court (1998)
United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice (1985) (Beijing Rules)
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)
Register of United Nations documents
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights General Comment 3
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights General Comment 3: The Nature of States Parties' Obligations (1990)
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Robbie Robinson
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}