Unintentionally Trapped by Debt Review: Procedural Inadequacies in the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 Relating to Withdrawal from the Debt Review Process





Debt review, withdrawal from debt review, withdrawal guidelines, explanatory note to withdrawal guidelines


The debt review procedure in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 is functioning relatively well and benefits both consumers and credit providers. This is despite its somewhat scarce procedural prescriptions, which result in difficulties from time to time. In this respect, a recent procedural challenge has appeared, namely that of consumers who voluntary enter the debt procedure, but who later want to withdraw therefrom – thus, before the procedure has reached its ordinary conclusion, on the basis that their financial situation has improved to the extent that they are no longer over-indebted. The fact that the National Credit Act does not provide for such an exit has led to procedural uncertainty and diverging court decisions. In this article, the relevant legislative provisions (or lack thereof), court and National Consumer Tribunal judgements, regulations, forms, guidelines and explanatory notes are considered to determine whether it is competent for consumers to withdraw from the debt review procedure before it has reached its normal conclusion. Not only provisions in the National Credit Act are considered, but also general civil procedure to contemplate all possibilities in searching for an answer to this procedural difficulty.




Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...

Author Biographies

Corlia Van Heerden

Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Pretoria

Hermie Coetzee, University of Pretoria

Associate Professor of Law University of Pretoria


Boraine A, Van Heerden C and Roestoff M "A Comparison between Formal Debt Administration and Debt Review: The Pros and Cons of these Measures and Suggestions for Law Reform (Part 1)" 2012 De Jure 80-103

Brits R "The ′Reinstatement′ of Credit Agreements: Remarks in Response to the 2014 Amendment of Section 129(3)-(4) of the National Credit Act" 2015 De Jure 75-91

Brits R, Coetzee H and Van Heerden C "Re-instatement of Credit Agreements in terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005: Quo Vadis" 2017 THRHR 177-197

Kelly-Louw M "The 2014 Credit-information Amnesty Regulations: What do they Really Entail?" 2015 De Jure 92-115

Otto JM "Over-indebtedness and Applications for Debt Review in terms of the National Credit Act: Consumers Beware!" 2009 SA Merc LJ 272-278

Otto JM "Die Oorbelaste Skuldverbruiker: Die Nasionale Kredietwet Verleen Geensins Onbeperkte Vrydom van Skulde nie" 2010 TSAR 399-408

Otto JM "The Impact of the National Credit Act on Consent to Jurisdiction in terms of the Magistrates' Courts Act" 2007 THRHR 140-147

Roestoff M and Coetzee H "Consent to Jurisdiction: An Unlawful Provision of a Credit Agreement in terms of the National Credit Act – Is the Jurisdiction of a Court thereby Ousted?" 2008 THRHR 678-688

Roestoff M and Smit A "Non-compliance with Time Periods: Should the Debt Review Procedure Lapse once a Reasonable Time has Expired?" 2011 THRHR 501-509

Van Heerden C "Over-indebtedness and Reckless Lending" in Scholtz WJ (ed) Guide to the National Credit Act (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2008-) ch 11

Van Heerden C "Jurisdiction in terms of the National Credit Act" 2008 TSAR 840-855

Van Heerden C and Coetzee H "Wesbank v Deon Winston Papier and the National Credit Regulator (unreported case no 14256/10 (WCC))" 2011 De Jure 463-479

Van Heerden C and Coetzee H "Perspectives on the Termination of Debt Review in terms of Section 86(10) of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005" 2011 PERJ 37-65

Van Loggerenberg DE (ed) Jones and Buckle: The Civil Practice of the Magistrates' Courts in South Africa 10th ed (Juta Cape Town 2019)

Van Loggerenberg DE (ed) Erasmus: Superior Court Practice (Service 10) (Juta Cape Town 2019)

Absa Bank Ltd v Walker (WC) (unreported) case number 2307/14 of 17 June 2014

Botha v Koekemoer t/a The Debt Expert 2; Mafakane v MSA Consultants t/a Consumer Financial Services (LMPP) (unreported) case number 7723/2017; 750/2018 of 11 May 2018

Collett v FirstRand Bank Ltd 2011 4 SA 508 (SCA)

Cordiant Trading CC v Daimler Chrysler Financial Services (Pty) Ltd 2005 6 SA 205 (SCA)

Daniels v Sensational Debt Relief (Pty) Ltd (WC) (unreported) case number 10065/17 of 3 August 2017

Du Plessis v De Klerk 1996 3 SA 850 (CC)

Du Toit v Sager (WC) (unreported) case number 16226/17 of 17 November 2017

Eseu v Debtsafe; Shingange v Mare trading as Debt Rescue (GPP) (unreported) case number 85651/2017; 85650/2017 of 10 April 2018

Ex parte Ford 2009 3 SA 376 (WCC)

Ex parte Ginsberg 1936 TPD 155

Ex parte Morris 1954 3 SA 153 (W)

Ex parte Nell 1963 1 SA 754 (A)

Ex parte Velkes 1963 3 SA 584 (C)

Ferris v Firstrand Bank Ltd 2014 3 SA 39 (CC)

Firstrand Bank Ltd t/a Wesbank v Maboja (ZAGPPHC) (unreported) case number 59378/2012 of 9 October 2014

Firstrand Bank Ltd v Kona 2015 5 SA 237 (SCA)

FirstRand Bank Ltd v Olivier 2009 3 SA 353 (SE)

Gardener v Whitaker 1996 4 SA 337 (CC)

Geldenhuys and Neethling v Beuthin 1918 AD 426

Graaf-Reinet Municipality v Van Ryneveld's Pass Irrigation Board 1950 2 SA 420 (A)

Gxarisa v Gardner (NCT) (unreported Tribunal judgement) case number NCT/121006/2018/165 of 14 February 2019

Johnson v A Blaikie & Co (Pty) Ltd t/a FT Building Supplies Manaba 1998 3 SA 251 (N)

Langa v Lewis (NCT) (unreported Tribunal judgment) case number NCT/84265/2017/165(1) of 11 September 2017

Less v Vosloo (KZP) (unreported) case number 7520/17P of 22 September 2017

Magadze v ADCAP, Ndlovu v Koekemoer (GP) (unreported) case number 57186/2016 of 2 November 2016

Maitland Cattle Dealers v Lyons 1943 WLD 1

Manamela v Du Plessis t/a Debt Safe (GPP) (unreported) case number 78244/2016 of 21 June 2017

Manong & Associates (Pty) Ltd v Department of Roads and Transport, Eastern Cape (No 2) 2009 6 SA 589 (SCA)

Mhlongo v Beatrice De Beer 2018 JOL 39571 (KZP) (22 September 2017)

Minister of Finance v Oakbay Investments (Pty) Ltd; Oakbay Investments (Pty) Ltd v Director of the Financial Intelligence Centre 2018 3 SA 515 (GP)

Mokubung v Mamela Consulting (GPP) (unreported) case number 87653/2016 of 14 June 2017

Moyana v Body Corporate of Cottonwood (GPJ) (unreported) case number A3068/16 of 17 February 2017

National Credit Regulator v Nedbank Ltd 2009 6 SA 295 (GNP)

Ndamase v Functions 4 All 2004 5 SA 602 (SCA)

Nedbank Ltd v Mateman; Nedbank Ltd v Stringer 2008 4 SA 276 (T)

Nedbank Ltd v National Credit Regulator 2011 3 SA 581 (SCA)

Ngcongo v Neil Roets trading as Debt Rescue 2018 JOL 39572 (KZP) (22 September 2017)

Ngubane v Capitec Bank Ltd 2017 JOL 37651 (NCT)

Nikiwe v Lewis (NCT) (unreported Tribunal judgment) case number NCT/86875/2017/165 of 22 December 2017

Ntonto v Chris Craven t/a Zero Debt (GNP) (unreported) case number 24163/2018 of 19 September 2018

Phaladi v Lamara 2018 3 SA 265 (WCC)

Philips v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2006 1 SA 505 (CC)

Preston v Vredendal Co-operative Winery Ltd 2001 1 SA 244 (E)

Pretoria Garrison Institutes v Danish Variety Products (Pty) Ltd 1948 1 SA 839 (A)

Rougier v Nedbank Ltd (GPJ) (unreported) case number 27333/2010 of 28 May 2013

SA Breweries v Registrar of Deeds 1943 CPD 433

Sibiya v Minister of Police 1979 1 SA 333 (T)

Softex Matress (Pty) Ltd v Transvaal Mattress and Furnishing Co Ltd 1979 1 SA 755 (D)

South African Broadcasting Corp Ltd v National Director of Public Prosecutions 2007 1 SA 523 (CC)

Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Jikeka (WCC) (unreported) case number 3430/2010 of 9 June 2011

Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Newman (WC) (unreported) case number 27771/2010 of 15 April 2011

Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Panayiotts 2009 3 SA 363 (W)

Swanepoel v Roets (GNP) (unreported) case of 23 October 2018

Universal City Studios Inc v Network Video (Pty) Ltd 1986 2 SA 734 (A)

Close Corporations Act 69 of 1984

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Divorce Act 70 of 1979

Insolvency Act 24 of 1936

Magistrates' Courts Act 32 of 1944

National Credit Act 34 of 2005

National Credit Amendment Act 19 of 2014

National Credit Amendment Act 7 of 2019

Superior Courts Act 10 of 2013

Supreme Court Act 59 of 1959

Government publications

GN R489 in GG 28864 of 31 May 2006

GN 389 in GG 37665 of 19 May 2014

GN R740 in GG 33487 of 23 August 2010

GN R48 in GG 999 of 12 January 1965

Memorandum on the Objects of the National Credit Bill, 2005

National Credit Regulator 2015 Circular 2 of 2015: Debt Review Task Team Agreements https://ncr.org.za/documents/pages/circulars/jan2015/Debt%20Review%20Task%20Team%20Agreements.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2015 Guidelines for the Withdrawal from Debt Review https://www.ncr.org.za/documents/pages/circulars/feb2015/Withdrawal%20from%20debt%20review%20guidelines.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2015 Explanatory Notes to the Withdrawal Guidelines https://www.ncr.org.za/documents/Withdrawal_guidelines/Explanatory%20Note%20to%20the%20Withdrawal%20Guidelines.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2016 Circular 7 of 2016: Debt Help System Enhancements https://ncr.org.za/documents/Circulars/Circular%20No7%

DHS.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2017 Circular 6 of 2017: Interpretation of Section 71 of the NCA https://ncr.org.za/documents/Circulars/Circular

%206%20of%202017-%20Section%2071.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2017 Circular 11 of 2017: DHS New Functionalities https://ncr.org.za/documents/Circulars/DHS%20Automated%20transfers%20circular%20.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2017/2018 Annual Report https://ncr.org.za/documents/pages/Annual%20Reports/NCR%20Annual%20Report%202017-18.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2018 Circular 4: Suspension Indicator on Debt Help System https://ncr.org.za/documents/Circulars/NCR%20Circular%2004%20of%20August%202018.pdf accessed 31 August 2019

National Credit Regulator 2018 The Debt Counselling Fee Guidelines https://www.ncr.org.za/documents/debt%20counselling%20fee%20structure%20guideline.pdf accessed 31 August 2019



How to Cite

Van Heerden, C., & Coetzee, H. (2019). Unintentionally Trapped by Debt Review: Procedural Inadequacies in the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 Relating to Withdrawal from the Debt Review Process. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 22, 1–69. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2019/v22i0a6966




Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.