Forceful arrests: an overview of section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 and its recent amendments
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i2a2493Keywords:
Forceful arrest, violence, policeAbstract
The debate concerning the use of violence by the police force is an endless one. Section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 serves as a framework for the use of violence by police officers during arrests in South Africa. While some hold the opinion that the powers of the police in this respect should be restricted, others see the 2003 redefined section 49 as a legislative guarantee of a suspect’s right to flee. Against this background this article has as its focus a critical discussion of the historical development of section 49 as well as the recent amendments of the same. The current legal position in South Africa is also compared with that in the United States of America as well as in the United Kingdom. Finally, certain conclusions and recommendations are made in order to enhance more favourable regulation of the employment of force in effecting arrests.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Bekker et al. 2009 Criminal Procedure
Bekker PM, Geldenhuys T, Joubert JJ, Swanepoel JP, Terblanche SS and Van der Merwe SE Criminal Procedure Handbook 9th ed (Juta & Co Claremont 2009)
Brave and Peters 1992 What’s your use-of-deadly-force standard?
Brave MA and Peters JG 1992 LAAW International, Inc. What’s your use-of-deadly-force standard? www.laaw.com/uodfs
[Date of use 15 Feb 2011].
Bruce 2011 SA Crime Quarterly
Bruce D “Beyond section 49: Control of the use of lethal force” 2011 South African Crime Quarterly 36:3-12.
Bruce 2010 Conference on Policing in South Africa
Bruce D “Shoot to kill: The use of deadly force by police” in the Report on the Conference on Policing in South Africa: 2010 and beyond 30 September to 1 October 2010 Muldersdrift 8-9.
Bruce 2011 Re: Criminal Procedure Amendment Bill, 39 of 2010
Bruce D “Submission to The Portfolio Committee on Justice and Constitutional Development” Re: Criminal Procedure Amendment Bill, 39 of 2010. 22 July 2011 s.p.
Burchell 2011 SACJ
Burchell J South African Criminal Law and Procedure Vol 1: General principles of criminal law 4th Edition. (Juta Claremont 2011)
Du Toit et al. 2010 Commentary on the Criminal Procedure Act
Du Toit E, De Jager FJ, Paizes A, Skeen A St Q, Van der Merwe S Commentary on the South African Criminal Procedure Act (Juta Cape Town 1987-2010)
Geldenhuys 2010 Conference on Policing in South Africa
Geldenhuys T “Shoot to kill: The use of deadly force by police” in the Report on the Conference on Policing in South Africa: 2010 and beyond 30 September to 1 October 2010 Muldersdrift 9-10.
Harrendorf et al. (Eds) 2010 International statistics on crime and justice
Harrendorf S, Heiskanen M and Malby S (Eds) International statistics on crime and justice (HEUNI Publication Series No 64 United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) Helsinki 2010)
Institute for Security Studies 2008 International Comparative Statistics
Institute for Security Studies 2008 International Comparative Statistics www.issafrica.org/crimehub/pgcontent.php?UID=1000048
[Date of use: 6 April 2011].
LAW.COM
Legal dictionary http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?typed=felony
&type=1 [Date of use: 5 April 2011]
Lee and Vaughn 2010 Journal of Criminal Justice
Lee H and Vaughn MS “Organizational factors that contribute to police deadly force liability” 2010 Journal of Criminal Justice 38:193-206.
Le Roux-Kemp and Horne 2011 SACJ
Le Roux-Kemp A and Horne CS “An analysis of the wording, interpretation and development of the provisions dealing with the use of lethal force in effecting an arrest in South African criminal procedure” 2011 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 24(3):266-282.
LEXISNEXIS
Use of force for law enforcement purposes http://www.lexisnexis.com/lawschool/study/outlines/html/crim/crim11.htm
[Date of use: 5 April 2011]
Metropolitan Police Authority
Meeting memo http://policeauthority.org/Metropolitan/downloads/foi/log/kratos-attach.pdf
[Date of use: 5 April 2011]
Mistry et al. 2001 Research report: The use of force by members of the South African Police Service: Case studies from seven policing areas in Gauteng
Mistry D, Minnaar A, Redpath J and Dhlamini J The use of force by members of the South African Police Service: Case studies from seven policing areas in Gauteng September 2001 (Institute for Human Rights & Criminal Justice Studies, TechnikonSA).
Neethling and Potgieter 2004 TSAR
Neethling J and Potgieter JM ”Section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977, private defence and putative private defence: regspraak” 2004 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 3:602-608.
Nicol 2005 Mail on Sunday
Nicol M “Met changes shoot-to-kill rules...but keeps them secret” 2005 Mail on Sunday October 9:2.
Open Society Foundation for South Africa 2010 Report on the OSF-SA roundtable discussion on the human rights and practical implications of the proposed amendments to section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act
Open Society Foundation for South Africa Report on the OSF-SA roundtable discussion on the human rights and practical implications of the proposed amendments to section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act 28 April 2010 (Johannesburg, South Africa)
Rappert 2002 British Journal of Criminology
Rappert B “Constructions of legitimate force” 2002 British Journal of Criminology 42:689-708.
Keebine-Sibanda and Sibanda 2003 Crime Research in South Africa
Keebine-Sibanda MJ and Sibanda OS “Use of deadly force by the South African Police Services re-visited” 2003 Crime Research in South Africa 5(1)s.p.
Smith 2009 Guardian.co.uk
Smith D 2009 South Africa considers ‘shoot to kill’ policing ahead of World Cup www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/sep/16/south-africa-police-world-cup
[Date of use 10 March 2011].
Snyman 2008 Criminal Law
Snyman CR Criminal law 5th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2008).
South African Police Service Annual Report
South African Police Service Annual Report 2008/2009 www.saps.gov.za
[Date of use 6 April 2011].
South African Police Service Annual Report 2009/2010 www.saps.gov.za
[Date of use 6 April 2011].
Staff and Agencies 2006 Guardian.co.uk
Staff and Agencies 2006 Police defend Menezes shooting tactics 8 March www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2006/mar/08/menezes
[Date of use: 15 Feb 2011].
Stone 2007 Theoretical Criminology
Stone C “Tracing police accountability in theory and practice: From Philadelphia to Abuja and Sao Paulo” 2007 Theoretical Criminology 11(2):245-259.
Tennenbaum 1994 The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology
Tennenbaum AN “The influence of the Garner decision on police use of deadly force” 1994 The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 85(1):241-260.
Thompson 2011 Report on the workshop: Developing a use-of-force policy for the South African Police Service
Thompson J Policing in a violent democratic society: Lessons in the use of force from the United States. In: Report on the workshop: Developing a use-of-force policy for the South African Police Service 21-22 July 2011 (Emoyeni Conference Centre, Johannesburg, South Africa).
Van der Walt 2007 TSAR
Van der Walt T “’n Grondwetlike oorsig oor die gebruik van geweld tydens arrestasie deur die Suid-Afrikaanse Polisiediens” 2007 Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg (1):96-111.
Van der Walt 2011 PER/PELJ
Van der Walt T “The use of force in effecting arrest in South Africa and the 2010 Bill: A step in the right direction?” 2011 Potchefstroom Electronic Journal (14)1:138-162.
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa of 1996
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 (South Africa)
South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995
Register of cases
April v Minister of Safety and Security [2009] 2 SACR 1 (SE)
Ex parte: Minister of Safety and Security and Others: In Re S v Walters and Another [2002] 4 SA 613 (CC)
Govender v Minister of Safety and Security [2001] 4 SA 273 (SCA)
Matlou v Makhubedu [1978] 1 SA 946 (A)
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Rinda Botha, Jo-Maris Visser
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}