The Constitutionality of a Biological Father's Recognition as a Parent
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i3a2688Keywords:
Biological father, constitutional rights of child, parents or father, legal parentage, parental responsibilities and rights, paternity.Abstract
Despite the increased recognition afforded to biological fathers as legal parents, the Children's Act[1] still does not treat fathers on the same basis as mothers as far as the automatic allocation of parental responsibilities and rights is concerned. This article investigates the constitutionality of the differential treatment of fathers in this respect, given South Africa's international obligations, especially in terms of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, to ensure that both parents have common responsibilities for the upbringing of their child. After a brief consideration of the constitutionality of the mother's position as parent, the constitutionality of the father's position is investigated, firstly, with reference to Section 9 of the Constitution and the question of whether the differentiation between mothers and fathers as far as the allocation of parental responsibilities and rights is concerned, amounts to unfair discrimination. The inquiry also considers whether the differentiation between committed fathers (that is, those who have shown the necessary commitment in terms of Sections 20 and 21 of the Children's Act to acquire parental responsibilities and rights) and uncommitted fathers may amount to discrimination on an unspecified ground. Since the limitation of the father's rights to equality may be justifiable, the outcomes of both inquiries are shown to be inconclusive. Finally, the legal position of the father is considered in relation to the child's constitutional rights – the rights to parental care and the right of the child to the paramountcy of its interests embodied in Section 28 of the Constitution. While there appears to be some justification for the limitation of the child's right to committed paternal care, it is submitted that an equalisation of the legal position of mothers and fathers as far as the automatic acquisition of parental responsibilities and rights is concerned, is not only justified but imperative if the constitutional rights of children are to be advanced and protected.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Albertyn and Goldblatt "Equality"
Albertyn C and Goldblatt B "Equality" in Woolman S et al (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed Vol 3 (Juta Cape Town 2006) 35-i–35-85
Bailey-Harris 1996 Adel LR
Bailey-Harris R "The Family Law Reform Act 1995 (Cth): A new approach to the parent/child relationship" 1996 Adel LR 83–101
Bainham 1989 IJLPF
Bainham A "When is a parent not a parent? Reflections on the unmarried father and his child in English law" 1989 IJLPF 208–239
Barton 1998 Solicitors Journal
Barton C "Equal responsibility for all fathers?" 1998 Solicitors Journal 401–402
Bekink and Brand "Constitutional protection of children"
Bekink B and Brand D "Constitutional protection of children" in Davel CJ (ed) Introduction to Child Law in South Africa (Juta Lansdowne 2000) 169-195
Bonthuys 1997 SAJHR
Bonthuys E "Of biological bonds, new fathers and the best interests of children" 1997 SAJHR 622–637
Bonthuys 1999 THRHR
Bonthuys E "Familiar discourses of parenthood" 1999 THRHR 547–576
Bonthuys 2002 SALJ
Bonthuys E "The South African Bill of Rights and the development of family law" 2002 SALJ 748–782
Boyd "Gender specificity to gender neutrality?"
Boyd SB "From gender specificity to gender neutrality? Ideologies in Canadian child custody law" in Smart C and Sevenhuijsen S (eds) Child Custody and the Politics of Gender (Routledge New York 1989) 126–157
Clark 2000 Stell LR
Clark B "A 'golden thread'? Some aspects of the application of the standard of the best interest of the child in South African family law" 2000 Stell LR 3–20
Clark and Goldblatt "Gender and family law"
Clark B and Goldblatt B "Gender and family law" in Bonthuys E and Albertyn C (eds) Gender, Law and Justice (Juta Cape Town 2007) 195–243
Claassen Dictionary of Legal Words and Phrases
Claassen CJ Dictionary of Legal Words and Phrases 2nd ed Vol 3 (Butterworths Durban 1997)
Cockrell "The Law of Persons and the Bill of Rights"
Cockrell A "The Law of Persons and the Bill of Rights" in Bill of Rights Compendium (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 1996)
Conway 1996 NLJ
Conway "Parental responsibilities and rights and the unmarried father" 1996 NLJ 782–784
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
Deech 1992 Journal of Child Law
Deech R "The unmarried father and human rights" 1992 Journal of Child Law 3–10
Eckhard 1992 TSAR
Eckhard B "Toegangsregte tot buite-egtelike kinders – behoort die wetgewer in te gryp?" 1992 TSAR 122–133
Garner Handbook of Family Law Terms
Garner B (ed) Handbook of Family Law Terms (West Publishing Eagan 2001)
Goldberg 1993 SALJ
Goldberg V "The right of access of a father of an extramarital child: Visited again" 1993 SALJ 261– 275
Goldberg 1996 THRHR
Goldberg V "The right of access of a father of an illegitimate child: Further reflections" 1996 THRHR 282–294
Heaton "Family Law and the Bill of Rights"
Heaton J "Family Law and the Bill of Rights" in Bill of Rights Compendium (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 1996) 3C-1–3C-67
Heaton South African Law of Persons
Heaton J The South African Law of Persons 3rd ed (LexisNexis Durban 2008)
Hughes "Law, religion and bastardy"
Hughes K "Law, religion and bastardy: Comparative and historical perspectives" in Burman S and Preston-Whyte E (eds) Questionable Issue: Illegitimacy in South Africa (Oxford University Press Cape Town 1992) 1-20
Kaganas "Joint custody and equality in South Africa"
Kaganas F "Joint custody and equality in South Africa" in Murray C Gender and the New South African Legal Order (Juta Cape Town 1994) 169–184
Kahn 1978 SALJ
Kahn E "A note on 'Is there any real basis for the preference accorded to mothers as custodial parents?'" 1978 SALJ 249–250
Kilkelly The Child and European Convention
Kilkelly U The Child and the European Convention on Human Rights (Ashgate Publishers Aldershot 1999)
Kruger 1996 THRHR
Kruger JM "Die toegangsbevoegdhede van die ongetroude vader – Is die finale woord gespreek? B v S 1995 3 SA 571 (A)" 1996 THRHR 514–522
Kruger et al 1993 THRHR
Kruger JM et al "Die vader van die buite-egtelike kind se toegangsreg S v S 1993 2 SA 200 (W)" 1993 THRHR 696–704
Labuschagne 1993 THRHR
Labuschagne JMT "Persoonlikheidsgoedere van 'n ander as regsobjek: Opmerkinge oor die ongehude vader se persoonlikhelds- en waardevormende reg ten aansien van sy buite-egtelike kind" 1993 THRHR 414–429
Littleton 1987 California LR
Littleton CA "Reconstructing sexual equality" 1987 California LR 1279–1337
Louw Acquisition of Parental Responsibilities and Rights
Louw Acquisition of Parental Responsibilities and Rights (LLD thesis UP 2009)
Lowe 1997 IJLPF
Lowe NV "The meaning and allocation of parental responsibility – A common lawyer's perspective" 1997 IJLPF 192–215
Lowe and Douglas Bromley's Family Law
Lowe NV and Douglas G Bromley's Family Law 10th ed (Oxford University Press London 2007)
Mahery "The United Nations Convention"
Mahery P "The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: Maintaining its value in international and South African law" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2009) 309–330
Meulders-Klein 1990 ILJF
Meulders-Klein M "The position of the father in European legislation" 1990 International Journal of Law and the Family 131–153
Mills Family Law
Mills E Family Law Butterworths Tutorial Series 3rd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Chatswood 2008)
Mosikatsana 1996 CILSA
Mosikatsana TL "Is papa a rolling stone? The unwed father and his child in South African law – a comment on Fraser v Naude" 1996 CILSA 152–167
Murray Gender and the New South African Legal Order
Murray C (ed) Gender and the New South African Legal Order (Juta Cape Town 1994)
Palmer 1996 SALJ
Palmer A "Are some fathers of extramarital children in a better position than others?" 1996 SALJ 579–585
Pantazis 1996 SALJ
Pantazis A "Access between the father and his illegitimate child" 1996 SALJ 8–21
Pearsall The Concise Oxford Dictionary
Pearsall J The Concise Oxford Dictionary 10th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 1999)
Robinson 1998 Obiter
Robinson JA "The child's right to parental and family care: Some brief remarks" 1998 Obiter 329–339
Rosen 1978 SALJ
Rosen R "Is there any real basis for the preference accorded to mothers as custodial parents?" 1978 SALJ 246–248
Schwenzer 2007 EJCL
Schwenzer I "Tensions between legal, biological and social conceptions of parentage" EJCL 11.3 (Dec)
Scottish Law Commission Report on Family Law
Scottish Law Commission Report 135 – Report on Family Law (Scottish Law Commission Edinburgh 1992)
Sinclair "Family rights"
Sinclair JD "Family rights" in Van Wyk D et al (eds) Rights and Constitutionalism: The New South African Legal Order (Juta Cape Town 1994) 502–572
Sinclair "Legal personality"
Sinclair JD "Legal personality" in Van Heerden B et al (eds) Boberg's Law of Persons and the Family 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1999) 1-3
Sloth-Nielsen 2002 International Journal of Children's Rights
Sloth-Nielsen J "Children's rights in the South African courts: An overview since the ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child" 2002 International Journal of Children's Rights 137–156
Sloth-Nielsen and Van Heerden 2003 IJLPF
Sloth-Nielsen J and Van Heerden B "The constitutional family: Developments in South African Family Law jurisprudence under the 1996 Constitution" 2003 IJLPF 121–146
Sonnekus and Van Westing 1992 THRHR
Sonnekus JC and Van Westing A "Faktore vir die erkenning van 'n sogenaamde reg van toegang vir die vader van 'n buite-egtelike kind" 1992 THRHR 232–255
Van der Linde Grondwetlike Erkenning
Van der Linde A Grondwetlike Erkenning van Regte ten Aansien van die Gesin en Gesinslewe met Verwysing na Aspekte van Artikel 8 van die Europese Verdrag vir die Beskerming van die Regte en Vryhede van die Mens (LLD thesis UP 2001)
Van der Linde and Labuschagne 2001 THRHR
Van der Linde A and Labuschagne JMT "Die omgangsreg van die ongehude vader en sy buite-egtelike kind en die vraagstuk van deliktuele aanspreeklikheid binne konteks van 'n interaksiereg" 2001 THRHR 308–315
Van Heerden "Judicial interference"
Van Heerden B "Judicial interference with the parental power: The protection of children" in Van Heerden B et al (eds) Boberg's Law of Persons and the Family 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 1999) 497–645
Van Onselen 1991 De Rebus
Van Onselen D "TUFF – the unmarried fathers' fight" 1991 De Rebus 499–501
Visser 1996 De Jure
Visser PJ "Die moontlike uitdruklike erkenning en beskerming van fundamentele regte ten aansien van die huwelik en gesin (familie) in die finale Grondwet van Suid-Afrika" 1996 De Jure 351–358
Visser and Potgieter 1994 THRHR
Visser PJ and Potgieter JM "Some critical comments on South Africa's Bill of Fundamental Human Rights" 1994 THRHR 493–498
Webster's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language
Webster's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language (Merriam Springfield 1976)
Wolhuter 1997 Stell LR
Wolhuter L "Balancing the scales – Access by a natural father to his extra-marital child" 1997 Stell LR 65–79
Register of international agreements
African Union African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child 29 Nov 1999
European Convention on Human Rights 4 Nov 1950
United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women 18 Dec 1979
United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child 20 Nov 1989
Register of legislation
South African legislation
Black Administration Act 38 of 1927
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993
Australia legislation
Australian Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Family Law Reform Act 1995 (Cth)
Register of cases
B v M 2006 3 All SA 109 (W)
B v S 1993 2 SA 211 (W)
B v S 1995 3 SA 571 (A)
Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha (Commission for Gender Equality as Amicus Curiae); Shibi v Sithole; South African Human Rights Commission v President of the Republic of South Africa 2005 1 SA 580 (CC)
Brink v Kitshoff NO 1996 4 SA 197 (CC)
Centre for Child Law v Minister of Home Affairs 2005 6 SA 50 (T)
De Reuck v Director of Public Prosecutions (Witwatersrand Local Division) 2004 1 SA 406 (CC)
Dawood v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 3 SA 936 (CC)
Du Toit v Minister of Welfare and Population Development (Lesbian and Gay Equality Project as Amicus Curiae) 2003 2 SA 198 (CC)
Ex parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Assembly: In re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 1996 4 SA 744 (CC)
Ex parte Critchfield 1999 3 SA 132 (W)
Fraser v Children's Court, Pretoria North 1997 2 SA 218 (T)
Fraser v Children's Court, Pretoria North 1997 2 SA 261 (CC)
Harksen v Lane 1998 1 SA 300 (CC)
J v Director-General, Department of Home Affairs 2003 5 SA 605 (D)
J v Director-General, Department of Home Affairs 2003 5 SA 621 (CC)
Jooste v Botha 2000 2 BCLR 187 (T)
K v M 2007 4 All SA 883 (E)
Madiehe (born Ratlhogo) v Madiehe 1997 2 All SA 153 (B)
McCall v McCall 1994 3 SA 201 (C)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Justice 1999 1 SA 6 (CC)
Petersen v Kruger 1975 4 SA 171 (C)
Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon's Town Maintenance Court 2004 2 SA 56 (C)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Hugo 1997 4 SA 1 (CC)
Prinsloo v Van der Linde 1997 3 SA 1012 (CC)
S v M (Centre for Child Law as Amicus Curiae) 2007 2 SACR 539 (CC)
Shalabi v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 3 SA 936 (CC)
SW v F 1997 1 SA 796 (O)
Thomas v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 3 SA 936 (CC)
Van der Linde v Van der Linde 1996 3 SA 509 (O)
Van Pletzen v Van Pletzen 1998 4 SA 95 (O)
European Court of Human Rights
Johnston v Ireland 1986 9 EHRR 203
Inze v Austria 1987 10 EHRR 394
Marckx v Belgium 1979 2 EHRR 330
American case law
Glona v American Guarantee and Liability Insurance Co 391 US 73 (1968)
Levy v Louisiana 391 US 68 (1968)
Stanley v Illinois 405 US 645 (1972)
Trimble v Gordon 430 US 762 (1977)
Weber v Aetna Casualty and Surety Co 406 US 164 (1972)
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Anne Louw
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}