Realising the Child's Best Interests: Lessons from the Child Justice Act to Improve the South African Schools Act
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2016/v19i0a1228Keywords:
School discipline, child justice, the best interests oof the child, children's rights, education law, restorative justiceAbstract
Although the contexts of school discipline and child justice differ considerably there are a number of contact points and points that overlap. Since the South African Schools Act 84 of 1996 came into operation in 1996, the Constitutional Court has made several pronouncements on the best-interests-of-the-child concept which are not reflected in the provisions regarding school discipline. The Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 came into operation in 2010. This Act provides valuable guidance on how to deal with transgressing children. It is therefore proposed that the Schools Act should draw on the provisions of the Child Justice Act to refine the Schools Act with regard to serious matters of school discipline and to ensure its proper alignment with the constitutional imperatives regarding the best-interests-of-the-child right.
Downloads
References
Literature
Alston 1994 IJLF
Alston P “The Best Interests Principle: Towards a Reconciliation of Culture and Human Rights” 1994 IJLF 1-25
American Psychological Association Zero Tolerance Task Force American Psychologist
American Psychological Association Zero Tolerance Task Force “Are Zero Tolerance Policies Effective in the Schools?” 2008 American Psychologist 852-862
Aull 2012 Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution
Aull EH “Zero-Tolerance, Frivolous Juvenile Court Referrals, and the School-to-Prison Pipeline: Using Arbitration as a Screening-Out Method to Help Plug the Pipeline.” 2012 Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution 179-206
Bekink and Bekink 2004 De Jure
Bekink B and Bekink M “Defining the Standard of the Best Interest of the Child: Modern South African Perspectives” 2004 De Jure 21-40
Bloomenthal 2011 N.Y.U Review of Law & Social Change
Bloomenthal E “Inadequate Discipline: Challenging Zero Tolerance Policies as Violating States Constitutions Education Clauses” 2011 N.Y.U Review of Law & Social Change 303-356
Burton Merchants, Skollies and Stones 2008:28-30
Burton P 2008. Merchants, Skollies and Stones: Experiences of School Violence in South Africa. (Centre for Justice and Crime Prevention Cape Town 2008) Also available at:
http://www.cjcp.org.za/admin/uploads/NSVS-final-internet-ready.pdf
(Retrieved 17/12/2012)
Cassim 2003 CILJSA
Cassim F “The Rights of Child Witnesses Versus the Accused’s Right to Confrontation: A Comparative Perspective. 2003 CILJSA 65-82
Clark, Davis & Booyens 2003 Acta Criminologica
Clark D, Davis L and & Booyens K. “A Silver Era for Victims of Crime: Reassessing the Role That Victim Impact Statements Can Play in Improving Victim Involvement in Criminal Justice Procedures” 2003 Acta Criminologica 43-56
Correspondent The Mercury
Correspondent “Shoe Thief’s Sentence Set Aside.” The Mercury (South Africa) (17 August) 3
Couzens 2010 THRHR
Couzens M “The Best Interests of the Child and Its Collective Connotations in the South African Law” 2010. THRHR 266–287
Davis and Saffy 2004 Acta Criminologica
Davis L and Saffy J Young Witnesses: Experiences of Court Support and Court Preparation Officials. 2004 Acta Criminologica 17-23
DBE 2008-2009 Annual Surveys
Department of Basic Education Report on the 2008 and 2009 Annual Surveys for Ordinary Schools 2010. (Department of Basic Education 2010). Also available at http://www.education.gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=EM0CsHBX%2f8g%3d&tabid= 358&mid=1261 (Retrieved 20/12/2012)
DBE Macro Indicator Trends
Department of Basic Education Macro Indicator Trends in Schooling: Summary Report 2011 http://www.education.gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=2W%2fLLyKAfNA%3d&tabid= 358&mid=126 (Retrieved 20/12/2012)
DBE Annual National Assessments of 2011
Department of Basic Education Report on the Annual National Assessments of 2011. 2011. (Department of Basic Education). Also available at http://www.education.gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=1U5igeVjiqg%3d&tabid=358& mid=1325 (Retrieved 20/12/2012)
DBE 2009-2010 Annual Surveys
Department of Basic Education: Report on the 2009/2010 Annual Surveys for Ordinary Schools. 2012. (Department of Basic Education) Also available at: http://www.education.gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=%2b5BphKZWqLA%3d&tabid =358&mid=1261 (Retrieved 20/12/2012)
De Wet C 2003 SAJE
De Wet C “Misdaad in die Suid-Afrikaanse Onderwys Soos Weerspieël in die Gedrukte Media.” 2003 SAJE 113-121
De Wet C 2003a SAJE
De Wet C “Skoolveiligheid en Misdaadbekamping: Die Sieninge van ’n Groep Vrystaatse Leerders en Opvoeders.” 2003a SAJE 85-93
De Wet C 2003b SAJE
De Wet C “Free State Educators’ Perceptions of the Scope of Learner Crime.” 2003b SAJE 168-175
Erasmus 2010 SA Public Law
Erasmus D ““There Is Something You Are Missing; What About the Children?” Separating the Rights of Children from Those of Their Caregivers.” 2010 SA Public Law 124-136
Ferreira 2010THRHR
Ferreira S “The Best Interests of the Child: From Complete Indeterminacy to Guidance by the Children’s Act” THRHR 201-213
Freeman M Commentary
Freeman A Commentary on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Article 3. The Best Interests of the Child. (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers Leiden 2007)
Gonzalez 2011 UC Davis Journal of Juvenile Law & Policy
Gonzalez T “Restoring Justice. Community Organizing to Transform School Discipline Policies.” 2011. UC Davis Journal of Juvenile Law & Policy 2-36
Heaton 1990 THRHR
Heaton J “Some General Remarks on the Concept “Best Interests of the Child”. 1990 THRHR 95-99
Hollely 2002 CARSA
Hollely K “Children in Court: The Role and Scope of the Support Person.” CARSA 2002 14-18.
Hopkins 2002 SFL
Hopkins B “Restorative Justice in Schools.” SFL 144-149.
Joubert & Prinsloo Law of Education
Joubert HJ and Prinsloo S The Law of Education in South Africa. 2nd ed. (Van Schaik Pretoria 2008)
Karlsson 2002 CE 332
Karlsson J “The Role of Democratic Governing Bodies in South African Schools.” 2002 CE 327-336
Le Roux and Mokhele 2011 Africa Education Review
Le Roux CS and Mokhele PR “The Persistence of Violence in South Africa’s Schools: In Search of Solutions” 2011 Africa Education Review 318-335.
Lopatka 1996 Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems
Lopatka A “An Introduction to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child” 1996 Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems 251-262
Louw 2004a CARSA
Louw AE “Die Bevoegdheid van Kinders as Getuies I: Die Rol van Ouderdom en Ontwikkelingsvlak in Geheue” 2004a CARSA 3-15
Louw 2004b CARSA
Louw AE “Die Bevoegdheid van Kinders as Getuies II: Die Rol van Sosiaal-emosionele Kontekste in Geheue” 2004b CARSA 16-24
Louw 2005a CARSA
Louw AE “Die Bevoegdheid van Kinders as Getuies: Die Rol van Taalvaardigheid.’’ 2005a CARSA 19-28.
Louw 2005b CARSA
Louw AE “Die Bevoegdheid van Kinders as Getuies: Die Rol van Kognitiewe Faktore in die Vatbaarheid vir Suggestie” 2005b CARSA 18-27
Maphosa and Mammen 2011 Anthropologist
Maphosa C and Mammen KJ “How Chaotic and Unmanageable Classrooms Have Become: Insights into Prevalent Forms of Learner Indiscipline in South African Schools. “ 2011 Anthropologist 185-193.
Mashau, Steyn, Van der Walt and Wolhuter 2008 SAJE 415.
Mashau S, Steyn ES, Van der Walt J and Wolhuter “Support Services Perceived Necessary for Learner Relationships by Limpopo Educators.” 2008 SAJE 415-430
Minister of Basic Education Internal Question Paper
Minister of Basic Education Internal Question Paper 17/2014 to the National Assembly published on 19 September 2014.
Müller 2003 CARSA 2-9
Müller “The Enigma of the Child Witness: A Need for Expert Evidence” 2003 CARSA 2-9
Reyneke Best interests of the child
Reyneke JM The best interests of the child in school discipline in South Africa (PhD thesis Tilburg University 2013)
Reyneke & Kruger 2006 JJS 87-89.
Reyneke JM and Kruger HB “Sexual Offences Courts: Better Justice for Children?” 2006 JJS 73 -107.
Ofer 2011 New York Law School Law Review
Ofer U “Criminalizing the Classroom: The Rise of Aggressive Policing and Zero Tolerance Discipline in New York City Public Schools.” 2011 New York Law School Law Review 1374-1411
Van Bueren “United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child”
Van Bueren G “United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: An Evolutionary Revolution” in CJ Davel (ed) Introduction to Child Law in South Africa: (Juta Law Lansdowne 2000)
Visser 2007 THRHR
Visser PJ “Some Ideas on the “Best interests of a Child” Principle in the Context of Public Schooling” 2007. THRHR 459-469
Van Wyk 2004 SAJE
Van Wyk N “School Governing Bodies: The Experiences of South African Educators.” 2004 SAJE 49-54
Wolhuter and Van Staden 2008 TG
Wolhuter CC and Van Staden JG. “Bestaan daar ’n Dissiplinekrisis binne Suid-Afrikaanse Skole? Belewenis van Opvoeders.” 2008 TG 389-398
Case law
Centre for Child Law v Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development and Others 2009 (6) SA 632 (CC); 2009 (2) SACR 477 (CC); 2009 (11) BCLR 1105 (CC)
Dayimani v S [2006] JOL 17745 (E)
Director of Public Prosecutions, Transvaal v Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development and Others 2009 (2) SACR 130 (CC); 2009 (4) SA 222 (CC)
Klink v Regional Court Magistrate NO and Others 1996 (3) BCLR 402 (SE)
Motaung v S [2005] JOL 16071 (SE)
Ndokwane v S [2011] JOL 27316 (KZP)
Roper, Superintendent, Patosi Correctional Center v Simmons 543 US 551 (2005)
Sonderup v Tondelli and Another 2001 (1) SA 1171 (CC)
Stefaans v S [1999] 1 All SA 191 (C)
S v Francke [1999] JOL 4451 (C)
S v Hartnick [2001] JOL 8576 (C)
S v M (Centre for Child Law as Amicus Curiae) 2008 (3) SA 232 (CC); 2007 (2) SACR 539 (CC)
S v Malatji [2005] JOL 15716 (T)
S v Mathebula [1996] 4 All SA 168 (T)
S v Mokoena 2008 (5) SA 578 (T)
S v Nagel [1998] JOL 4098 (T)
S v T 2000 (2) SACR 658 (Ck)
Van Rooyen v S [2006] JOL 16675 (W)
Welkom High School and Another v Head, Department of Education, Free State Province, and Another 2011 (4) SA 531 (FB)
Legislation
Child Justice Act 75 of 2008
Children’s Act 38 of 2005.
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
South African Schools Act 84 of 1996
Government publications
GN R1374 in GG 15024 of 30 July 1993.
GN 2433 in GG 19377 of 19 October 1998.
Internet source
SAHRC 2008. Report of the Public Hearing on School-based Violence. http://www.sahrc.org.za/home/index.php?ipkContentID=15&ipkMenuID=19 accessed on 2 July 2012
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2016 Mariette (JM) Reyneke
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}