A Note on the Ninth Amendment to the Constitution of Lesotho
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2021/v24i0a8624Keywords:
Constitution of Lesotho, Ninth Amendment to the Constitution, vote of no confidence, dissolution of parliament, prorogation of parliament, caretaker governmentAbstract
The Constitution of Lesotho has been amended nine times since its adoption in 1993. The latest amendment, styled the Ninth Amendment to the Constitution, was assented into law in May 2020 amidst great controversy. The Amendment makes fundamental changes to the Constitution. Its main thrust is to cushion parliament from early dissolutions necessitated by a motion of no confidence against the government. The Amendment has also introduced other significant changes to the Constitution. Those other changes are on the prorogation of parliament, the Prime Minister's resignation for personal reasons and the caretaker government. All these changes have been inspired by the country's constitutional problems since the advent of coalition politics in 2012. The purpose of this commentary is to critique these changes. The paper contends that the changes brought about by the Ninth Amendment can at best be regarded as interim rather than permanent measures, while the long-lasting constitutional reforms are being prepared for the country.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Literature
Anckar D "Westminster Lilliputs? Parliaments in Former Small British Colonies" 2007 Parliamentary Affairs 637-654
Baron DP "Comparative Dynamics of Parliamentary Governments" 1998 Am Polit Sci Rev 593-609
Baruch Y, Sayce S and Gregoriou A "Retirement in a Global Labour Market: A Call for Abolishing the Fixed Retirement Age" 2014 Personnel Review 464-482
Blackburn R "The Dissolution of Parliament: The Crown Prerogatives (House of Commons Control) Bill" 1988 MLR 837-840
Bogdanor V "A Hung Parliament: A Political Problem, Not a Constitutional One" in Brazier A and Kalitowski S (eds) No Overall Control? The Impact of a "Hung Parliament" on British Politics (Hansard Society London 2008) 15-26
Booysen S "The 2015 Parliamentary Elections in Lesotho" 2015 Electoral Studies 430-433
Boston J "Dynamics of Government Formation" in Miller R (ed) New Zealand Government and Politics 5th ed (Oxford University Press Melbourne 2010) 206-225
Boston J et al "Caretaker Government and the Evolution of Caretaker Conventions in New Zealand" 1998 VUW L Rev 629-648
Craig PP "The Supreme Court, Prorogation and Constitutional Principle" 2020 Public Law 248-278
Davis G et al "Rethinking Caretaker Conventions for Australian Governments" 2001 AJPA 11-26
Davison CB "Prorogation: A Powerful Tool Forged by History" 2009 Law Now 13-15
De Smith SA The New Commonwealth and its Constitutions (Stevens London 1964)
De Smith SA "Westminster Export Model the Legal Framework of Responsible Government" 1961 J Commonw Polit Stud 2-16
Harding A "The 'Westminster Model' Constitution Overseas: Transplantation, Adaptation and Development in Commonwealth States" 2004 OUCLJ 143-166
Heard A "The Governor General's Decision to Prorogue Parliament: A Chronology and Assessment" 2009 Constitutional Forum 1-11
Heard A "The Reserve Powers of the Crown: The 2008 Prorogation in Hindsight" in Smith J and Jackson M (eds) The Evolving Canadian Crown (McGill-Queen's University Press Kingston 2012) 87-97
Horgan GW "Partisan-motivated Prorogation and the Westminster Model: A Comparative Perspective" 2014 Commonw Comp Polit 455-472
Keating M "Caretaker Conventions Post Election" 2002 AJPA 119-120
Klein C "The Powers of the Caretaker Government: Are they Really Unlimited?" 1977 Israel L Rev 271-287
Labuschagne BPS and Bekker JMT "Compulsory Retirement and Discrimination on the Grounds of Old Age" 2004 CILSA 40-64
Letsie TW "Lesotho's February 2015 Snap Elections: A Prescription that never Cured the Sickness" 2015 JAE 81-109
Macartney WJ "African Westminster? The Parliament of Lesotho" 1970 Parliamentary Affairs 121-140
Martin L and Stevenson R "Government Formation in Parliamentary Democracies" 2001 Am J Polit Sci 33-50
Matlosa K "Pondering the Culture of Violence in Lesotho: A Case for Demilitarisation" 2020 J Contemp Afr Stud 381-398
Matlosa K and Pule N "The Military in Lesotho" 2001 Afr Secur Rev 62-74
Monahan J Constitutional Law (Irwin Law Toronto 2006)
Newman WJ "Of Dissolution, Prorogation, and Constitutional Law, Principle and Convention: Maintaining Fundamental Distinctions During a Parliamentary Crisis" 2009 NJCL 217-229
Norton P "The Fixed-term Parliaments Act and Votes of Confidence" 2016 Parliamentary Affairs 3-18
'Nyane H "Commentary on the Case of Attorney General v His Majesty the King and Others" 2015 Lesotho LJ 177-188
'Nyane H "Formation of a Government in Lesotho in the Case of a Hung Parliament" 2016 LDD 174-191
'Nyane H "The Advent of Coalition Politics and the Crisis of Constitutionalism in Lesotho" in Thabane M (ed) Towards Anatomy of Political Instability in Lesotho, 1966-2016 (Morija Printing Morija 2017) 77-102
Rasmussen J "Constitutional Aspects of Government Formation in a Hung Parliament" 1987 Parliamentary Affairs 139-153
Russell M and Ruxandra S "The Muddle of the 'Westminster Model': A Concept Stretched Beyond Repair" 2020 Gov Oppos 1-21
Schleiter P and Belu V "Avoiding another 'Squatter in Downing Street' Controversy: The Need to Improve the Caretaker Conventions before the 2015 General Election" 2014 Political Quarterly 454-461
Schleiter P and Belu V "The Challenge of Periods of Caretaker Government in the UK" 2015 Parliamentary Affairs 229-247
Schleiter P and Fleming TG "Parliamentary Prorogation in Comparative Context" 2020 Political Quarterly 641-648
Schleiter P and Sukriti I "Constitutional Rules and Patterns of Government Termination: The Case of the UK Fixed-term Parliaments Act" 2016 Gov Oppos 605-631
Schleiter P, Belu V and Hazell R "Hung Parliaments and the Need for Clearer Rules of Government Formation" 2017 Political Quarterly 404-411
Sejanamane MM "Lesotho's 2015 Elections in the Context of an Ongoing Security Vacuum" 2016 Afr Secur Rev 288-302
Shale S "Re-write or Re-read the Constitution?" Lesotho Times (9 April 2015) 13
Simms M "Westminster Norms and Caretaker Conventions: Australian and New Zealand Transition Debates" in Hart P and Uhr J How Power Changes Hands (Palgrave Macmillan London 2011) 94-107
Southall R "Lesotho" 2017 Africa Yearbook 436-441
Tiernan A and Menzies J Caretaker Conventions in Australasia: Minding the Shop for Government (ANU Press Canberra 2007)
Tremblay G "Limiting the Government's Power to Prorogue Parliament" 2010 Can Parliam Rev 16-17
Twomey A "Changing the Leader: The Constitutional Conventions Concerning the Resignation of Prime Ministers and Premiers" 2011 F L Rev 329-360
Weisfelder RF "Free Elections and Political Instability in Lesotho" 2015 JAE 50-80
Wilson J "The Status of the Caretaker Convention in Canada" 1995 Can Parliam Rev 12-19
Case law
All Basotho Convention v Prime Minister (Constitutional Case No 0006/2020) 2020 LSHCONST 1 (17 April 2020)
Attorney General v His Majesty the King (C of A (CIV) 13/2015; CONS/CASE/02/2015) 2015 LSCA 1 (12 June 2015)
Kananelo Mosito v Director of Public Prosecutions (C of A (CIV) 66/2015) 2016 LSCA 17 (29 April 2016)
Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Ralejoe (LAC/CIV/A/03/2006) 2007 LSLAC 5 (2 February 2007)
Makenete v Lekhanya 1991-1996 LLR 486
Nthabiseng Mokoena v Lesotho Post Bank (Pty) Ltd (LC/80/2013) 2013 LSLC 72 (13 October 2013)
Pekeche v Thabane (CIV/APN/208/98) 1998 LSCA 50 (20 May 1998)
Phoofolo KC v The Right Honourable Prime Minister (C of A (CIV) 17/2017) 2017 LSCA 8 (12 May 2017)
R (on the Application of Miller) (Appellant) v The Prime Minister 2019 UKSC 41
Selloane Mahamo v Nedbank Lesotho Limited (LAC) (unreported) case number LAC/CIV/04/2011 (date unknown)
Thulo v Government Secretary (C of A (CIV) 2/2003) 2003 LSHC 50 (14 April 2003)
Legislation
Constitution of Lesotho, 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Eighth Amendment to the Constitution of Lesotho Act 8 of 2018
First Amendment to the Constitution of Lesotho Act 1 of 1996
Fixed-term Parliaments Act, 2011
Legal Notice 21 of 2020
Ninth Amendment to the Constitution Act 7 of 2020
Internet sources
Kabi P and Motsoeli N 2020 Thabane Resigns, Pledges Support for Majoro http://lestimes.com/thabane-resigns-pledges-support-for-majoro/ accessed 8 August 2020
Lesotho News Agency 2019 National Assembly Adopts Motion to Amend Constitution https://www.gov.ls/national-assembly-adopts-motion-to-amendment-of-constitution/ accessed 3 August 2020
Mohloboli M 2020 Rakuoane Speaks on Constitutional Amendment http://lestimes.com/rakuoane-speaks-on-constitutional-amendment/ accessed 6th August 2020
Mohloboli M 2020 Lesotho's King Assents to Bill Limiting PM Thabane's Powers https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/lesothos-king-assents-to-bill-limiting-pm-thabanes-powers-2020-05-07/ accessed 29 July 2020
Mohloboli M 2021 Majoro must Go: ABC MP https://sundayexpress.co.
ls/majoro-must-go-abc-mp/ accessed 16 March 2021
Mpaki B 2017 What Price Democracy? Counting the Cost of the Upcoming Polls http://lestimes.com/what-price-democracy/ accessed 12 July 2020
Ngatane M 2020 Lesotho Votes for Law Change Stripping PM of Powers to Dissolve Parliament https://ewn.co.za/2020/03/13/lesotho-votes-for-law-change-stripping-pm-of-powers-to-dissolve-parliament/ accessed 6 August 2020
'Nyane H 2020 Lesotho can't Afford Incremental Changes to its Constitution: It Needs a Complete Overhaul https://theconversation.com/lesotho-cant-afford-incremental-changes-to-its-constitution-it-needs-a-complete-overhaul-140747/ accessed 2 August 2020
'Nyane H and Makhobole M 2019 Expert Report on Constitutional Reforms https://www.gov.ls/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/EXPERT-REPORT-OF-CONSTITUTUIONAL-REFORMSFINAL-23-OCT-19.pdf accessed 6 August 2020
Staff Reporter 2012 Lesotho PM Resigns after Losing Outright Majority https//mg.co.za/article/2012-05-30-lesotho-prime-minister-steps-down/ accessed 25 March 2021
Staff Reporter 2020 Thabane Regime Collapses https://lestimes.
com/thabane-regime-collapses/ accessed 29 July 2020
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Hoolo 'Nyane
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}