The Debt Couselling Process-Closing the Loopholes in the National Credit Act 34 of 2005

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2009/v12i4a2745

Keywords:

Debt counselling, debt review, debt rearrangement, debt counsellor, consumer, over-indebtedness, clearance certificate, work stream agreement

Abstract

Statistics showing that only 3.8% of consumers who have applied for debt review in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 (NCA) have succeeded to have their cases adjudicated by the court, indicate that the process is not functioning effectively. In January 2009, the Law Clinic of the University of Pretoria was commissioned by the National Credit Regulator (NCR) to conduct an assessment on the reasons for the ineffectiveness of the debt counselling process. The research report indicated that credit providers not co-operating in the process and not-complying with the NCA and Regulations and the so-called work stream agreement reached between major credit providers, established debt counsellors and the National Credit Regulator, were the main reasons for the ineffectiveness of the debt counselling process. Second on the list of so-called major obstacles were the vagueness and insufficiency of the NCA and Regulations.

 

The main purpose of this article, which is based on chapter 2 of the research report mentioned above, is to identify the loopholes in the NCA which cause the lack of legal certainty and which contribute to the ineffectiveness of the debt counselling process. Although the work stream guidelines are to be welcomed because they attempt to find a solution for the vagueness and insufficiency of the NCA and Regulations, it is submitted that the situation is still not desirable. Many credit providers and debt counsellors did not form part of the work stream processes and therefore cannot be bound by these agreements. The NCR's application to the High Court for a declaratory order in terms of section 16(1)(b)(ii) may shed some light on the problems currently experienced, however, it is submitted that the best solution is for the legislator to address these shortcomings in order to bring about a proper and effective debt counselling process. By also taking the Draft Debt Counselling Regulations into consideration, certain issues which, in our view, should be addressed by the legislator are identified and proposals for the amendment of provisions of the NCA are made.

 

Ultimately, the effectiveness of the NCA's provisions to provide debt relief to the over-indebted consumer depends on the co-operation of the different role players and compliance with the spirit of the Act in terms of section 86(5)(b) to participate in good faith in the review and in the negotiations for debt rearrangement. It is submitted that in theses negotiations the purpose of the Act, namely to protect consumers, should constantly be kept in mind. Credit providers will have to change their attitudes and appreciate the fact that they will have to take greater responsibility for the negative consequences of credit granting. It is furthermore submitted that more should still be done to prevent over-indebtedness and to reduce the need for consumers to resort to the debt relief mechanisms of the Act. The apparent need for consumer education at both the adult and school level should therefore be addressed.

    

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bibliography

Boraine "Reform"

Boraine A "The reform of administration orders within a new consumer credit framework" in Kelly-Louw M, Nehf JP and Rott P (eds) The Future of Consumer Credit Regulation Creative Approaches to Emerging Problems (Ashgate Aldershot 2008) 187-216

Boraine and Renke 2007 De Jure

Boraine A and Renke S "Some practical and comparative aspects of the cancellation of instalment agreements in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005" (part 1) 2007 De Jure 222-235

Boraine and Renke 2008 De Jure

Boraine A and Renke S "Some practical and comparative aspects of the cancellation of instalment agreements in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005" (part 2) 2008 De Jure 1-15

Du Plessis 2007 JJS

Du Plessis MA "The National Credit Act: Debt counselling may prove to be a risky enterprise" 2007 Journal for Juridical Science 76-94

Du Preez Saturday Star

Du Preez L 'Merits of new debt counselling process yet to be proved' Saturday Star 6 October 2007 4

Eastonberry "Attorney"

Eastonberry R "The attorney for the NCA credit provider" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Gerretsen Saturday Weekend Argus

Gerretsen B 'Debt counselling spikes as hikes hit consumers' Saturday Weekend Argus 21 June 2008 12

Gillingham Sunday Times 21

Gillingham A 'It's time to ring up the debt counsellor' Sunday Times 1 June 2008 21

Haupt, Roestoff and Erasmus Debt Counselling Process

Haupt F, Roestoff M and Erasmus M The Debt Counselling Process: Challenges to Consumers and the Credit Industry in General (Report submitted by the University of Pretoria Law Clinic to the National Credit Regulator April 2009)

Jackson Mail and Guardian

Jackson D 'Debt counselling: no quick fix' Mail and Guardian 5 June 2008 42

Kelly-Louw 2008 SAMercLJ

Kelly-Louw M "The prevention and alleviation of consumer over-indebtedness" 2008 SA Mercantile Law Journal 200-226

Khanyile Star

Khanyile S 'Debt counselling is 'misunderstood'' Star 12 March 2008 20

Loots "Magistrate"

Loots C "The magistrate and the application of the NCA in debt enforcement" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Naidu Sunday Independent

Naidu E 'Now even debt counsellors are feeling the pinch' Sunday Independent 1 June 2008 1

NCR: Founding affidavit

Founding affidavit to the National Credit Regulator's application for a declaratory order in terms of section 16 of the National Credit Act – National Credit Regulator v Nedbank Ltd and others (Unreported case no 19638/08 TPD)

Otto "Credit provider"

Otto C "The credit provider and NCA debt enforcement" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Otto National Credit Act explained

Otto JM The National Credit Act Explained (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)

Pienaar "Payment distribution agent"

Pienaar H "The role and function of the payment distribution agent" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Renke, Roestoff and Bekink 2006 IIR

Renke S, Roestoff M and Bekink B "New legislative measures in South Africa aimed at combating over-indebtedness – are the new proposals sufficient under the constitution and law in general? 2006 International Insolvency Review 91-107

Renke, Roestoff and Haupt 2007 Obiter

Renke S, Roestoff M and Haupt F "The National Credit Act: New parameters for the granting of credit in South Africa" 2007 Obiter 229-270

Richards "Debt counsellor"

Richards T "The debt counsellor and debt restructuring" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Roestoff 2009 Obiter

Roestoff M "Enforcement of a credit agreement where the consumer has applied for debt review in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005" (accepted for publication in 2009 (2) Obiter)

Roestoff and Coetzee 2008 JCRDL

Roestoff M and Coetzee H "Consent to jurisdiction – unlawful provision in a credit agreement – is the jurisdiction of a court ousted thereby?" 2008 Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law 678-688

Roestoff and Renke 2003 Obiter

Roestoff M and Renke S "Solving the problem of over-indebtedness: International guidelines" 2003 Obiter 1-26

Roestoff and Renke 2005 IIR

Roestoff M and Renke S "A fresh start for individual debtors: The role of South African insolvency and consumer protection legislation" 2005 International Insolvency Review 93-109

Roestoff and Renke 2005 JCRDL

Roestoff M and Renke S "The Consumer Credit Bill – a solution to over-indebtedness?" 2005 Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law 115-121

Roestoff and Renke 2006 Obiter

Roestoff M and Renke S "Debt relief for consumers – the interaction between insolvency and consumer protection legislation" (part 2) 2006 Obiter 98-110

SALC Project 74

South African Law Commission Project 74 Debt Collecting (1995)

Scholtz et al Credit Act

Scholtz JW et al Guide to the National Credit Act (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2008)

Stadler "Debt review applications"

Stadler S "Debt review applications to the Magistrate's Court" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Stewart Daily Dispatch

Stewart T 'Millions in debt trap overwhelm counsellors' Daily Dispatch 21 August 2008 11

Stoop 2008 De Jure

Stoop PN "Kritiese evaluasie van die toepassingsveld van die 'National Credit Act'" 2008 De Jure 352-370

Van Heerden and Otto 2007 JSAL

Van Heerden CM and Otto JM "Debt enforcement in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005" 2007 Journal of South African Law 655-684

Van Loggerenberg, Dicker and Malan 2008 De Rebus

Van Loggerenberg D, Dicker L and Malan J "Aspects of debt enforcement under the National Credit Act" 2008 De Rebus 40-44

Van Wyk "F(r)iction"

Van Wyk D "F(r)iction in debt enforcement" (Unpublished paper delivered at a Conference on Debt Enforcement 16-17 March 2009 Midrand)

Van Zyl Sake Rapport

Van Zyl A 'Hulp met skuld sukkel nog' Sake Rapport 5 April 2009 8

Vessio 2008 SAMercLJ

Vessio ML "What does the National Credit Regulator regulate?" 2008 SA Mercantile Law Journal 227-242

Visagie 2006 De Rebus

Visagie T "Collecting your debts against the odds" 2006 De Rebus 21-23

Register of legislation and government publications

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996

Gen Not 503 in Government Gazette 32229 of 15 May 2009

GN R489 in Government Gazette 28864 of 31 May 2006

Insolvency Act 24 of 1936

Magistrates' Courts Act 32 of 1944

National Credit Act 35 of 2005

Register of court cases

Absa Bank Ltd v Myburgh Case no 31827/2007 (TPD) (unreported)

Absa Bank Ltd v Prochaska Case no 14839/2007 (D) (unreported)

Absa Bank Ltd v Whelpton Case no 35313/2008 (TPD) (unreported)

Ex parte Ford and Two Similar Cases 2009 (3) SA 376 (WCC)

First Rand Bank Ltd v Olivier [2008] JOL 22138 (SE)

First Rand Bank Ltd v Smith Case no 24205/08 (WLD) (unreported)

Frederick v Greenhouse Funding (Pty) Ltd Case no 31825/2008 (WLD) (unreported)

Nedbank Ltd v Motaung Case no 22445/07 (TPD) (unreported)

Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Oosthuizen [2008] JOL 22036 (T)

Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Panayiotts Case no 08/00146 (WLD) (unreported)

Register of internet sources

CBM 2009 www.ncr.org.za

CBM 2009 Credit Bureau Monitor (March 2009) www.ncr.org.za [date of use 27 July 2009]

CBM 2008 www.ncr.org.za

CBM 2008 Credit Bureau Monitor (December 2008) – www.ncr.org.za [date of use 27 July 2009]

Da Silva et al 2008 www.ncr.org.za/

Da Silva M et al 2008 Debt Counselling – Principles and Guidelines www.ncr.org.za/pdfs/Guidelines/Principles%20&%20Guidelines/DEBT%20COUNSELLING%20%20%20PRINCIPLES%20GUIDELINES%20%20-%20BASA%20training%202008.pdf [date of use 11 December 2009]

Heymans 2009 www.ncr.org.za/

Heymans M 2009 Blockages in Payment Distribution – an Investigation into the Matters that Influence the Effectiveness of Payment Distribution in the Debt Counselling System www.ncr.org.za/.../Blockages%20Debt%20counsellors%2013a%20Oct%20%202009.ppt

Published

26-06-2017

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Roestoff, M., Haupt, F., Erasmus, M., & Coetzee, H. (2017). The Debt Couselling Process-Closing the Loopholes in the National Credit Act 34 of 2005. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 12(4), 246-305. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2009/v12i4a2745

Similar Articles

1-10 of 1082

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.