Limitation of Socio-Economic Rights in the 2010 Kenyan Constitution: A Proposal for the Adoption of a Proportionality Approach in the Judicial Adjudication of Socio-Economic Rights Disputes
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2013/v16i5a2433Keywords:
2010 Kenyan Constitution, Kenya, Socio-economic rights, Limitation of rights, Internal limitations, Proportionality approach, Transformation.Abstract
On 27 August 2010 Kenya adopted a transformative Constitution with the objective of fighting poverty and inequality as well as improving the standards of living of all people in Kenya. One of the mechanisms in the 2010 Constitution aimed at achieving this egalitarian transformation is the entrenchment of justiciable socio-economic rights (SERs), an integral part of the Bill of Rights. The entrenched SERs require the State to put in place a legislative, policy and programmatic framework to enhance the realisation of its constitutional obligations to respect, protect and fulfill these rights for all Kenyans. These SER obligations, just like any other fundamental human rights obligations, are, however, not absolute and are subject to legitimate limitation by the State. Two approaches have been used in international and comparative national law jurisprudence to limit SERs: the proportionality approach, using a general limitation clause that has found application in international and regional jurisprudence on the one hand; and the reasonableness approach, using internal limitations contained in the standard of progressive realisation, an approach that has found application in the SER jurisprudence of the South African Courts, on the other hand. This article proposes that if the entrenched SERs are to achieve their transformative objectives, Kenyan courts must adopt a proportionality approach in the judicial adjudication of SER disputes. This proposal is based on the reasoning that for the entrenched SERs to have a substantive positive impact on the lives of the Kenyan people, any measure by the government aimed at their limitation must be subjected to strict scrutiny by the courts, a form of scrutiny that can be achieved only by using the proportionality standard entrenched in the article 24 general limitation clause.
Downloads
References
Bibliography
Albertyn and Goldblatt 1998 SAJHR
Albertyn C and Goldblatt B "Facing the challenge of transformation: Difficulties in the development of an indigenous jurisprudence of equality" 1998 SAJHR 248-276
Alston and Quinn 1987 Hum Rts Q
Alston P and Quinn G "The nature and scope of state parties obligations under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights" 1987 Hum Rts Q 156-229
Bilchitz Poverty and Fundamental Rights
Bilchitz D Poverty and Fundamental Rights: The Justification and Enforcement of Socio-economic Rights (Oxford University Press Oxford 2007)
Brand Courts, Socio-economic Rights and Transformative Politics
Brand JFD Courts, Socio-economic Rights and Transformative Politics (LLD-thesis US 2009)
Chapman 1996 Hum Rts Q
Chapman AR "A 'violations approach' for monitoring the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights" 1996 Hum Rts Q 23-66
Cheadle "Limitation of Rights"
Cheadle H "Limitation of Rights" in Cheadle H, Davis DM and Haysom N (eds) South African Constitutional Law: The Bill of Rights (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2002) chapter 30
Craven International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
Craven M The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: A Perspective on its Development (Clarendon Press Oxford 1998)
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)
Davis 2006 SAJHR
Davis DM "Adjudicating the socio-economic rights in the South African Constitution: Towards 'deference lite'?" 2006 SAJHR 301-327
De Schutter International Human Rights Law
De Schutter O International Human Rights Law: Cases, Materials, Commentary (Cambridge University Press New York 2010)
De Vos 1997 SAJHR
De Vos P "Pious wishes or directly enforceable human rights? Social and economic rights in South Africa's 1996 Constitution" 1997 SAJHR 67-?
Eide "Economic, Social and Cultural Rights"
Eide A "Economic, Social and Cultural Rights as Human Rights" in Eide A, Krause C and Rosas A (eds) Economic and Social Rights: A Textbook 2nd ed (Martinus Nijhoff Dordrecht 2001) 9-28
Heyns and Brand 1998 LDD
Heyns C and Brand JFD "Introduction to socio-economic rights in the South African Constitution" 1998 LDD 153-167
Iles 2004 SAJHR
Iles K "Limiting socio-economic rights: Beyond the internal limitation clauses" 2004 SAJHR 448-465
Klare 1998 SAJHR
Klare K "Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188
Liebenberg "Violations of Socio-economic Rights"
Liebenberg S "Violations of Socio-economic Rights: The Role of the South African Human Rights Commission" in Andrews P and Ellmann S (eds) The Post-apartheid Constitutions: Perspectives on South Africa's Basic Law (Witwatersrand University Press Johannesburg 2001)
Liebenberg Socio-economic Rights Adjudication
Liebenberg S Socio-economic Rights Adjudication under a Transformative Constitution (Juta Cape Town 2010)
Mutakha-Kangu 2008 LSKJ
Mutakha-Kangu J "The theory and design of limitation of fundamental rights and freedoms" 2008 LSKJ (Page numbers not available. Source on file with
author).
Orago 2013a AHRLJ
Orago NW "The 2010 Kenyan Constitution and the hierarchical place of international law in the Kenyan domestic legal system: A comparative perspective" 2013 AHRLJ (forthcoming)
Orago 2013b AHRLJ
Orago NW "The place of the 'minimum core approach' in the realisation of the entrenched socio-economic rights in the 2010 Kenyan Constitution" 2013 AHRLJ (forthcoming)
Ouguergouz African Charter
Ouguergouz F The African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights: A Comprehensive Agenda for Human Dignity and Sustainable Democracy in Africa (Martinus Nijhoff Leiden 2003)
Pati 2005 Berkeley J Int'l L
Pati R "Rights and their limits: The constitution for Europe in international and comparative legal perspective" 2005 Berkeley J Int'l L 223-380
Pieterse 2003 SALJ
Pieterse M "Towards a useful role for section 36 of the Constitution in social rights cases? Residents of Bon Vista Mansions v Southern Metropolitan Local Council" 2003 SALJ 41-48
Sepulveda Nature of Obligations
Sepulveda M The Nature of the Obligations under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Intersentia Antwerpen 2003)
Sseyonjo Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
Sseyonjo M Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in International Law (Hart Portland 2009)
Stewart 2010 PSILR
Stewart L "Adjudicating socio-economic rights under a transformative constitution" 2009-2010 PSILR 487-512
Viljoen International Human Rights Law
Viljoen F International Human Rights Law in Africa (Oxford University Press New York 2007)
Viljoen "Justiciability of Socio-economic and Cultural Rights"
Viljoen F "The Justiciability of Socio-economic and Cultural Rights: Experience and Problems" In Donders Y and Volodin V (eds) Human Rights in Education, Science, and Culture: Legal Developments and Challenges 53 (Ashgate Aldershot 2007) 53-111
Warren 1962 USAFJAGB
Warren E "The Bill of Rights and the military" 1962 USAFJAGB 4(3) 6-?
Woolman 1997 SAJHR
Woolman S "Out of order? Out of balance? The limitation clause of the final Constitution" 1997 SAJHR 102-134
Woolman and Botha "Limitations"
Woolman S and Botha H "Limitations: Shared Constitutional Interpretation, an Appropriate Normative Framework and Hard Choices" in Woolman S and Bishop M (eds) Constitutional Conversations (Pretoria University Law Press Pretoria 2008)
Register of case law
Canada
R v Oakes 1986 26 DLR (4th) 200
Kenya
Changanlal v Kericho Urban District Council 1965 EA 370
Ibrahim Songor Osman v Attorney General High Court Constitutional Petition No 2 of 2011
In the Matter of the Principle of Gender Representation in the National Assembly and the Senate Supreme Court of Kenya, Advisory Opinion Application 2 of 2012
John Kabui Mwai v Kenya National Examination Council High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Petition No 15 of 2011
Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v Attorney General High Court of Kenya at Nairobi Petition No 164 of 2011
Okwanda v The Minister of Health and Medical Services High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Petition No 94 of 2012
Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance v Attorney General High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Petition No 229 of 2012
South Africa
Dawood v Minister of Home Affairs; Shalabi v Minister of Home Affairs; Thomas v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 3 SA 930 (CC)
De Reuck v Director of Public Prosecution (Witwatersrand Local Division) 2002 12 BCLR 1285 (CC)
Ferreira v Levin, and Vryenhoek v Powell 1996 1 BCLR 1 (CC)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Jaftha v Schoeman 2005 2 SA 140 (CC)
Khosa v Minister of Social Development, Mahlaule v Minister of Social Development 2004 6 SA 505 (CC)
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign (No 1) 2002 5 SA 703 (CC)
Moise v Transitional Local Council of Greater Germiston 2001 4 SA 491 (CC)
Rail Commuters Action Group v Transnet Ltd t/a Metrorail 2005 2 SA 359 (CC)
Re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa (First Certification case) 1996 1 BCLR 1253 (CC)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
S v Mamela 2000 3 SA 1 (CC)
S v Zuma 1995 2 SA 642 (CC)
International and regional
African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights
Amnesty International v Zambia 2000 AHRLR 325 (ACHPR 1999)
Interights v Mauritania 2004 AHRLR 87 (ACHPR 2004)
Media Rights Agenda v Nigeria 2000 AHRLR 200 (ACHPR 1998)
Prince v South Africa 2004 AHRLR 105 (ACHPR 2004)
Social and Economic Rights Action Centre (SERAC) v Nigeria 2001 AHRLR 60 (ACHPR 2001)
European Court of Human Rights
The Observer and the Guardian v The United Kingdom Application No 13585/88, Judgement of 26 November 1991
Open Door and Dublin Well Woman v Ireland 64/1991/316/387-388, 23 September 1992
Inter-American Court of Human Rights
The Word "Laws" in Article 30 of the American Convention on Human Rights Advisory Opinion OC-6/86, May 9, 1986, Inter-Am Ct HR (Ser A) No 6 (1986)
Register of legislation
Constitution of Kenya, 1963
Constitution of Kenya, 2010
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
German Basic Law. 1949
Water Services Act 108 of 1997
Register of international instruments and documentation
African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (1981)
African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (1990)
CCPR General Comment No 27 (1999)
CESCR General Comment No 3 (1990)
CESCR General Comment No 4 (1991)
CESCR General Comment No 9 (1998)
CESCR General Comment No 13 (1999)
CESCR General Comment No 14 (2002)
CESCR General Comment No 15 (2002)
CESCR General Comment No 16 (2005)
CESCR General Comment No 17 (2005)
CESCR General Comment No 18 (2006)
CESCR General Comment No 19 (2008)
CESCR General Comment No 20 (2009)
CESCR General Comment No 21 (2009)
Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979) (CEDAW)
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2006) (UNCRPD)
Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989) (CRC)
ILO Abolition of Forced Labour Convention (1957) (No 105)
ILO Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention (1958) (No 111)
ILO Equal Remuneration Convention (1951) (No 100)
ILO Forced Labour Convention (1930) (No 29)
ILO Minimum Age Convention (1973) (No 138)
ILO Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention (1949) (No 98)
ILO Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention (1999) (No 182)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966) (ICESCR)
Limburg Principles on the Implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1987)
Maastricht Guidelines on Violations of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1997)
Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa (2003)
Register of internet sources
CESCR 2007 tbinternet.ohchr.org
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 2007 An Evaluation of the Obligation to Take Steps 'to the Maximum of the Available Resources' under an Optional Protocol to the Covenant tbinternet.ohchr.org/
_layouts/treatybodyexterna [date of use 1 Aug 2013]
Chenwi 2010 www.spii.org.za
Chenwi L 2010 Monitoring the Progressive Realisation of Socio-economic Rights: Lessons from the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the South African Constitutional Court www.spii.org.za/agentfiles/434/file/Progressive%20realisation%20Research%20paper1.pdf [date of use 10 Sep 2013]
ECOSOC 1985 www.uio.no
United National Economic and Social Council 1985 Siracusa Principles on the Limitation and Derogation of Provisions in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Annex, UN Doc E/CN.4/1984/4 www.uio.no/studier/emner/jus/humanrights [date of use 18 May 2013]
Eide Date Unknown www.fao.org
Eide A Date Unknown The Human Right to Adequate Food and Freedom from Hunger www.fao.org/docrep/W9990E/w9990e03.htm [date of use 2 Jul 2013]
FAO 2004 www.fao.org
Food and Agricultural Organisation of the United Nations 2004 Voluntary Guidelines for the Progressive Realisation of the Right to Adequate Food in the Context of National Food Security www.fao.org/docrep/meeting/008/
J3345e/j3345e01.htm [date of use 10 Sep 2013]
ICHRP 2003.ichrp.org
International Council on Human Rights Policy 2003 Duties sans Frontieres: Human Rights and Global Social Justice www.ichrp.org/files/
reports/43/108_report_en.pdf [date of use 22 Feb 2013]
ILO Date Unknown www.ilo.org
International Labour Organisation Date Unknown Ratification www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=1000:11200:1445709296871334::NO:11200:P11200 [date of use 8 May 2013]
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2017 Nicholas Wasonga Orago
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}